The Mentalist
The Mentalist is a compelling American crime drama series that ran for seven seasons, centering on the enigmatic Patrick Jane, a former celebrity psychic who now works as an independent consultant for the California Bureau of Investigation (CBI). Driven by a personal vendetta against the serial killer Red John, who murdered his wife and daughter, Jane uses his acute powers of observation, deduction, and manipulation to solve complex crimes. The show explores themes of justice, revenge, morality, and the human psyche, often presenting gruesome crime scenes and psychological tension. While the series offers a procedural format, a overarching narrative follows Jane's relentless pursuit of Red John. Aimed at a mature audience, the content includes intense violence, mature sexual themes, and strong language.
Concerns
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
HighThe series includes clear instances of LGBTQ representation, portraying gay characters and drag queens in a positive light, with their identities affirmed by the main protagonists. There are also mentions of characters having same-sex partners, integrated into the narrative without being the central focus of the mystery.
In Season 4, Episode 21, 'Ruby Slippers,' the CBI investigates a case involving a gay man named Archie, whose homosexuality is affirmed by Patrick Jane and the team. The episode also features 'female impersonators' (drag queens) who are presented positively, with the character Glenn/Glenda receiving a GLAAD Media Award nomination for positive portrayal. Furthermore, casual references to characters having a 'man's husband' or a 'woman's girlfriend' have been noted, indicating incidental but present same-sex relationships within the show.
Violence
HighThe show consistently features graphic and intense violence, often depicting brutal murders, physical assaults, and disturbing crime scene imagery. The central premise of the series is rooted in a brutal act of violence, driving the protagonist's actions.
The catalyst for the entire series is the brutal murder of Patrick Jane's wife and young daughter by the serial killer Red John. Viewers encounter graphic descriptions and visuals, such as a killer smashing a weapon on a man's head and jamming it into his body (off-screen) and scenes showing a severed, charred foot or a man with grotesquely missing skin. An unsettling scene describes a construction site manager pressing a decomposing human nose protruding from concrete, resulting in a 'little squelch'.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe series contains frequently scary and intense content due to its crime drama nature. This includes graphic depictions of death, suspenseful situations, and psychologically disturbing elements related to serial killers.
The show's core revolves around Patrick Jane's vengeful hunt for Red John, a serial killer responsible for the brutal murders of his family, which creates an ongoing intense and dark atmosphere. Disturbing imagery includes a scene where a construction site manager presses a decomposing human nose sticking out of concrete, producing a 'squelch' sound. Another character, Lorelei Martins, is depicted as torturing and killing people for Red John without remorse, showcasing extreme villainy.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe series includes elements of romance and sexual content, featuring implied sexual activity, mild suggestive language, and discussions of mature sexual themes. There are instances of nudity and references to sensitive topics such as rape.
The show contains scenes with nudity and implied sex, and discussions around mature topics like rape are part of its narrative. Mild sexual allusions are present, and a character, Teresa, reveals her bra before dressing. A significant romantic subplot develops between Patrick Jane and Teresa Lisbon, evolving from a combative friendship to a more intimate relationship in later seasons.
Profanity
MediumProfanity is present throughout the series, with moderate use of common curse words and occasional stronger language. Misuse of religious exclamations also occurs.
In various episodes, mild curse words like 'd---n' (twice), 'h---' (five or six times), and 'a---' (once) are heard. Stronger terms such as 'b---ch' and 'b---tard' are also used by characters, alongside a few instances of misusing God's name.
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumWhile the protagonist, Patrick Jane, actively debunks supernatural claims, the series incorporates occult themes through characters' beliefs and antagonist-related cult practices. These elements provide plot devices rather than endorsing actual supernatural abilities.
Grace Van Pelt explicitly expresses belief in psychics, talking to dead people, and an afterlife, stating in Season 1, 'The Kingdom of God is a real place Mr. Jane,' and is considered by some to believe in occultism. The antagonist Red John is associated with a cult, 'Visualize,' which features activities described as 'religious/satanistic ceremony' and its followers display red tattoos interpreted as the 'mark of the beast.'
Substance Use
MediumThe show depicts substance use, including alcohol consumption and mentions of drug addiction. It also addresses the severe consequences of drug abuse, such as hallucinations.
The narrative includes mature topics like addiction to painkillers and hallucinations induced by drugs. An FBI officer's past struggles with drug addiction are revealed. Characters are seen casually drinking alcohol, such as consuming a glass of whiskey or being served champagne. A character mentions the inability to drink due to medication interactions, highlighting consequences of substance use.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe protagonist, Patrick Jane, frequently exhibits disrespect for rules and authority, employing manipulative and deceptive tactics. While often directed at criminals, his methods showcase a rebellious and ethically flexible approach to law enforcement.
Patrick Jane, as an ex-charlatan, is known for his willingness to 'lie, cheat or pick a man's pocket to solve a case,' and the show often portrays his ethical relativism. His past as a fake psychic involved 'lying to and manipulating vulnerable people for his own financial gain and hubris,' demonstrating a pattern of disrespectful and rebellious behavior against societal norms.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumThe series presents a protagonist who is an atheist and often pragmatic, contrasting with explicitly Christian characters within the team. While faith is present, the show also positively affirms LGBTQ identities, which may conflict with some traditional Christian worldviews. Antagonistic elements also co-opt religious imagery.
Patrick Jane is portrayed as an atheist, rejecting superstition and higher powers, and explicitly states 'there's no such thing as psychics.' His pragmatic and sometimes nihilistic views, such as stating 'No such thing as right and wrong' in Season 5, stand in contrast to Teresa Lisbon's overt Christian faith. In Season 4, Episode 21 ('Ruby Slippers'), the show's positive affirmation of a gay character and drag queens, where those opposing these identities are presented negatively, was seen by a Christian reviewer as problematic and anti-Christian.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
TV-14, recommended for viewers aged 14 and older. The series consistently features mature themes including graphic violence, implied sexual content, discussions of rape and addiction, and moderate language. The psychological intensity, coupled with the often dark nature of the crimes investigated, warrants this rating.
Additional Notes
The show's narrative is heavily character-driven, particularly by Patrick Jane's quest for revenge, which shapes the tone and moral ambiguities presented. The episodic nature often involves solving individual crimes, but the overarching 'Red John' storyline provides deep psychological and intense content that escalates across seasons. Viewers should be prepared for a consistent level of mature content and ethical dilemmas.
Related Reviews
Is The Mentalist right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required