StoryScanner
Start free

13 Reasons Why

Here's what we found in 13 Reasons Why. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family
General Review

Parent's Guide to 13 Reasons Why

13 Reasons Why is an American teen drama television series developed by Brian Yorkey, based on Jay Asher's 2007 novel. The series, which aired for four seasons on Netflix, centers on the students of Liberty High School and explores a wide range of intense social issues affecting modern youth. The initial season follows Clay Jensen as he uncovers the reasons behind his classmate Hannah Baker's suicide through a series of cassette tapes she left behind, detailing her perspective on the individuals and events that contributed to her decision. Subsequent seasons expand on the aftermath of Hannah's death, focusing on themes of sexual assault, bullying, mental health, and the justice system within the high school community. While aiming to stimulate conversation around taboo topics, the show has generated significant controversy for its graphic depictions of mature content, leading to the addition of viewer warning cards and edits to specific scenes.

Things to Consider

High7

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

The series prominently features LGBTQ+ characters and storylines, exploring themes of coming out, internalized homophobia, and same-sex relationships. Creator Brian Yorkey is openly gay, contributing to the representation, which evolves and intensifies across seasons. While aiming for diversity, some portrayals have been criticized for adhering to stereotypes or for problematic plotlines.

Monty de la Cruz, a closeted gay character, violently assaults Winston Williams after they share a kiss, illustrating internalized homophobia and violence. Monty later has sex with Winston, further complicating his struggle with his sexuality. In Season 4, main character Alex Standall explores his bisexuality, entering a relationship with Charlie St. George, who also identifies as bisexual. This season also controversially features Justin Foley's death from AIDS, a plotline criticized for potentially perpetuating stigma around HIV/AIDS and its connection to substance abuse and sex work.

Violence

13 Reasons Why contains frequent and graphic depictions of violence, encompassing self-harm, sexual assault, and physical aggression, which are central to the plot across multiple seasons. The intensity and explicit nature of these scenes have been a major point of controversy.

Romance and Sexual Content

The series contains extensive and often graphic sexual content, particularly focusing on sexual violence and non-consensual acts. It includes explicit scenes of sexual assault, discussions of sexual activity, and instances of nudity, especially among teenage characters.

Profanity

The show features a high frequency of strong language and profanity throughout its run, consistent with its mature themes and depiction of realistic teenage dialogue in stressful situations. The use of expletives is pervasive rather than occasional.

Substance Use

Substance use, including both alcohol and illegal drugs, is a recurring and prominent theme within the series, depicted frequently among the high school characters. The show portrays both casual use and the serious consequences of addiction.

Scary & Intense Content

The series is characterized by its consistently intense and often frightening content, including graphic imagery and psychologically disturbing themes. The overall tone can be described as a psychological thriller, with elements designed to evoke distress and fear, particularly related to the traumatic experiences of the characters.

Disrespect & Rebellion

Disrespect and rebellion against authority figures, including parents, teachers, and school administrators, are central and recurring themes throughout the series. Teenagers frequently defy rules and express disdain for adult institutions, often driven by perceived failures of the adult world to protect or support them.

Would these 7 concerns matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium1
Anti-Christian Themes
Low1
Witchcraft & Occult
Medium1

Anti-Christian Themes

While not explicitly anti-Christian in its direct messaging or plot, the series has drawn criticism from some Christian groups who perceived its portrayal of suicide and revenge as potentially glorifying or validating actions contrary to Christian teachings. The show explores themes like forgiveness and consequence, but the overall moral framework may conflict with specific Christian values for some viewers.

Low1

Witchcraft & Occult

There is no significant presence of witchcraft or occult themes within '13 Reasons Why'. The narrative focuses on realistic social issues, mental health, and crime, rather than supernatural or magical elements.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

From a Christian worldview, "13 Reasons Why" presents a complex and often challenging landscape of adolescent issues, frequently at odds with biblical values while also providing opportunities for critical discussion. The core themes of the destructive power of selfishness, the interconnectedness of actions and their repercussions, bullying, and sexual assault are tragically depicted. While the show aims to foster conversation about these difficult topics, its portrayal of suicide as a means of 'revenge' or 'punishing others' directly contradicts a Christian understanding of life's sanctity and God's sovereignty over life and death, which offers hope even in suffering. The narrative often lacks clear moral accountability for vice, particularly in early seasons where characters like Bryce Walker initially evade justice, suggesting that privilege can shield individuals from consequences. While some characters later face legal repercussions or attempt 'redemption arcs,' these are often debated and not universally seen as fully realized moral transformations from a Christian perspective, which emphasizes genuine repentance and reconciliation. The worldview presented in "13 Reasons Why" leans heavily towards a relativistic and at times fatalistic perspective, where characters often struggle with a sense of hopelessness and lack of ultimate meaning beyond their immediate circumstances. There is a pronounced absence of transcendent hope or overt faith representation, with spiritual elements surrounding suicide, such as identity and truth, largely unaddressed from a biblical standpoint. Redemption themes, such as sacrifice, forgiveness, or grace, are notably scarce within Hannah's initial narrative, which is largely driven by blame and retribution rather than a path to healing or reconciliation. Later seasons attempt to explore healing and taking care of each other, yet this often occurs within a secular framework. Family values are generally portrayed as strained or absent, with parents often depicted as oblivious, ineffectual, or preoccupied, failing to recognize or adequately address their children's deep struggles. This depiction of parental obliviousness stands in contrast to the biblical emphasis on parental guidance, vigilance, and the importance of family support. While the show can serve as a catalyst for parents to discuss critical issues with their children, the content itself does not offer a robust, faith-based framework for navigating these challenges.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

Not recommended for viewers under 17, and extreme caution is advised for anyone under 16, even with parental guidance. The series carries a TV-MA rating due to its graphic and mature themes, including suicide, sexual assault, drug use, and strong language. Mental health professionals have raised concerns about its content, particularly for vulnerable young adults. If watched, it should be accompanied by open and thorough discussions with a trusted adult to process the difficult topics presented.

Good to Know

The series deals with highly sensitive and potentially triggering content, including detailed depictions of suicide, sexual assault, and mental health crises. Netflix added prominent warning cards before each season and specific graphic content warnings before individual episodes. The original graphic suicide scene in Season 1 was edited out by Netflix in 2019 due to advice from mental health experts. Parental discretion and active co-viewing with discussion are strongly recommended due to the graphic nature and complex moral dilemmas presented.

How does this review compare?

This review
  • 9 standard concerns
  • General sensitivity level
  • One-size-fits-all perspective
Your report
  • Concerns you choose
  • Sensitivity levels you set
  • Tailored to your family

What are you watching next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly
Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families