The Guilty
The Guilty refers to two crime thriller films: the 2018 Danish original "Den Skyldige" and its 2021 American remake. Both films center on a demoted police officer working as a 911 dispatcher who receives a frantic call from an abducted woman. The narrative unfolds almost entirely through telephone conversations, creating a highly suspenseful and claustrophobic atmosphere as the protagonist attempts to piece together clues and guide a rescue. The American adaptation, starring Jake Gyllenhaal, maintains the intense thriller genre while expanding on the protagonist's personal struggles, including his family life and a looming court hearing. The films are psychological dramas that explore themes of judgment, redemption, and the nature of truth. Due to mature and disturbing themes, intense psychological content, and strong language, these films are generally recommended for older teenage and adult audiences.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe films feature significant references to and descriptions of intense violence, including assaults, a shooting, and infanticide, though almost none of these acts are depicted visually on-screen. The impact comes from the graphic verbal descriptions and the protagonist's reactions to these disturbing details.
1. In the 2021 American remake, the 911 operator Joe Baylor learns of the graphic act of infanticide, where the caller Emily Lighton reveals she has harmed her baby, Oliver, believing there were 'snakes in his belly.' This revelation drives a significant portion of the film's tension and Joe's emotional distress. 2. Both the 2018 Danish original and the 2021 American remake involve the protagonist, Asger Holm (2018) or Joe Baylor (2021), facing an internal investigation for a past shooting incident where they used deadly force, leading to a death. This off-screen violence is central to their character's psychological state and motivation.
Profanity
HighBoth films feature frequent and strong profanity, with the 2021 American remake notably containing a high number of extreme curse words, including numerous 'f-bombs' and other scatological and religiously-tinged expletives. This pervasive language contributes significantly to the film's R-rating.
1. The 2021 American film, according to one review, contains "61 extreme profanities, 14 scatological terms, and frequent use of terms of deity." This includes "many 'f' words and many profanities" throughout the dialogue, often spoken by the protagonist, Joe Baylor, in moments of frustration or anger. 2. Common Sense Media notes that the 2021 film includes "frequent f-bombs, s-words, and other crude talks" in the dialogue, reflecting the intense and stressful environment of the 911 call center.
Scary & Intense Content
HighBoth films are characterized by high psychological intensity and suspense, with a constant sense of dread and urgency. While graphic violence is mostly implied rather than shown, the verbal descriptions of disturbing events, coupled with the protagonist's emotional breakdown, create a profoundly unsettling and frightening experience.
1. The entire premise of both films places the audience in a state of high tension as the protagonist, Joe Baylor (2021) or Asger Holm (2018), frantically works against time to save a kidnapped woman, Emily Lighton (2021) or Iben (2018), whose desperate situation is conveyed through her whispered phone calls from a moving vehicle. The limited visual scope (confined to the 911 center) intensifies the psychological pressure. 2. The discovery that the kidnapped woman, Emily, is not a victim of abduction by her ex-husband but rather the perpetrator of violence against her own child, Oliver (implied infanticide in the 2021 film), serves as a major, shocking twist that contributes to the film's intensely disturbing nature and Joe's subsequent emotional collapse.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe films contain minimal explicit sexual content but do include references to mature sexual themes, particularly prostitution. Romantic elements are subdued, focusing more on implied relationships and familial separation as background to the protagonist's emotional state.
1. In the 2021 American remake, Joe Baylor, while on 911 duty, argues with a caller who reports being robbed by a prostitute on Bunker Hill, indicating a reference to commercial sex work. 2. The American remake introduces Joe Baylor's separation from his wife, Jess Baylor (voiced by Gillian Zinser), and his daughter, Abby. While not explicit romance, the implied marital issues and Joe's attempts to connect with his family provide a background of romantic and familial strife.
Substance Use
MediumThe films include references to substance use, specifically alcohol and methamphetamine, though no on-screen depiction of their consumption or effects. These references serve to contextualize callers' situations or the environment the protagonist operates within.
1. In the 2021 American remake, the protagonist Joe Baylor scolds a caller for taking drugs, which implies drug use is a prevalent issue among some of the individuals calling 911. 2. Reviews for the 2021 film explicitly state there are "references to drinking and methamphetamine with no on-screen appearance or use," indicating that substance use is discussed as part of the criminal or social context.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe protagonist, a demoted police officer, frequently displays disrespect and a rebellious attitude towards callers and colleagues. His behavior reflects his frustration and internal conflict, often leading him to overstep procedural boundaries in his desperate attempts to control the unfolding crisis.
1. In the 2021 American film, Joe Baylor exhibits a quick-to-judge persona, often scolding callers for their predicaments and showing impatience, such as when he argues with a caller reporting a robbery by a prostitute, revealing his judgmental attitude towards the public. 2. Joe Baylor frequently disregards standard 911 protocol, making unauthorized calls and asking his off-duty partner, Rick, to go to Henry Fisher's house without official authorization, demonstrating his rebellious nature and willingness to defy authority.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowNo explicit LGBTQ+ characters, themes, or representation were found in either the 2018 Danish film or the 2021 American remake of "The Guilty" through comprehensive searches. The narratives of both films focus on heterosexual relationships and family dynamics, with no mention of diverse sexual orientations or gender identities in plot summaries, character descriptions, or reviews.
No specific examples of LGBTQ+ characters, relationships, or themes were identified in the available content reviews, plot summaries, or cast information for either 'The Guilty' (2018) or 'The Guilty' (2021).
Witchcraft & Occult
LowNo elements of witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, spells, or explicit supernatural themes were found in either the 2018 Danish film or the 2021 American remake of "The Guilty." The narratives are grounded in realistic crime thriller scenarios and psychological drama.
No instances or references to witchcraft, occult practices, or supernatural phenomena were present in the plot descriptions, character details, or reviews for either the Danish or American adaptations of "The Guilty." The films focus on human actions and psychological tension.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowThe 2021 American remake explicitly features a strong moral worldview with overt Christian elements. The film does not contain anti-Christian themes; instead, it promotes values such as truth, justice, love, confession, and responsibility, with a direct biblical reference in its opening.
1. The 2021 American film opens with the biblical quote John 8:32, "And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free." This directly establishes a Christian theme of truth and spiritual liberation within the narrative. 2. Movieguide notes that the film has a "strong moral worldview with overt Christian elements," promoting justice and love, and stressing the importance of confession and taking responsibility for one's actions, which aligns with Christian teachings rather than opposing them.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Recommended for ages 16+ due to mature and disturbing thematic content, including implied violence (such as infanticide), pervasive strong profanity, and intense psychological distress. The Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) rated the 2021 American film 'R' for language throughout, and Common Sense Media also recommends it for teens 16 and up.
Additional Notes
The analysis is based on the 2018 Danish film "Den Skyldige" and its 2021 American remake, both titled "The Guilty." While the prompt requested analysis for a "tv" series, the most prominent media with this title and fitting the "adaptations" aspect are these two films. There is no widely recognized multi-season TV series named "The Guilty" that fits the criteria for tracking evolution across seasons, other than a brief mention of a 2025 Tamil web series. The content concerns primarily stem from the intense psychological nature and verbal descriptions of disturbing events, rather than explicit on-screen visuals. The films are essentially one-location thrillers that rely heavily on sound design and voice acting to convey the story's intensity.
Related Reviews
Is The Guilty right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required