The Good Place
The Good Place is an American fantasy-comedy television series created by Michael Schur, which concluded after four seasons. The series explores philosophical and ethical dilemmas within a unique afterlife setting. It follows Eleanor Shellstrop, a recently deceased woman who mistakenly arrives in the seemingly utopian 'Good Place' but quickly realizes she has been sent there in error. Along with a moral philosophy professor, a socialite, and a dim-witted DJ, she attempts to conceal her true identity and learn how to be a good person, uncovering profound truths about morality and the afterlife in the process. The show is critically acclaimed for its clever writing, humor, and optimistic messages about human nature and the capacity for self-improvement, even for immortal demons. It delves into complex ethical theories without watering down concepts, making philosophy accessible and entertaining. While primarily a comedy, it addresses weighty themes such as death, personal responsibility, and the meaning of existence, making it suitable for audiences who appreciate thought-provoking narratives alongside humor and character development.
Concerns
Anti-Christian Themes
HighThe series presents a secular, philosophical framework for the afterlife that explicitly deviates from established religions, including Christianity. It introduces a 'points system' for morality and a bureaucratic afterlife system, positing that 'no known religion or prophet' accurately guessed its workings. This narrative fundamentally reinterprets concepts of heaven, hell, and salvation, which can be a significant concern for Christian viewers.
The show's depiction of the afterlife involves a 'points system' where every action, positive or negative, contributes to a soul's score, determining entry into the Good or Bad Place, a concept that does not align with Christian teachings of grace and salvation through faith. The series explicitly states that all human religions, including Christianity, were incorrect about the afterlife, with the exception of a man named Doug Forcett who made some accurate guesses while on psychedelics, thereby undermining traditional religious authority. Furthermore, the show's inclusion of non-heteronormative relationships, as mentioned in LGBTQ+ concerns, is flagged by a parental review as a potential conflict for those who believe 'marriage should be between a man and woman.'
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe series includes LGBTQ+ representation and themes, with explicit mentions of non-heteronormative relationships and gender identity fluidity. The overall tone is accepting and inclusive of diverse sexual orientations and gender identities, which may be a point of consideration for some Christian parents.
The afterlife system does not adhere to traditional views on marriage, with one parental review outlet noting, 'anyone who believes that marriage should be between a man and woman need not apply.' Janet, an artificial intelligence, eventually marries Jason, a human, and engages in romantic relationships with both Jason and Michael at different points, showcasing a non-binary understanding of relationships. Additionally, in one of Michael's reboots, Eleanor and Tahani engage in a brief romantic relationship, further demonstrating same-sex romantic involvement within the show's narrative.
Violence
MediumViolence in 'The Good Place' is primarily comedic, slapstick, or psychological, rather than graphic. The core premise involves 'psychological torture' in the Bad Place, and characters are sometimes subjected to painful but non-bloody situations or discussions of hypothetical violent scenarios.
The entire first season reveals itself to be a form of psychological torture devised by the demon Michael for Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, and Jason, designed to make them miserable without physical harm. Jason Mendoza's original death, recounted in a comedic context, involved suffocating in a safe while attempting a heist, a scenario described as 'horrifying' if considered realistically, as he was conscious and desperate.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe show frequently includes discussions and suggestive humor related to sex and relationships, but avoids explicit sexual acts. Romantic relationships among the main characters are central to the plot, featuring kissing and implied intimacy.
Sexual content is a 'frequent topic' in the series. In the first episode, the character Eleanor mentions the concept of '50,000 simultaneous orgasms' as a perk of the Good Place. Another instance of suggestive language is when a Reddit user references a line about 'passing out on top of my vibrator,' indicating discussions of sexual items.
Profanity
MediumProfanity in 'The Good Place' is notably handled through a running comedic censorship gag where strong curse words are replaced with euphemisms like 'fork' and 'shirt.' While explicit strong language is largely avoided due to this mechanism, occasional milder uncensored swears are present.
A core comedic element is the 'Good Place' language filter, which changes profanities to words like 'fork' for the f-word and 'shirt' for the s-word, which Eleanor uses frequently. Despite this, some 'occasional swears go unchecked,' as noted by a parental review. For example, Eleanor exclaims, 'Damn it Eleanor, you are the worst,' at one point.
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumThe show's entire premise is rooted in a supernatural afterlife, featuring 'demons' (who appear as humans but can revert to 'lava monster' forms), 'immortal beings,' and an artificial intelligence like Janet with supernatural abilities. The existence of these entities and the concept of 'the Bad Place' (a version of hell) are central, but presented in a comedic and philosophical manner rather than a traditional occult context.
Michael, initially presented as an architect of the Good Place, is revealed to be a demon from the Bad Place whose purpose is to psychologically torture humans. Other demons, such as Shawn and Trevor, appear in human guises but are also depicted as 'lava monsters' in their true forms, whose sole purpose is to inflict pain. Janet, a non-human entity, possesses vast knowledge and the ability to conjure almost anything, akin to magic within the afterlife system.
Substance Use
MediumThe series includes references to both legal and illegal substance use, often in a comedic or narrative context to establish character backstories or contribute to plot points. These instances are generally mentioned rather than explicitly depicted in a detailed or glamorizing way.
Mindy St. Claire, a resident of the Medium Place, is revealed to have died after a 'cocaine high' during which she had the idea for a successful charity, leading to a complex afterlife scoring situation. Doug Forcett, a character who famously 'guessed the workings of the afterlife' with surprising accuracy, did so 'circa 1970' after 'once took psychedelics.' Additionally, Jason Mendoza's friend Pillboi is mentioned in the context of getting 'high together,' and Jason's death involves him being 'almost out of whip-its.' Characters also casually drink alcohol, such as wine, which 'flows freely' in the afterlife.
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe show, despite its comedic tone, deals with the inherently intense subject matter of death, eternal damnation, and psychological torment. While visual scares are minimal, the existential dread and the constant threat of the 'Bad Place' can be intense.
The central twist of the first season reveals that the characters are, in fact, in the 'Bad Place,' designed for psychological torture, creating a constant undercurrent of dread and high stakes for the protagonists. The ending of the series, where characters eventually choose to 'pass through a door' to cease existing after achieving fulfillment, has been described by some viewers as 'scary' or causing 'depressed for days' due to its confrontational depiction of ultimate finality.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumDisrespect for rules and rebellion against authority are significant and recurring themes, particularly in the early seasons. The main characters, initially flawed and self-serving, constantly defy the established norms and rules of the afterlife system.
Eleanor Shellstrop's character arc begins with her being an 'amoral loner' who deliberately tries to exploit the system, frequently talking back to Michael and Chidi and ignoring ethical guidelines. The entire premise of the series revolves around the four humans and Michael rebelling against the established, flawed afterlife system and the demons like Shawn, consistently trying to find loopholes or create new systems.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
A general age recommendation of 14+ is appropriate. While some discussions suggest 12-15+, the show's complex philosophical themes, frequent suggestive humor, implied strong language, and its unique take on the afterlife, which deviates significantly from traditional religious views, may be better understood and processed by older adolescents.
Additional Notes
The Good Place is known for its serialized nature and frequent plot twists. Parents should be aware that discussions of philosophy can be complex and may require additional context or conversation with younger viewers. The show's optimistic message about moral improvement and redemption is a strong positive element. The show concludes with a satisfying, yet emotionally resonant ending that deals directly with the ultimate finality of existence.
Related Reviews
Is The Good Place right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required