The Good Doctor
The Good Doctor (2017) is a medical drama that centers on Dr. Shaun Murphy, a young surgeon with autism and savant syndrome, as he navigates his residency at a prestigious hospital. The series explores his professional triumphs and personal challenges, including his struggles with social communication and forming relationships. It delves into complex medical cases, ethical dilemmas, and the intricate lives of the hospital staff, providing a character-driven narrative. The show is generally aimed at older teens and adults, due to its mature medical content, emotional themes, and explorations of various social issues.
Concerns
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
HighThe series features prominent LGBTQ+ representation, notably through the character of Dr. Asher Wolke, an openly gay former Hasidic Jew who is in a relationship with a male nurse. His storyline includes his journey of faith and sexual identity, culminating in his murder in a hate crime. Additionally, an early episode centers on a young transgender patient, discussing medical transition and family acceptance. Co-showrunner Liz Friedman is openly lesbian, highlighting an intentional approach to LGBTQ+ representation.
Dr. Asher Wolke (recurring in Season 4, main in Seasons 5-7) is openly gay and dates nurse Jerome Martel. Their relationship is depicted, and Asher is tragically murdered in a hate crime in Season 7 while on the verge of engagement. Season 1, Episode 14, titled 'She,' features a young transgender cancer patient named Quinn, whose storyline addresses topics such as pronouns, puberty blockers, and the process of transitioning at a young age, as well as family reactions.
Violence
HighThe show, as a medical drama, frequently presents graphic surgical scenes, blood, and depictions of severe injuries and medical emergencies. Beyond clinical violence, the series includes interpersonal violence, such as physical assaults and a character's murder. These instances can be visually explicit and emotionally intense.
In Season 7, Dr. Asher Wolke is brutally murdered in a hate crime, a significant and shocking event. The Season 5 finale features Dr. Audrey Lim being violently attacked and stabbed in the stomach by a nurse's disgruntled boyfriend, leading to severe injury and her subsequent paraplegia.
Romance and Sexual Content
HighThe series includes numerous romantic relationships among its characters, with depictions of intimacy ranging from kissing to implied sexual activity. More serious content includes explicit discussions of sexual harassment and a character revealing a past rape. These themes contribute to a mature rating for sexual content.
Season 1 features a storyline where Dr. Matt Coyle sexually harasses Dr. Claire Browne, leading to Dr. Jared Kalu assaulting Coyle in response and subsequently being fired. In Season 6, Dr. Claire Browne reveals she was raped while in medical school, a discussion that arises while she is helping a patient who experienced a drug-induced rape.
Profanity
HighThe series features a range of profanity, from mild to strong language. Occasional uses of words like 'damn,' 'hell,' 'ass,' 'crap,' and 'asshats' are present in dialogue, reflecting the stressful and intense hospital environment. Stronger expletives may also occur, as indicated by parental feedback.
Discussions on fan forums indicate the presence of strong profanity, with one user stating, 'fuck all this shit' in a critical comment about the show. For a hypothetical G-rated version of the show, specific words targeted for censorship included 'damn,' 'hell,' 'ass,' 'asshats,' 'crap,' and 'turds,' implying their presence in the original dialogue.
Substance Use
HighSubstance use is portrayed through characters struggling with addiction, instances of drunk driving, and references to drug-induced incidents. The consequences of substance abuse, including death and severe medical complications, are depicted.
Dr. Claire Browne's mother struggles with drug and alcohol addiction due to bipolar disorder, ultimately dying in Season 3 as a result of drunk driving. In Season 6, a storyline involves a patient who experienced a drug-induced rape, and a character reflects on her own past rape which implicitly connects to such themes.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe series contains frequently scary and intense content due to its medical setting, including graphic surgical procedures, emergency situations, and depictions of severe injuries, illnesses, and patient deaths. Emotional intensity arises from life-or-death stakes, character trauma, and violent attacks such as stabbings and a hate-crime murder.
The show frequently features intense surgical scenes, such as complex operations with visible blood and organs, designed to convey the high stakes of medical practice. Dr. Lim experiences significant emotional trauma and PTSD in Season 4 due to the overwhelming number of patient deaths during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumInstances of disrespect and rebellion are present through character actions and dialogue. Dr. Shaun Murphy's autism can lead to communication perceived as disrespectful or blunt, even if unintentional. Other characters engage in direct challenges to authority figures or institutional norms when they believe it's ethically justified.
In Season 1, Dr. Jared Kalu files a lawsuit against the hospital for racism after being unfairly fired, demonstrating significant defiance against the institution. Dr. Audrey Lim actively confronts hospital president Salen Morrison in Season 5 over her profit-driven decisions, which Lim believes compromise patient care, leading to a direct clash of authority.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumThe series addresses themes related to faith and identity, particularly through Dr. Asher Wolke's journey. Asher, a former Hasidic Jew, becomes an atheist after leaving his community due to his sexual identity. Before his death, he finds reconciliation with his faith, exploring the possibility of being both Jewish and gay. While not explicitly 'anti-Christian,' this narrative explores complex religious and non-religious viewpoints and sexual identity within a faith context, which may challenge traditional Christian perspectives for some viewers.
Dr. Asher Wolke's character arc explicitly involves his rejection of his Hasidic Jewish faith and subsequent embrace of atheism after coming out as gay, stating he left his community at eighteen. Later, shortly before his death in Season 7, Asher converses with a rabbi and is assured he can be both Jewish and gay, leading him to reconnect with his faith, demonstrating a nuanced approach to religious belief.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThere is no explicit depiction or discussion of witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, spells, or supernatural themes within 'The Good Doctor.' The show maintains a realistic, albeit dramatized, medical and human-interest focus. No elements related to these concerns were found.
This concern is entirely absent from the series. The narrative consistently adheres to a grounded reality, focusing on medical science, ethics, and human relationships, without venturing into supernatural or occult themes.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
This series is recommended for ages 14 and older, primarily due to its frequent depictions of graphic medical procedures, intense emotional and violent situations, mature thematic discussions including sexual harassment and a character's rape, explicit LGBTQ+ storylines, and instances of strong language and substance abuse. The complex bioethical dilemmas and character-driven narratives are best suited for a more mature audience capable of understanding nuanced themes.
Additional Notes
The portrayal of autism in the main character, Dr. Shaun Murphy, has received both praise for raising awareness and criticism for perpetuating the 'savant' stereotype. The show is produced by David Shore and Daniel Dae Kim and primarily filmed in Vancouver, British Columbia.
Related Reviews
Is The Good Doctor right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required