Stargirl
Stargirl is a superhero drama series adapted from DC Comics, centering on high school student Courtney Whitmore. After discovering the powerful Cosmic Staff, Courtney embraces her destiny as Stargirl and inspires a new iteration of the Justice Society of America (JSA). Alongside her stepfather, Pat Dugan, who was once a superhero sidekick, she leads her friends in battling various supervillains, including the original Injustice Society of America (ISA), in the seemingly idyllic town of Blue Valley, Nebraska. The series combines classic superhero action with prevalent coming-of-age themes, focusing on self-discovery, identity, and the formation of familial and friendly bonds.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe show features frequent and intense superhero action violence, including physical confrontations, use of superpowers resulting in harm, and instances of death with some graphic descriptions of injuries. The violence is a central element of the superhero narrative.
In the pilot episode, Starman is impaled in the stomach by a villain's projectile, leading to his death. Strong action violence is depicted in several scenes, with heroes and villains punching and hitting one another, energy blasts, explosions, and a supervillain threatening to 'melt' a girl's brain. In Season 1, Episode 13, Yolanda (Wildcat) kills the villain Brainwave.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe series features significant scary and intense content, particularly with the introduction of supernatural villains who employ psychological tactics, disturbing visions, and life-threatening scenarios. This escalates beyond typical superhero action to include psychological horror elements.
Season 2 introduces the villain Eclipso, who plays mind games and generates frightening and disturbing visions for characters, such as Pat being visited by a vision of Dr. Mid-Nite's daughter crawling out of her coffin. Characters frequently face intense jeopardy, including a supervillain threatening to 'melt' a girl's brain and attempts to crush a character between a bus and a car.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe series introduces an explicitly gay character in its later seasons, confirming LGBTQ+ representation. Earlier adaptations, such as the Disney+ movie, featured implied same-sex relationships, indicating a progression in the explicit nature of this content.
In Season 3, Tim Gabriel was cast as Todd Rice, also known as Obsidian, the son of the Golden Age Green Lantern Alan Scott, who is canonically gay in the comics. Additionally, the *Stargirl* movie (Disney+) includes an implied homosexual character, a girl who dresses in a boyish style and is seen dancing affectionately with another girl at a high school dance.
Profanity
MediumMild to moderate profanity is present in the series, including common expletives and some instances of name-calling. The frequency and intensity are generally moderate, with some curse words appearing in dialogue and occasionally in background music.
The pilot episode includes a few obscenities, such as the 'b' word, 'h' word, 'a**' word, and the exclamation 'OMG'. Episode 1.2 contains seven obscenities, including the 'a**' word and several 'd' words, with some appearing in a pop song on the soundtrack, in addition to 'OMG' exclamatory profanities.
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumThe series incorporates supernatural elements through its villains and their powers, alongside subtle references to occult concepts. These elements are integral to the plot and the nature of the superhero universe.
The pilot episode makes a comment about the 'stars being aligned' for Courtney's discovery of the Cosmic Staff, which is noted as having a 'possible metaphorical link to occult astrology.' In Season 2, the primary antagonist Eclipso is a supernatural villain who engages in mind games and creates disturbing visions, such as Pat seeing Dr. Mid-Nite's daughter crawling out of her coffin.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe series includes themes of teenage rebellion and disrespect, often in the context of young heroes operating without full adult supervision or dealing with social pressures. Bullying is also depicted as a recurring issue.
Courtney, as Stargirl, frequently sneaks out of her home to engage in superhero activities, initially without her stepfather Pat's knowledge or approval, demonstrating a form of youthful defiance. Bullying is shown at school, and a villain's son lies to his father to conceal that he was beaten up by Stargirl, highlighting deceit and avoidance of parental authority.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile not overtly anti-Christian, the series contains 'politically correct elements' and subtle occult references that some Christian parents might find concerning. The worldview may lean towards secular humanism with an emphasis on individuality and personal justice rather than explicitly Christian morality.
The pilot episode is noted for containing 'implied politically correct elements' that 'seem to promote a liberal view toward tradition and a rich versus poor anti-capitalist motif.' Additionally, the mention of the 'stars being aligned' for Courtney's powers is highlighted as an 'occult comment' associated with astrology, which may be contrary to Christian beliefs.
Romance and Sexual Content
LowRomantic content is present but generally mild and age-appropriate for teenagers, focusing on budding relationships, flirting, and chaste physical affection. There are some instances of suggestive attire, particularly in the movie adaptation.
The series includes typical teenage romantic relationships with moments of flirting, hand-holding, and chaste kisses between characters like Courtney (Stargirl) and her love interests. In the *Stargirl* movie, some girls are briefly shown in cleavage-baring dresses, and cheerleaders wear standard uniforms.
Substance Use
LowSubstance use is minimal and generally limited to incidental adult alcohol consumption. There is no depiction of illegal drug use or glorification of substance abuse in the TV series.
In the *Stargirl* movie, Leo's mother is seen drinking a glass of wine at dinner. For the TV series, official reviews explicitly state 'No smoking or drugs' for the pilot and episode 1.2, indicating a very low presence of substance use.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Stargirl is recommended for ages 12 and up. While the show promotes positive themes of heroism and friendship, it contains consistent action violence, some intense and scary sequences (especially in later seasons with supernatural villains), mild language, and evolving thematic content including LGBTQ+ representation. Parental guidance is advised for younger viewers or those sensitive to action violence and psychological intensity.
Additional Notes
The content intensity and complexity tend to increase across seasons, particularly regarding scary/intense elements and the introduction of diverse characters. The Disney+ movie adaptation, based on the same book, generally has a milder content profile than the TV series. Discussions around themes of nonconformity, justice, and family dynamics are prominent throughout the series.
Related Reviews
Is Stargirl right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required