StoryScanner
Start free

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin

Here's what we found in Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family
General Review

Parent's Guide to Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin is a spin-off of the popular Pretty Little Liars franchise, reimagined as a darker, horror-tinged teen drama with elements of slasher mystery. Set in the blue-collar town of Millwood, it follows a new generation of five disparate teen girls who find themselves tormented by an unknown assailant, 'A,' who seeks to punish them for the secret sins committed by their mothers two decades prior, as well as their own. The series blends suspense, mystery, and horror, taking inspiration from classic slasher films while exploring contemporary themes relevant to Gen Z. Targeted primarily at older teens and young adults, the show delves into complex social issues, trauma, and identity struggles. It is significantly more mature and explicit than its predecessor, with intensified violence, profanity, and sexual content. The series aims to provide a fresh take on the beloved franchise, emphasizing a grittier atmosphere and a more direct engagement with mature subject matter, making it suitable for viewers who appreciate dark, suspenseful narratives.

Things to Consider

High5

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

The series features significant LGBTQ+ and gender identity representation. Main characters Mouse Honrada and Noa Olivar are openly queer and bisexual, respectively. Mouse dates Ash Romero, a transgender male character portrayed by a trans actor, whose identity is presented as fully accepted. Additionally, Mouse is raised by two lesbian mothers, Elodie and Shirley Honrada. Noa also develops a romantic interest in Jennifer Fox, a lesbian character in Season 2. The show's creator aims for authentic queer representation.

Mouse Honrada (queer) is in a relationship with Ash Romero (transgender male). Ash's actor, Jordan Gonzalez, is also transgender, and Ash's transition is a normalized aspect of his character, not a source of conflict. Noa Olivar (bisexual) has a past relationship and developing romantic interest with Jennifer Fox (lesbian) in the 'Summer School' season. Mouse's home life prominently features her two mothers, Elodie and Shirley Honrada, who are a lesbian couple.

Violence

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin features frequent and graphic violence, aligning with its slasher horror genre. The mysterious villain 'A' commits brutal attacks and murders, often with explicit visual and auditory detail. Themes of psychological manipulation and threats of violence are central to the plot, creating a consistently intense and disturbing atmosphere.

Romance and Sexual Content

The show contains significant romance and sexual content, including implied sexual activity, suggestive dialogue, and discussions about relationships. A central and mature theme involves sexual assault, with a main character becoming pregnant as a result of rape. There are instances of partial nudity and depictions of predatory relationships.

Profanity

Profanity is frequent and strong throughout the series, exceeding the level seen in the original 'Pretty Little Liars'. The dialogue includes numerous explicit curse words, reflecting the show's mature tone and the creators' intention to portray realistic teen language in a streaming environment.

Scary & Intense Content

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin is intentionally scary and intense, heavily leaning into the slasher horror genre. It features graphic violence, jump scares, psychological torment, and a consistently frightening tone. The series addresses severe themes like suicide, sexual assault, and trauma in a raw and unsettling manner, often with visual and auditory impact.

Would these 5 concerns matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium2
Substance UseDisrespect & Rebellion
Low2
Witchcraft & OccultAnti-Christian Themes
Medium2

Substance Use

The series includes depictions and references to substance use, primarily alcohol and marijuana, within the context of teenage life. Characters are shown consuming alcohol, and there are direct consequences for drug-related activities for at least one main character.

Disrespect & Rebellion

The series portrays significant themes of disrespect and rebellion among its teenage protagonists. The 'Little Liars' frequently engage in defiant behavior, break rules, and keep secrets from adults and authority figures. This rebellion often stems from their desire to uncover the truth and protect themselves, but it also leads to dangerous situations.

Low2

Witchcraft & Occult

The series focuses on slasher horror and psychological mystery rather than overt witchcraft or occult themes. While it embraces a dark, horror-tinged atmosphere with a mysterious villain, there is no evidence of magic rituals, sorcery, demons, or supernatural powers driving the plot or being practiced by characters.

Anti-Christian Themes

No explicit anti-Christian themes, mockery of Christian beliefs, or sacrilegious acts are prominently featured or central to the plot of Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin. While the show delves into moral complexities and 'sins,' these are framed within a secular horror and mystery narrative, rather than directly opposing or critiquing Christian doctrine.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin delves into themes of generational trauma, bullying, secrets, and revenge, often portraying the severe consequences of past misdeeds. While the narrative highlights the pain and suffering caused by sin, particularly the "original sin" committed by the mothers, it often presents moral issues in a way that may contradict biblical values. The show explores difficult subjects such as sexual assault, suicide, drug use, and LGBTQ+ relationships, with the implication that many characters operate within a relativistic moral framework where personal feelings and experiences often dictate what is considered right or wrong. Virtue, in a biblical sense, is rarely explicitly rewarded, and vice often drives the plot, leading to a cycle of retribution rather than clear moral accountability and justice. The consequences faced by characters are more often a result of vengeful actions rather than an inherent, transcendent moral order. While characters experience suffering due to their actions or the actions of others, the show does not consistently offer a clear path to redemption aligned with Christian principles. The worldview presented in "Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin" leans towards a materialistic and relativistic understanding of life. Meaning and purpose are largely derived from personal experiences, relationships, and the quest for justice or revenge, rather than from a transcendent source. There are limited explicit themes of sacrifice, forgiveness, or grace in a redemptive sense. While some characters may apologize or seek to atone for specific actions, the overarching narrative is driven by a quest for vengeance, particularly by 'A,' who seeks to punish both the mothers and their daughters for their sins. Family relationships are complex and often dysfunctional, with parental authority frequently undermined or absent, and a heavy emphasis on the damaging impact of parental secrets and actions on their children. Parenting is often portrayed as flawed, with mothers carrying the burden of past mistakes that directly impact their daughters' present struggles. Faith and Christianity are depicted in the series, but not always in a positive light. For example, the concept of a "Redemption House" is introduced as a youth project by a church, "Our Mother of Holy Grace." However, this initiative is portrayed as misguided and even exploitative, recreating the characters' past traumas, including sexual assault and suicide, under the guise of repentance, and its intent is grounded in hate, punishing people for sins like being gay or committing suicide. One character, Martha Beasley, is presented as a religious matriarch who attempts to maintain appearances despite private struggles and ultimately snaps, further illustrating a potentially negative or critical view of performative religious devotion. The show does not offer an affirming portrayal of Christian faith as a source of genuine comfort, guidance, or moral compass for its characters, and instead uses religious elements to highlight hypocrisy or manipulative behavior.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

17+ (TV-MA). The series is officially rated TV-MA, indicating content unsuitable for viewers under 17. This is due to frequent graphic violence, intense horror elements, mature sexual content including rape themes and partial nudity, pervasive strong language, and depictions of substance abuse and psychological trauma. Parents should exercise extreme caution.

Good to Know

The series 'Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin' is a significant departure in tone and content from the original 'Pretty Little Liars,' adopting a much darker, slasher-horror aesthetic. Parents should be aware of the escalated mature content across all categories, especially concerning violence and sexual themes, which are portrayed with graphic realism and are central to the storyline. The show's commitment to diverse LGBTQ+ representation is notable, but this occurs within an overall mature and often disturbing narrative. Viewer discretion is strongly advised, and it is recommended that parents preview content if considering it for younger mature teens.

How does this review compare?

This review
  • 9 standard concerns
  • General sensitivity level
  • One-size-fits-all perspective
Your report
  • Concerns you choose
  • Sensitivity levels you set
  • Tailored to your family

What are you watching next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly
Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families