StoryScanner
Start free

Only Murders in the Building

Here's what we found in Only Murders in the Building. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family
General Review

Parent's Guide to Only Murders in the Building

Only Murders in the Building is a comedic mystery series that follows an unlikely trio of true-crime podcast enthusiasts residing in the upscale Arconia apartment building in New York City. When a suspicious death occurs within their residence, the three neighbors—aging actor Charles, struggling Broadway director Oliver, and enigmatic young artist Mabel—band together to launch their own podcast, determined to uncover the truth behind the titular murders. Each season presents a new central mystery, blending elements of humor, suspense, and character-driven drama as they investigate, often finding themselves embroiled in dangerous situations and personal revelations. The series explores themes of loneliness, friendship across generations, and the human fascination with true crime. It is generally targeted at a mature audience who appreciate sophisticated comedy and engaging whodunit narratives.

Things to Consider

High5

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

The series features significant LGBTQ+ representation, including openly lesbian and bisexual characters with depicted romantic relationships and discussions of sexual identity. This content is recurring across seasons and integrated into character storylines, moving beyond casual mentions.

Mabel Mora is depicted in a bisexual relationship with artist Alice Banks in Season 2, which includes a kissing scene. Charles-Haden Savage's stunt double, Sazz Pataki, is explicitly a lesbian and is shown to have had relationships with women, including Charles' ex-girlfriend Jan, and their ongoing romantic involvement is confirmed in later seasons.

Violence

Given its murder mystery genre, violence is a central and frequent theme. The show includes depictions of dead bodies, blood, and the aftermath of violent acts, though often with a comedic tone. Characters are exposed to threats, stabbings, poisonings, and kidnappings.

Romance and Sexual Content

The series includes implied sexual activity, suggestive dialogue, partial nudity, and references to sexual harassment. While explicit sexual acts are not graphically shown, the content is mature and frequently present, escalating beyond mild flirtation.

Profanity

Profanity is prevalent throughout the series, including frequent use of strong curse words and misuses of divine names. The language is a consistent element of the dialogue across various characters.

Scary & Intense Content

As a murder mystery, the show inherently contains scary and intense content, including discovery of dead bodies, suspenseful situations, and direct threats to characters. While often balanced with comedy, the core themes are dark and can be disturbing.

Would these 5 concerns matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium3
Substance UseDisrespect & RebellionAnti-Christian Themes
Low1
Witchcraft & Occult
Medium3

Substance Use

Alcohol consumption is a regular and casual occurrence among characters. There are also explicit references to past illegal drug use and addiction, although the show generally does not graphically depict current heavy drug use.

Disrespect & Rebellion

Characters frequently exhibit sarcastic and sometimes rude behavior, particularly Mabel, and engage in minor rebellious or unlawful acts like breaking and entering for their investigations. While present, these actions are usually framed within the show's comedic tone and are not central to promoting extreme defiance.

Anti-Christian Themes

The series contains a scene referencing Christian iconography, specifically a recreation of 'The Last Supper,' where a character places himself in a central, Christ-like role. While some viewers found this irreverent, many self-identified Christians in fan communities interpreted it as satirical humor targeting a character's ego rather than mocking Christian faith. There are also incidental jokes about religious figures.

Low1

Witchcraft & Occult

Mentions of witchcraft or occult themes are minimal and appear in a casual, comedic context rather than depicting actual practices or rituals. There is no serious exploration or portrayal of supernatural elements.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

Only Murders in the Building presents a narrative rich in themes that resonate with some Christian values, particularly concerning community, purpose, and the overcoming of loneliness. The core message of three disparate individuals forming deep intergenerational friendships, finding connection, and ultimately a renewed sense of purpose through their shared endeavor, strongly aligns with biblical principles of fellowship and valuing others. The show subtly suggests that genuine fulfillment is found not in isolation or self-absorption, but in meaningful relationships, a concept deeply embedded in Christian teaching about love for neighbor and community. Furthermore, the exploration of identity, encouraging a balanced foundation for self-esteem rather than focusing on a single pursuit, offers a parallel to the biblical caution against placing ultimate hope in worldly achievements. While the show itself does not explicitly present a transcendent worldview, the unexpected joy and connection found by the characters amidst challenging circumstances can point to a deeper human longing for meaning beyond the material. However, Christian parents should be aware of certain aspects that may contradict biblical values. The characters often engage in morally ambiguous actions, such as breaking into apartments, tampering with evidence, and lying to advance their investigation. While these actions serve the plot, moral accountability for these vices is not always clearly portrayed in a legal sense, though emotional and relational consequences are explored. The worldview presented leans more humanistic, with meaning primarily derived from human connection and personal achievement (like the success of their podcast), rather than an explicit reliance on a divine or transcendent source of truth and morality. Family relationships are portrayed as complex and sometimes strained, with chosen families often taking precedence, and authority figures like the police are sometimes depicted as fallible or even obstructive, leading the protagonists to take matters into their own hands. Redemption themes are present, primarily through the characters' personal growth and the healing they experience from past traumas and regrets as they forge their friendships. This transformation suggests a form of secular redemption, where broken individuals find wholeness through authentic connection and shared purpose. Explicit faith representation, however, is minimal and, when present, tends to be through casual exclamations or jokes that misuse God's name, rather than a respectful depiction of Christian belief or practice. Therefore, while the series offers positive themes of friendship and purpose, its moral relativism in investigative methods and lack of clear spiritual grounding require discernment from a Christian worldview.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

16+ (TV-MA). While Common Sense Media suggests 14+, the official TV-MA rating from Hulu/Disney+ indicates content suitable for mature audiences 17 and older. This recommendation is due to frequent strong language, discussions and depictions of violence related to murder, implied sexual content, and LGBTQ+ romantic relationships.

Good to Know

The show consistently blends dark subject matter (murder, death) with comedic elements, which may alter the perception of intensity for some viewers. Parental discretion is advised due to the mature nature of the themes, language, and sexual references.

How does this review compare?

This review
  • 9 standard concerns
  • General sensitivity level
  • One-size-fits-all perspective
Your report
  • Concerns you choose
  • Sensitivity levels you set
  • Tailored to your family

What are you watching next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly
Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families