Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is an acclaimed anime series that falls into the action, adventure, and fantasy genres. It follows the journey of two young alchemist brothers, Edward and Alphonse Elric, who attempt the forbidden act of human transmutation to bring their deceased mother back to life. Their failed attempt results in Edward losing an arm and a leg, and Alphonse losing his entire body, with his soul bound to a suit of armor. The narrative then chronicles their quest to find the legendary Philosopher's Stone, believing it holds the key to restoring their original bodies, while uncovering a vast conspiracy within their country.
Concerns
Violence
HighFullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood features significant and often graphic animated violence, including bodily dismemberment, on-screen murders, and depictions of war. The violence is integral to the plot, showcasing the brutal consequences of alchemy and human conflict, and can be quite intense and disturbing.
The series opens with a flashback in Episode 2, 'The First Day,' depicting Edward Elric losing his left leg and right arm, and Alphonse Elric losing his entire body, during their failed human transmutation attempt. This scene is shown with visible blood and grotesque imagery. Another highly disturbing example occurs in Episode 7, 'Hidden Truths,' where Shou Tucker transmutes his young daughter, Nina, and their dog into a grotesque speaking chimera, a horrific act that deeply traumatizes the protagonists and is explicitly depicted.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighAlchemy, though presented as a science, functions as a form of magic with occult-like elements, including forbidden human transmutation and the creation of artificial life forms (Homunculi). The narrative explores the moral and spiritual consequences of these practices, blurring lines between science and the supernatural.
The entire premise revolves around the Elric brothers performing 'human transmutation,' a forbidden alchemical ritual to resurrect their mother, which is explicitly shown in Episode 2. This act attempts to defy the natural order of life and death, resulting in their physical tolls and a grotesque failed creation. The antagonists, the Homunculi, are artificial beings created through occult means and the use of the Philosopher's Stone, a powerful artifact made from human souls. Their existence and powers are central to the series' darker, more mystical elements.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe series contains frequent scary and intense content, including psychological horror, body horror, and themes of war and genocide. Several scenes are designed to be shocking and emotionally impactful, addressing mature concepts of suffering, loss, and moral ambiguity.
The grotesque outcome of the Elric brothers' failed human transmutation in Episode 2, featuring a monstrous, incomplete creation and severe bodily harm, is highly disturbing. The transformation of Nina Tucker into a chimera in Episode 7 is a deeply traumatic and morally horrifying event that serves as a major emotional turning point for the protagonists and the audience, showcasing human experimentation at its worst.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe series includes a canonically genderless character, Envy, who identifies as a homunculus and demonstrates the ability to shift forms and gender expression. Additionally, a minor character, Garfiel, is depicted as explicitly gay, though his portrayal has been noted as stereotypical. Some fan interpretations also suggest queer coding for other characters and allegorical readings of the Elric brothers' journey.
Envy, one of the primary antagonists, is explicitly depicted as a genderless homunculus with an androgynous appearance and voice, capable of taking on various forms regardless of gender. While English translations often use 'he/him' pronouns, the character is confirmed to be genderless in the original Japanese and manga. Garfiel, a minor character who is Winry Rockbell's automail instructor and friend, is canonically gay and is shown hitting on men, though some of these scenes were reportedly omitted from the Brotherhood anime.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumRomantic relationships are present but not explicit, with only mild suggestive content. There are very few instances of nudity, and these are not graphic or sexualized. Allusions to prostitution are present through a specific location.
Brief scenes of non-graphic nudity include Winry Rockbell bathing and Edward Elric showering, where private parts are obscured or not detailed. The character Lust, a homunculus, engages in suggestive dialogue, particularly during her confrontations with Colonel Mustang, hinting at seductive intentions without explicit sexual acts. Additionally, characters visit 'Madame Christmas's Brothel,' implying the presence of prostitution, though no explicit sexual acts are shown.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumCharacters, particularly the young protagonists Edward and Alphonse Elric, frequently display disrespect and rebellious attitudes towards authority figures, especially military superiors. This often stems from their strong moral compass and distrust of the establishment, rather than wanton defiance.
Edward Elric frequently talks back to and openly challenges his superior officer, Colonel Roy Mustang, often using sarcastic remarks and defying direct orders when he believes they are unjust or inefficient. This behavior is a recurring character trait. The Elric brothers, along with other allied characters, actively engage in rebellion against the corrupt State Military and the Homunculi, defying the highest authority within Amestris for what they perceive as the greater good and to expose the truth.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile not explicitly anti-Christian, the series' core concept of alchemy and its philosophical underpinnings can be seen to challenge traditional Christian doctrines. The act of human transmutation attempts to usurp divine power, and the ultimate antagonist seeks godhood, presenting a worldview where human agency and scientific principles, albeit fantastical, take precedence over traditional religious cosmology.
The central premise of human transmutation, the forbidden act of attempting to resurrect the dead or create life, directly challenges the concept of God as the sole creator and arbiter of life and death. The Elric brothers' initial motivation to 'play God' by reviving their mother sets the stage for the narrative's exploration of forbidden knowledge. The main antagonist, Father, explicitly seeks to achieve godhood and become a 'perfect being,' manipulating human souls and the entire nation to achieve this ultimate blasphemous goal, directly positioning himself against any traditional divine authority.
Profanity
LowThe series contains occasional mild profanity, primarily consisting of words like 'damn' and 'crap.' Stronger expletives are notably absent, making the language generally suitable for a teenage audience.
Characters occasionally use mild curse words such as 'damn' and 'crap' in moments of frustration or anger. For example, Edward Elric, known for his short temper, might exclaim 'Damn it!' when plans go awry or he is provoked. The language used is generally consistent with a TV-14 rating.
Substance Use
LowThe portrayal of substance use is minimal, limited primarily to casual alcohol consumption by adult characters in social settings. There is no depiction of illegal drug use or glorification of substance abuse.
Adult characters, particularly military personnel like Colonel Mustang and his subordinates, are occasionally shown drinking alcohol in bars or during downtime. These instances are casual and do not depict heavy intoxication or addiction. The mention of 'Madame Christmas's Brothel' implies an adult environment where alcohol would likely be consumed, but it's not a focus of the visual content.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is recommended for viewers aged 15 and older. While lacking explicit sexual content, the series features pervasive animated violence, graphic depictions of bodily harm, and mature themes such as genocide, war crimes, human experimentation, and philosophical discussions on life, death, and morality. Younger viewers may find certain scenes highly disturbing and the complex narrative challenging to fully comprehend.
Additional Notes
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a critically acclaimed series renowned for its intricate plot, character development, and exploration of profound philosophical and ethical themes. Parental guidance is strongly advised due to intense violence, disturbing imagery, and complex moral dilemmas that may require discussion with younger viewers. The emotional depth and mature storytelling make it unsuitable for audiences below mid-adolescence.
Related Reviews
Is Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required