Downton Abbey is a historical drama television series and subsequent films set in the early 20th century, primarily focusing on the aristocratic Crawley family and their domestic staff on a fictional English country estate. The narrative explores themes of love, loss, social change, and personal struggles across class lines during significant historical periods like the sinking of the Titanic, World War I, and the Roaring Twenties. Known for its lush period aesthetics, intricate storylines, and strong character development, the series captivated a wide audience. While generally regarded as a sophisticated and often family-friendly drama, it addresses mature themes and complex human experiences, including societal prejudices, violence, and romantic entanglements, making it most suitable for teenage and adult viewers.
The series and films feature a significant and recurring LGBTQ+ storyline centered on Thomas Barrow, a gay footman and later butler, depicting the severe societal repression and personal struggles faced by homosexual individuals in the early 20th century. Creator Julian Fellowes intentionally explored the 'predicament of being gay before the modern age'. This representation evolves from initial struggles and isolation to finding acceptance and love in later installments.
Thomas Barrow's journey includes a storyline where he attempts a 'cure' for his homosexuality through hormonal therapy in Season 5, which leaves him ill and profoundly depressed, leading to a suicide attempt. He is also arrested during a police raid on an underground gay club, highlighting the illegality and danger of being gay during the period. In the film 'Downton Abbey: A New Era,' Thomas eventually finds love and companionship with Guy Dexter, a closeted gay movie star, offering a more optimistic resolution to his arc.
Downton Abbey contains instances of violence, though generally not graphic. These include the impact of war, physical altercations, and a non-explicit but emotionally intense sexual assault. The portrayal focuses more on the aftermath and emotional trauma rather than explicit visual detail.
In Season 4, Episode 3, lady's maid Anna Bates is sexually assaulted by Mr. Green, a guest's valet. The attack itself occurs off-screen, but Anna's screams are heard, and she is later shown bruised and traumatized, leading to significant emotional distress. In the first Downton Abbey film, a plot to assassinate the King involves a man pointing a gun, who is then tackled to the ground by Tom Branson. This scene includes a physical struggle but avoids graphic gore.
The media features various romantic relationships, including several extramarital affairs and implied sexual activity, consistent with the adult themes of a period drama. While nudity is absent, suggestive material and intense emotional intimacy are present, particularly around sensitive topics like illegitimacy and sexual assault.
Lady Edith has an out-of-wedlock child, Marigold, with Michael Gregson, which she initially tries to keep secret and later raises as her own, a scandalous situation for the era. The series also includes kissing and embracing between various couples, such as Cora and Robert, Lucy and Tom, and Lady Mary and Henry Talbot. In Season 3, Thomas Barrow is portrayed kissing another footman, James Kent, while he is asleep, leading to serious repercussions for Thomas.
The language used in Downton Abbey is generally mild for a contemporary audience, reflecting the period setting. However, it does include some mild curse words and terms of deity, as well as some stronger derogatory terms in certain contexts, particularly in moments of heightened emotion or conflict.
Occasional mild curse words such as 'damn' and 'hell' are used throughout the series and films. Stronger terms like 'bitch,' 'bastard,' and 'slut' have been noted by viewers as being present in some dialogue, particularly during intense arguments or character disputes. For instance, the term 'bastard' is used, notably by Bates in one instance.
Characters in Downton Abbey frequently consume alcohol in social settings, reflecting the customs of the era. Smoking is also present, though less explicitly glamorized. There are instances of misuse, including one character having their drink intentionally spiked and another attempting to self-medicate.
Alcohol is regularly consumed by both upstairs and downstairs characters during meals, parties, and social gatherings. In Season 3, Larry Grey intentionally spikes Tom Branson's drink during a dinner party to embarrass him, leading to inappropriate behavior from Tom. Thomas Barrow attempts to 'cure' his homosexuality using hormonal therapy in Season 5, which involves injections and pills, leading to severe illness.
The series and films contain several emotionally intense and unsettling plotlines. These include the psychological impact of war, character deaths, a sexual assault, and a suicide attempt, which contribute to a sense of dramatic tension and mature themes.
The death of Matthew Crawley in a car crash at the end of Season 3 is depicted with distressing visuals of his crumpled body and blood. Thomas Barrow's deep loneliness and despair over his sexuality lead to a suicide attempt where he slits his wrists in the bath, a scene discovered by Miss Baxter. The sexual assault of Anna Bates, though not graphically shown, is an intensely disturbing event that generates significant emotional trauma for the character and is a central plot point.
The narrative frequently explores themes of class struggle, social hierarchy, and challenges to established norms. Characters exhibit various forms of disrespect and rebellion, from subtle snarky remarks to direct defiance of authority and societal expectations.
Lady Sybil Crawley, one of the daughters, actively defies her aristocratic family's expectations by training as a nurse and later marrying the family chauffeur, Tom Branson, a significant act of rebellion against class conventions. The Dowager Countess, Violet Crawley, is known for her sharp wit and often delivers sarcastic and critical remarks, challenging others' opinions and occasionally displaying subtle disrespect for changing social attitudes.
While the setting is a largely Christian society, overt religious practices or discussions of faith are notably downplayed. The show's historical advisor explicitly stated that religious references were deliberately limited to avoid alienating secular audiences, which some critics have noted as historically inaccurate for the period.
Alistair Bruce, the show's historical advisor, revealed that scenes showing characters saying grace before meals were never included, as the production team aimed to 'leave religion out of it' to broaden audience appeal. There is a storyline involving anti-Catholic sentiment when Tom Branson and Lady Sybil's baby is to be baptized, highlighting religious prejudice within the Anglican upper class.
Direct depictions of witchcraft or overt occult practices are minimal. There are brief instances of characters engaging with spiritualist tools that were popular in the historical period, suggesting a peripheral interest in the supernatural rather than active engagement with dark magic.
In a Christmas special, Anna and Daisy are shown using a Ouija board in the staff common hall, receiving a message from a deceased character, Lavinia, hinting at paranormal communication. Additionally, there are subtle moments where characters, such as Mary and Daisy, experience an almost paranormal sense of distress or faintness when loved ones (Matthew and William) are injured, implying a strong emotional or intuitive connection rather than magic.
Recommended for ages 13 and up. The series and films contain mature thematic elements, including discussions of sexuality, instances of violence, substance use, and intense emotional storylines that may be unsettling for younger viewers. Official ratings such as UK 12A and US PG (for the films) suggest suitability for adolescents with parental guidance due to adult themes.
The series and films are rich in historical context, allowing for discussions about early 20th-century social customs, class structures, gender roles, and the challenges faced by marginalized groups, particularly LGBTQ+ individuals, during this era. Parental guidance is recommended to help contextualize these sensitive topics.
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required