Criminal Minds
Criminal Minds is a long-running American police procedural crime drama television series that delves into the dark and complex world of criminal profiling. The show follows an elite squad of FBI profilers, known as the Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU), who travel across the country to assist local law enforcement in investigating heinous crimes by analyzing the behavior and motivations of unknown subjects, or "unsubs." Each episode typically features a new case, focusing on the psychological aspects of the criminals rather than traditional forensic evidence. Targeted at mature audiences, Criminal Minds explores the depths of human depravity, frequently depicting graphic violence, disturbing psychological themes, and intense situations. While the original run on CBS maintained a TV-14 rating, the recent revival, "Criminal Minds: Evolution" on Paramount+, has adopted a TV-MA rating, allowing for darker content and more explicit language. The series is known for its suspenseful narratives, character-driven storylines, and a consistent focus on the battle between good and evil through the lens of criminal psychology.
Concerns
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
HighLGBTQ+ representation in 'Criminal Minds' has evolved, with early seasons featuring problematic portrayals such as transgender individuals linked to mental illness or gay characters solely as villains. However, the more recent 'Criminal Minds: Evolution' introduced a positive, canonical same-sex relationship for a main character.
In 'Criminal Minds: Evolution' (Season 16, Episode 2, 'Sicarius'), Dr. Tara Lewis is revealed to be in a relationship with Rebecca Wilson, who is confirmed as her girlfriend, and actress Aisha Tyler stated Tara identifies as pansexual. Conversely, earlier seasons presented negative depictions, such as the Season 4, Episode 20, 'Conflicted' storyline, criticized for conflating gender identity with mental illness and predatory behavior. Additionally, the only LGBTQ character found in the show's first 13 seasons, Mark Tolson (Season 12), was a gay serial killer.
Violence
HighThe series is characterized by frequent and often extremely graphic depictions of violence, torture, and murder, which are central to the plot in almost every episode. This content consistently pushes the boundaries of its network TV-14 rating in early seasons and is intensified in the TV-MA streaming revival.
In 'The Inspiration'/'The Inspired' (Season 9, Episodes 1/2), victims are subjected to forced cannibalism. Another particularly disturbing example is 'Proof' (Season 7, Episode 2), where a serial killer destroys victims' senses by pouring acid into their mouths and eyes. The episode 'The Lesson' (Season 8, Episode 10) features an unsub who disarticulates victims' joints to turn them into human marionettes, showing the gruesome process in detail. 'To Hell… and Back, Part II' (Season 4, Episode 26) involves an unsub feeding victims to pigs to dispose of bodies, with a chilling scene of a bin full of shoes as evidence.
Profanity
HighProfanity usage escalates significantly in the later 'Criminal Minds: Evolution' seasons, transitioning from limited, milder language under network television restrictions to frequent and strong expletives. This change has been noted as jarring by long-time viewers due to the historical character portrayals.
In 'Criminal Minds: Evolution' (Season 16+), characters like David Rossi are heard using strong language, including expletives such as 'fuckhead,' which was uncharacteristic of the original series. Long-time fans have expressed surprise at the sudden increase in explicit language, stating it feels unnatural from characters who rarely swore for 15 seasons. Prior to 'Evolution,' the original CBS run (Seasons 1-15) adhered to TV-14 guidelines, meaning strong profanity was largely absent or highly censored.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe show is inherently designed to be scary and intense, focusing on disturbing criminal psychology and graphic crime scenes. It frequently features themes of psychological torture, child abduction and murder, and unsettling visuals, making it consistently frightening for viewers.
Many episodes are singled out for their disturbing content, such as 'The Lesson' (Season 8, Episode 10), where an unsub turns victims into human marionettes, depicting the horrific disarticulation process. 'Mr. Scratch' (Season 10, Episode 21) portrays extreme psychological horror as a serial killer drugs victims, causing them to hallucinate monsters and murder their families. The episode 'To Hell… and Back, Part II' (Season 4, Episode 26) involves a chilling scenario where victims are fed to pigs, emphasizing the complete disappearance of their remains. The presence of child killers, such as the 12-year-old unsub in 'The Boogeyman' (Season 2, Episode 6), adds a particularly disturbing layer of intensity.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumWhile explicit sexual acts are generally implied rather than shown, sexual content is a prevalent thematic element due to the nature of the crimes investigated, including frequent references to sexual assault, rape, and sexually motivated violence. Romantic relationships among the BAU team are present but rarely explicit.
Sexual assault is a recurring crime theme, often discussed and implied in grim detail, as seen in episodes like 'Burn' (Season 10), which is described as very graphic relating to sexual assault. A Reddit discussion confirms that while there are no explicit sex scenes in the main series, implied sex and rape are present in many cases. For instance, the character Spencer Reid engages in a kiss with Hollywood starlet Lila Archer in 'Somebody's Watching,' though the relationship is not heavily explored with explicit content.
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumThe show occasionally incorporates themes of witchcraft, occult practices, and demonic possession, primarily through the delusions or belief systems of serial killers (unsubs). While these elements are present, they are usually framed within a psychological context rather than portraying actual supernatural occurrences.
In 'Heathridge Manor' (Season 7, Episode 19), an unsub, James Heathridge, drowns victims, believing he is determining if they are witches and murdering 'Devil's wives.' Another episode, 'In The Blood' (Season 9, Episode 6), features ritualistic murders and an unsub fascinated by the Salem witch trials, leading to a scene where he attempts to burn a woman at the stake. The episode 'Demonology' explores exorcism themes and insinuates demonic possession, with a priest warning a character about being open to possession.
Substance Use
Medium'Criminal Minds' features significant storylines involving substance abuse and addiction, notably with a main character struggling with drug dependency. Additionally, drugs are frequently used as a plot device by unsubs to control or torture victims, and there are references to alcohol abuse.
Dr. Spencer Reid develops an addiction to Dilaudid in Season 2's 'Revelations' after being repeatedly drugged and tortured by serial killer Tobias Hankel while held captive. This addiction is a recurring subplot throughout later seasons, with Reid attending support groups. Another example is the unsub known as 'Mr. Scratch' (Peter Lewis), who uses a cocktail of drugs to induce hallucinations in his victims, manipulating them into killing their loved ones or themselves, as seen in 'Mr. Scratch' (Season 10, Episode 21).
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumThe series explores distorted religious beliefs primarily as motivations for serial killers and within the context of dangerous cults. While it critiques extreme dogmatic interpretations and religious fanaticism that lead to violence, it does not broadly mock or insult mainstream Christian faith.
In 'Minimal Loss' (Season 4, Episode 3), Agents Reid and Prentiss infiltrate a religious cult, 'Liberty Church Ranch,' led by Benjamin Cyrus, which depicts the dangers of extreme, dogmatic religious belief, reinforced by an opening quote: 'To follow by faith alone is to follow blindly.' The show features a category of 'Religious Killers' on its fan wiki, with characters like Floyd Feylinn Ferell and Tobias Hankel whose crimes are rooted in twisted religious motivations.
Disrespect & Rebellion
LowWhile the FBI agents largely operate within professional bounds, there are instances of characters bending rules or displaying informal behavior. The core of the show, investigating 'unsubs,' inherently deals with individuals who exhibit extreme defiance and rebellion against societal norms and laws through their criminal acts.
Garcia occasionally pushes cases to the front of the queue to aid her support group, which could be seen as an unprofessional bending of rules for personal connections. Additionally, Spencer Reid once abused his power as an FBI agent to work an unauthorized case and investigate his own father, nearly destroying his father's career, an act criticized for its ethical implications.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
18+ due to consistent graphic violence, disturbing psychological themes, frequent sexual assault narratives, substance abuse, and strong language, especially in later seasons. The original TV-14 rating was often stretched, and the TV-MA rating for 'Evolution' more accurately reflects the mature content.
Additional Notes
Parents should be aware that while the original 'Criminal Minds' seasons (1-15) were rated TV-14, the content often pushed the limits of this rating, particularly concerning graphic violence and disturbing psychological themes. The more recent streaming revival, 'Criminal Minds: Evolution' (Season 16+), carries a TV-MA rating and features a noticeable increase in profanity and a deeper dive into darker subject matter. The show's episodic nature means that content intensity can vary, but recurring themes of torture, murder, sexual assault, and complex psychological disorders are consistent. Viewer discretion is strongly advised for younger or sensitive audiences, and a co-viewing approach is recommended for parents considering allowing older teens to watch, especially for discussing the difficult themes presented.
Related Reviews
Is Criminal Minds right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required