StoryScanner
Start free

All American

Here's what we found in All American. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family
General Review

Parent's Guide to All American

All American is a compelling sports drama series on The CW, drawing inspiration from the real-life journey of NFL player Spencer Paysinger. The show chronicles the experiences of Spencer James, a talented high school football player from the challenging neighborhood of Crenshaw, as he transitions to play for the affluent Beverly Hills High. Through this central narrative, the series intricately explores the contrasts between these two distinct worlds, delving into critical themes such as family dynamics, enduring friendships, racial tensions, class disparities, and the relentless pursuit of dreams. Although American football provides the primary setting, the show's core strength lies in its exploration of the personal triumphs and struggles of a diverse ensemble cast, particularly focusing on the nuanced experiences of Black youth in contemporary America. The series is celebrated for its inclusive storytelling, aiming to represent a wide spectrum of relatable challenges and underscore the significance of community and self-identity, making it particularly resonant for teen and young adult audiences.

Things to Consider

High3

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

The series features significant LGBTQ+ representation. Tamia "Coop" Cooper is a main character who is lesbian, with storylines detailing her coming out to her religious family and navigating romantic relationships. The spin-off, "All American: Homecoming," further expands this by introducing Nathaniel, a prominent non-binary character, and also highlights Keisha, who is queer/bisexual. Additionally, the character Marco Galvez is openly gay. The show's creators and actors have openly discussed the importance of this representation.

Tamia "Coop" Cooper (lesbian) faces rejection from her church-going mother in Season 1, Episode 3 ("i") after coming out as gay. Coop's romantic relationship with Patience, also a lesbian, is a recurring plot point, exemplified in Season 1, Episode 5 ("All We Got") where they define their relationship. In the spin-off, "All American: Homecoming," Nathaniel (played by Rhoyle Ivy King) is introduced as The CW's first Black non-binary character, exploring gender identity and expression. Furthermore, the character Marco Galvez is a five-star running back who is openly gay, a fact that becomes a plot point when a college attempts to use his identity for a campaign.

Violence

The series frequently depicts violence, particularly in relation to gang activity in the Crenshaw neighborhood. This includes instances of physical fights, gun violence, and stabbings, some of which are portrayed graphically and result in severe trauma or character deaths. The escalating nature of violence is noted across seasons.

Substance Use

Substance use is a significant and recurring concern in "All American." The show explicitly depicts underage drinking, marijuana use, and serious drug addiction, particularly through the ongoing storyline of Olivia Baker. It explores the struggles, consequences, and recovery processes associated with substance abuse.

Would these 3 concerns matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium4
Romance and Sexual ContentProfanityScary & Intense ContentDisrespect & Rebellion
Low2
Witchcraft & OccultAnti-Christian Themes
Medium4

Romance and Sexual Content

The show incorporates numerous romantic storylines and moderate sexual content, including passionate kissing and implied sexual activity. While broadcast television standards prevent explicit depiction, the presence of suggestive themes and discussions about romantic and sexual relationships is consistent throughout the series.

Profanity

Profanity is regularly used throughout the series, aligning with its TV-14 rating. While the most explicit words may be censored or less common on broadcast television, a range of mild to strong curse words and strong language are present in character dialogues.

Scary & Intense Content

While not a horror show, "All American" contains intense and emotionally charged content, particularly stemming from the pervasive threat of gang violence and the severe personal struggles of its characters. These situations can generate significant suspense and fear, especially when characters' lives are directly imperiled.

Disrespect & Rebellion

The series frequently portrays acts of disrespect and rebellion from its teenage and young adult characters towards authority figures, including parents, coaches, and school rules. This manifests as backtalk, defiance, and independent decision-making that often leads to challenging consequences.

Low2

Witchcraft & Occult

There is no indication of witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, spells, or any supernatural elements within the "All American" series. It is a realistic sports drama focused on contemporary human experiences and societal issues.

Anti-Christian Themes

"All American" does not exhibit overt anti-Christian themes. While there is a storyline involving a character, Coop, whose lesbian identity is not accepted by her church-going mother, this is presented as a personal conflict within the family, not as a condemnation of Christianity itself. The series also includes positive portrayals of faith and community within a church setting.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

All American presents a compelling, albeit complex, landscape for Christian parents to navigate, touching upon numerous societal issues with both alignment and divergence from biblical values. Core themes like the pursuit of dreams, overcoming adversity, and the strength of community resonate with Christian principles of perseverance and mutual support. The series commendably explores racial injustice, class disparities, and the nuanced experiences of Black youth in America, fostering empathy and a call for justice that aligns with Christian teachings. However, the show often operates within a relativistic worldview, where moral boundaries can appear fluid. While destructive behaviors like drug addiction and gang violence are depicted with negative consequences, reflecting a natural law of cause and effect, other character choices, including instances of infidelity, teen pregnancies, and the acceptance of diverse sexual orientations, may contradict traditional biblical sexual ethics. The narrative highlights the repercussions of poor choices, but the framework for moral accountability is often secular, focusing on personal growth and societal acceptance rather than a transcendent moral standard. Regarding themes of redemption, the series showcases characters striving to overcome personal struggles and make sacrifices for others, embodying aspects of selflessness. Spencer's "savior complex" and his consistent efforts to uplift his community, alongside a notable instance of a character sacrificing their life for a child, reflect redemptive acts, though these are typically portrayed without explicit theological grounding. Family values are a central pillar, illustrating both the resilience and fragility of familial bonds. Parents are generally depicted as loving and protective, striving to guide their children, which aligns with biblical emphasis on family. However, the show also candidly portrays family dysfunction, including absentee fathers, marital infidelity, and challenges to traditional gender roles within relationships. While overt faith representation is not a primary focus, there are brief, respectful depictions, such as a mother actively involved in her church choir. Conversely, one specific storyline involving a cross necklace used to conceal drugs might be perceived as irreverent or disrespectful by Christian viewers. Ultimately, All American offers numerous opportunities for discussion on human struggles, choices, and the pursuit of a meaningful life, requiring parental discernment to filter its messages through a biblical lens.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

TV-14. This recommendation is based on the show's consistent depiction of mature themes including gang violence, substance abuse, sexual content, and strong language. These topics are often presented with a level of intensity and realism that requires a more mature understanding and can be better processed with parental guidance for viewers aged 14 and older.

Good to Know

The series' official TV parental rating is TV-14 with content descriptors that include sequences of violence, suggestive dialogue, and crude language. The spin-off, "All American: Homecoming," shares similar thematic elements and age-appropriateness. Parents should be aware that the show delves into complex social issues, including gang violence, drug and alcohol addiction, and racism, which are treated with realism and can be intense. These elements provide potential discussion opportunities for mature teens, but consistent parental guidance is recommended.

How does this review compare?

This review
  • 9 standard concerns
  • General sensitivity level
  • One-size-fits-all perspective
Your report
  • Concerns you choose
  • Sensitivity levels you set
  • Tailored to your family

What are you watching next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly
Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families