A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Here's what we found in A Good Girl's Guide to Murder. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.
Screen for YOUR familyParent's Guide to A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder (2024) is a British mystery thriller series adapted from Holly Jackson's bestselling young adult novel. The series follows Pippa 'Pip' Fitz-Amobi, a diligent high school student who, for her senior project, decides to re-investigate the closed case of Andie Bell's murder. Five years prior, Andie's boyfriend, Sal Singh, was accused of her murder and subsequently died by suicide, leading the town to believe the case was solved. Pip, however, suspects there's more to the story and embarks on a journey to uncover the truth, which leads her into a dangerous web of secrets and lies in her seemingly idyllic small town. The show is geared towards a young adult audience, specifically older teens, and delves into mature and intense themes surrounding crime and its consequences.
Things to Consider
Violence
Violence is a central and pervasive theme, revolving around a murder mystery. The series includes discussions of murder, suicide, sexual assault, self-harm, kidnapping, and physical threats. While much of the violence is implied or discussed, rather than graphically depicted, there are visual instances of injuries.
The entire plot is driven by the unsolved murder of Andie Bell and the presumed murder-suicide of Sal Singh, with detailed discussions of these deaths. Pip encounters significant physical peril, including being drugged and nearly strangled to death by Becca. A scene contains 'strong images of a bloody head injury'. The narrative also includes instances of self-harm and discussions of suicide.
Romance and Sexual Content
The series includes frequent discussions and plot points related to sexual content, although explicit sexual acts or nudity are generally not shown on screen. Key themes include sexual assault (drugging at parties), underage sex, inappropriate relationships between adults and minors, and leaked nude photos. There are also occasional mild sex references and romantic kissing.
Profanity
Profanity is frequently present throughout the dialogue, often by teen characters. Multiple sources confirm the use of strong language, including 'f-words' and 's-words,' as well as other expletives and milder curse words.
Substance Use
Substance use is a significant and recurring element of the plot. The series depicts frequent underage drinking at parties and features illegal drug use, including ketamine and Rohypnol, with the latter being central to sexual assault plotlines. Drug dealing is also an integral part of the mystery being investigated.
Scary & Intense Content
The series features highly intense and scary content derived from its central murder mystery. This includes discussions of death, suicide, kidnapping, death threats, and pervasive psychological manipulation. The protagonist, Pip, is frequently placed in life-threatening situations and experiences significant emotional and psychological distress.
Would these 5 concerns matter to your family?
Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
The series features explicit LGBTQ+ representation through several characters. Pip's best friend, Cara Ward, is openly gay and has a romantic storyline. Another character, Jesse Walker, is subtly presented as non-binary, using they/them pronouns. This representation is integrated naturally without significant conflict or drama.
Disrespect & Rebellion
Disrespect and rebellion are prominent, largely through the protagonist Pip's actions. She consistently defies warnings from authority figures, including teachers and anonymous threats, to pursue her investigation. While often driven by a sense of justice, her methods involve breaking rules, lying, and challenging established systems.
Witchcraft & Occult
Minimal and non-active portrayal of occult themes. The series includes a brief mention of a Ouija board being brought along by characters for 'creepy fun' during a camping trip, but they ultimately do not use it on screen.
Anti-Christian Themes
The series does not contain explicit anti-Christian themes. There are no instances of mockery, criticism, or negative portrayals of Christian beliefs or practices. One review noted a 'mixed pagan worldview' due to non-Christian elements like a Ouija board, but this was not depicted as actively used or anti-Christian in nature.
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder centers on the pursuit of truth and justice, which aligns with biblical principles of righteousness and advocating for the innocent. Pip's unwavering determination to uncover what truly happened to Sal Singh and Andie Bell reflects a strong moral compass that seeks to expose hidden wickedness. However, the methods employed by Pip often involve deception, breaking rules, and placing herself in perilous situations, which raise questions from a Christian perspective regarding wisdom, obedience to governing authorities (where not in conflict with God's law), and integrity. The series depicts a world where human corruption and secrets abound, echoing the biblical understanding of a fallen world, but the solutions presented are primarily humanistic, relying on individual intellect and persistence rather than divine intervention or moral transformation through faith. The show’s portrayal of morality is complex; while good intentions often drive Pip, her actions can blur ethical lines. Characters are rewarded for cunning and perseverance in solving the mystery, and vice, such as murder, sexual assault, and drug dealing, is clearly condemned, demonstrating a secular form of moral accountability. Redemption is explored through the clearing of Sal's name and the exposure of the true perpetrators, reflecting a desire for wrongs to be made right. However, concepts of spiritual grace, divine forgiveness, or ultimate spiritual redemption are absent. Family values are presented as varied, with Pip's supportive parents contrasting with other dysfunctional or abusive family units, highlighting the brokenness that can pervade society. Christian faith is not explicitly represented in the narrative, leaving a vacuum where biblical answers to suffering, justice, and moral dilemmas might otherwise be explored, and instead leaning on a secular, often relativistic, worldview.
Additional Context
Best For Ages
TV-MA (17+). While some outlets suggest 14+, the official TV Parental Guidelines rating is TV-MA, indicating content suitable for mature audiences. This is due to pervasive mature themes including violence, sexual assault, drug use, self-harm, and psychological manipulation, which may be too intense for younger viewers. Parents should exercise caution and consider co-viewing with older teens.
Good to Know
The series, based on a popular YA book, often presents mature themes in a way that is less graphically explicit than adult crime dramas, but the sheer volume and nature of these themes still warrant a mature rating. The show highlights the importance of critical thinking and seeking justice, but also explores the moral ambiguities inherent in such a pursuit.
What are you watching next?
Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.
No credit card required — join hundreds of families