The School for Good and Evil
The School for Good and Evil series is a young adult fantasy saga that reimagines classic fairy tales through a dark and thought-provoking lens. It introduces readers to a magical academy where aspiring heroes and villains are trained to maintain the balance between good and evil. The narrative centers on two unlikely best friends, Sophie and Agatha, whose destinies are seemingly reversed when Sophie is sent to the School for Evil and Agatha to the School for Good. This initial misplacement sparks a journey of self-discovery, challenging preconceived notions of good and evil as they navigate complex friendships, rivalries, and a looming threat to their world. Targeted towards middle-grade and young adult readers, the series delves into themes of identity, friendship, loyalty, and the gray areas of morality. It encourages readers to question traditional archetypes and understand that true goodness or evil is not always as it appears. The stories feature magic, adventure, and intense conflicts, evolving into a sweeping epic across multiple volumes as the characters mature and the stakes escalate, suitable for those who enjoy a twist on conventional fantasy narratives.
Concerns
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
HighThe series incorporates subtle and explicit LGBTQ+ themes and characters. The author, Soman Chainani, is openly gay and aims to include diverse representation, often using 'showing not telling' to imply queer characters and relationships for a younger audience. This includes challenging traditional romantic tropes and introducing gender identity exploration in later books.
In the first book, Agatha revives Sophie with a 'True Love's Kiss,' which is shared between the two best friends, challenging the traditional heterosexual fairy tale trope. In the second book, a minor character named Tristan, originally a prince, takes a potion to transform into a girl and join the School for Girls, subtly portrayed as a trans girl. Additionally, Sophie transforms into a boy named Filip, and Prince Tedros develops a crush on 'Filip,' suggesting themes of bisexuality that are not explicitly addressed later.
Violence
HighThe series features significant fantastical violence, including intense magical combat, physical attacks, and death. Descriptions can be graphic, detailing magical transformations, injuries, and fatalities. The film adaptation is described as 'intensely violent' with a 'violent final act' and plentiful blood and gore.
Characters are involved in fantastical conflicts where they are 'stabbed, shot with arrows, tossed around, subject to magical transformations, burned with magical fire, and attacked with 'blood magic''. A prominent example includes the killing of Rafal with Excalibur by Agatha, with assistance from Sophie and Tedros. There is also a scene depicting a beast being cut in half.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighWitchcraft, magic, and occult practices are fundamental to the premise of The School for Good and Evil, as characters are trained as either heroes or villains using magical abilities. 'Blood magic' is explicitly featured as a dark and powerful force.
The School for Evil explicitly teaches students 'the dark arts,' including 'casting spells, kidnapping and causing suffering.' A significant example of occult content is the use of 'blood magic' by antagonists like Rafal, which is depicted as a powerful and forbidden magic capable of controlling human blood and incapacitating others.
Anti-Christian Themes
HighChristian review outlets identify significant anti-Christian themes. The series deconstructs traditional Christian morality and presents a worldview that contrasts with biblical ideals regarding sin, redemption, and the nature of good and evil.
The narrative's premise suggests that individuals are born with fixed 'good' or 'evil' souls and are unable to change their fundamental nature, which is presented as defying 'the need for a Redeemer' from a Christian perspective. The story also 'does away with the normal Christian notions of redemption and holding oneself accountable for one's transgressions' by deconstructing traditional morality and presenting a more ambiguous view of good and evil.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe books and film include various romantic relationships, kisses, and suggestive descriptions. While some romance is typical for young adult fantasy, one instance in the book describes a 13-year-old character in a manner that concerned parents and reviewers due to its sexualized nature. The True Love's Kiss between Sophie and Agatha also functions as a romantic element in challenging traditional norms.
A Reddit discussion highlights concerns from parents regarding descriptions of the 13-year-old character Sophie, particularly around page 250 of the book, where she is described in 'revealing clothing' showing 'creamy thighs' when attempting to impress Prince Tedros. The story features kisses between Sophie and Tedros, and Agatha and Tedros, alongside the significant 'True Love's Kiss' shared between Sophie and Agatha.
Profanity
MediumThe film adaptation contains some coarse language, including a few obscenities and light profanities. While not excessively frequent or consistently strong, its presence warrants a medium severity rating for younger audiences.
Parental reviews for the film note approximately 'six obscenities (including one 's' word)' and '16 light profanities' used throughout the dialogue. While specific quotes from the book are not provided in the search results, the film's rating indicates similar language expectations for the book's target audience.
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe narrative features numerous scary and intense scenes, including frightening creatures, dangerous magical encounters, and life-threatening situations. The author intended a 'Game of Thrones' like feel, ensuring readers feel suspense and unpredictability. The film is rated PG-13 due to 'frightening images' and intense action.
The protagonists, Sophie and Agatha, are kidnapped by a 'giant stymph,' a monstrous bird-like creature, and violently transported to the school. Intense scenes include magical battles and a 'chilling scene where a young man is agonizingly disintegrated by magic,' contributing to the overall frightening atmosphere.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumDisrespect and rebellion are prevalent themes, as the main characters frequently challenge authority, question established rules, and defy expectations. This is central to the narrative's exploration of good versus evil and individual agency.
Agatha often displays disrespect for the superficiality of the School for Good, openly critiquing its values and norms. Sophie consistently rebels against her placement in the School for Evil, manipulating situations and attempting to subvert the school's structure to achieve her own desires, often directly defying directives from school staff.
Substance Use
LowThe series contains very limited and non-graphic instances of substance use. One notable example includes a character drinking from a flask and appearing to be under the influence.
A character in the film adaptation is observed drinking from a flask and exhibits signs of intoxication, though this is not a central plot point or a recurring theme.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Ages 11-13+ with parental guidance. The book series, similar to its film adaptation, contains themes of intense violence, dark magic, complex moral dilemmas, and instances of suggestive content and LGBTQ+ representation. While suitable for mature middle-grade readers, the depth and nature of some content warrant discussion and guidance from parents.
Additional Notes
The content analysis draws primarily from discussions and reviews of the first book in 'The School for Good and Evil' series and its Netflix film adaptation, as many parental guidance details are often consolidated around initial releases. While the film may diverge in specific plot points, the core themes and types of content are largely consistent with the underlying book series. Content intensity may evolve or be further explored in subsequent books of the series.
Related Reviews
Is The School for Good and Evil right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required