A Crystal of Time
A Crystal of Time is the fifth installment in Soman Chainani's New York Times bestselling fantasy series, The School for Good and Evil, a twisted fairy tale saga. The narrative plunges readers into a perilous quest where main characters Sophie, Agatha, and their friends must navigate a world of political intrigue and dark magic to overthrow a false king who has seized Camelot's throne and sentenced the true king, Tedros, to death. The story follows Agatha's desperate efforts to restore Tedros and save Camelot, while Sophie is forced into a dangerous game as the usurper's queen, with her friends' lives hanging in the balance. This middle-grade/young adult book, approximately 624-688 pages long, is characterized by its blend of adventure, magic, romance, and humor, targeting readers from ages 11-14 with themes of truth versus lies and the complexities of good and evil.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains significant violence, including threats of execution, battles, and death. Characters face perilous situations, and the overarching plot involves a violent struggle for power with high stakes. The intensity of violence is noted to increase in later installments of the series.
The plot centers on King Rhian sentencing 'Tedros to death,' a recurring threat throughout the narrative. The book also features 'deaths in this tale' and describes Japeth as a 'psycho' who 'killed his brother'. Another scene involves Japeth using Sophie's blood to heal his injuries, highlighting a darker and dangerous form of magic intertwined with violent acts.
Romance and Sexual Content
HighRomantic relationships are a central element, involving kissing and deep emotional bonds between teenage characters. The book also contains a significant, albeit non-explicit, plot point involving magical non-consensual pregnancy, which elevates the severity of this concern.
Agatha and Tedros share a 'deep love for each other,' including 'brief kissing and hugging when reunited'. Sophie is 'trapped to become Rhian's queen,' with her wedding 'fast approaching,' indicating forced romantic entanglement. A content warning for the series mentions 'a scene where someone uses dark magic to become non-consensually pregnant (note that there is no sex involved, but still...)'.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighWitchcraft and magic are fundamental to the world and plot of 'A Crystal of Time.' Characters are trained in magic, and both good and dark magic are actively practiced, influencing major plot points and character fates.
The narrative is set within 'The School for Good and Evil,' where students, including main characters, are trained as 'witches and princesses, warlocks and princes'. Dean Dovey possesses and teaches about a magical crystal that reveals fragmented pasts and possible futures. Additionally, 'dark magic' is utilized by characters like Japeth, who uses Sophie's blood for healing.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book features a high degree of suspense, perilous situations, and disturbing imagery suitable for its middle-grade fantasy genre but potentially intense for younger readers. It includes explicit threats to life, battles, and the presence of grotesque magical creatures.
The plot involves 'King Rhian's dark plans for Camelot taking shape' and characters facing 'perilous moments' and 'high stakes'. The story includes the death of a significant character, Dean Clarissa Dovey. Additionally, creatures like 'stymphs' are described as 'ginormous bird[s] with no skin or flesh. It is practically a skeleton that is alive,' which can be frightening imagery.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe series, including discussions around 'A Crystal of Time' and subsequent books, features casual diversity and upending of expected gender roles. Specific mentions in fan communities and reviews of later books in the series indicate the presence of LGBTQ characters and themes, including a character identified as 'into guys' and another whose bisexuality/pansexuality is acknowledged by the author.
A Goodreads comment explicitly states, 'JA. PETH'S. INTO GUYS. JAPETH'S INTO GUYS.' for the character Japeth. Additionally, a review for 'One True King,' the sixth book in the series, mentions that 'Tedros' bisexuality/pansexuality' is validated, having been 'fanon since Book 2,' and that 'same-sex relationships are recognised and there was also a brief discussion of gender fluidity' in the series.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumDisrespect and rebellion are central themes, as the protagonists actively work to overthrow a 'false king' and defy established authority they deem unjust. This is portrayed as a necessary action to restore balance and truth.
The main characters, Agatha and the students of the School for Good and Evil, 'must find a way to overthrow the sinister evil that twists lies into the truth' and 'restore Tedros to the throne' from a usurper king. Sophie, while seemingly trapped, 'plays a dangerous game' and shows 'a shine of rebellion,' strategically outmaneuvering Rhian to protect her friends.
Profanity
LowNo explicit instances of strong profanity or frequent mild curse words were identified in summaries or reviews for 'A Crystal of Time.' The language appears to remain consistent with middle-grade fantasy expectations.
While specific searches for profanity were conducted, no direct examples of curse words or strong language within 'A Crystal of Time' were found in the provided search results. A review for a different book by a different author mentioned a character using 'shitty things' and mocking faith, but this does not apply to 'A Crystal of Time'.
Substance Use
LowThere is no indication of substance use, such as alcohol, drugs, or smoking, explicitly depicted or as a notable theme within 'A Crystal of Time' based on the available content reviews.
Specific searches for alcohol, drugs, and smoking within the context of 'A Crystal of Time' did not yield any relevant results. An unrelated book review mentioned a character with 'drug and drink problem[s],' but this information pertains to a different title and author.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes or direct mockery of Christian beliefs were found in the available content analysis for 'A Crystal of Time.' The narrative explores themes of good and evil within a fantasy, fairytale context, focusing on universal moral dilemmas rather than specific religious doctrines.
The core conflict of the series revolves around abstract concepts of 'Good and Evil,' 'truth versus lies,' and moral ambiguity within a fairytale world. There were no search results indicating any direct criticism or negative portrayal of Christian faith or symbols related to this specific book.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Recommended for ages 12-14+. While publishers often list an age range of 8-12, the content, especially in this fifth installment, is noted to be more mature than earlier books in the series. It features themes of death, intense violence, complex moral dilemmas, and some suggestive romantic elements, along with a controversial magical pregnancy plot point that may be more suitable for older middle-grade readers or younger young adults.
Additional Notes
The 'School for Good and Evil' series tends to evolve in complexity and intensity with each installment, with 'A Crystal of Time' being the fifth book. Parents should be aware that the content generally becomes more mature, delving into deeper moral ambiguities and more intense situations than the initial books. The overarching series by Soman Chainani is known for its nuanced characters and relationships, including a strong emphasis on friendship. Readers unfamiliar with previous books may find the plot convoluted due to the ongoing narrative arcs.
Related Reviews
Is A Crystal of Time right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required