A World Without Princes
A World Without Princes is the second installment in Soman Chainani's popular Middle Grade/Young Adult fantasy series, The School for Good and Evil. The story picks up after protagonists Sophie and Agatha have returned home, seemingly achieving their 'happily ever after.' However, a wish to change the past sends them back to the magical Endless Woods, where the School for Good and Evil has been dramatically transformed. Instead of schools for Good and Evil, there are now separate institutions for boys and girls, locked in a fierce, gender-divided conflict. The narrative explores evolving dynamics of friendship, love, and identity amidst this new, chaotic world, challenging traditional fairy tale tropes and examining gender roles. The book is known for its darker tone compared to the first installment and delves into complex relationships and moral ambiguities, making it suitable for readers who enjoy a blend of magical adventure and thematic depth.
Concerns
Disrespect & Rebellion
HighThis book features significant themes of disrespect and rebellion, particularly concerning gender roles and societal expectations. The transformed schools foster an environment of animosity between boys and girls, with explicit instances of one gender advocating for the subjugation or elimination of the other.
The School for Girls takes 'feminism to a tyrannical level by teaching the students that boys are the scum of the earth and should be enslaved,' directly promoting extreme disrespect and rebellion against the male gender. The narrative portrays princesses 'smashing out of her glass coffin with her fists,' and 'Red Riding Hood slitting the wolf's throat,' illustrating a widespread rebellion against traditional, submissive female roles.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book subtly introduces LGBTQ+ themes through character relationships and gender fluidity. There are implied romantic feelings between same-sex characters, and a character undergoes a gender transformation. The author, Soman Chainani, is openly gay and uses 'showing not telling' to integrate these themes, though explicit LGBTQ+ terminology is not used within the narrative.
The series includes 'two same-sex kisses' across its run, with reviewers noting that the author 'never mentions the words "lesbian" or "gay" even though it's such a huge part of the narrative' regarding the bond between Agatha and Sophie. The minor character Tristan is subtly portrayed as a trans girl, who takes a potion to transform and join the School for Girls, seeking happiness in wearing dresses and makeup rather than conforming to prince expectations.
Violence
MediumThe book contains moderate fantasy violence, including fight scenes, descriptions of minor injuries, and a narrative where princesses act violently against princes. The setting of the transformed schools pits boys and girls against each other, leading to thematic and depicted conflicts.
In the altered world, 'Princesses kill/evict their princes,' and the School for Girls advocates for extreme measures like teaching students that 'boys are the scum of the earth and should be enslaved.' Descriptions include 'fighting and some description of blood and stabbing,' with 'arrows fly at characters and the two main characters often get hurt throughout the story,' though graphic violence is noted as largely absent.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumRomance is a central plot element, primarily revolving around a complex love triangle involving Sophie, Agatha, and Prince Tedros. This includes strong emotional bonds, implied romantic feelings between girls, and at least one described kissing scene. The focus is on emotional choices and relationships rather than explicit sexual content.
The book features a 'real love triangle' between Sophie, Agatha, and Tedros, with discussions among reviewers about Agatha having to 'choose between Sophie and Tedros' or the potential for a 'bisexual love triangle.' There is 'a kissing scene that isn't really described in detail' between characters.
Profanity
MediumThe book contains occasional mild to moderate profanity. Specific words such as 'ass' and 'hell' are mentioned to be used sparingly within the text. Reviewers also use strong language to describe their critical perspectives on the book's themes.
The words 'ass' and 'hell' are stated to be used 'a few times (at most) throughout the whole story.' While external reviews use stronger terms like 'bullsh*t' and 'f*cking sh*tty' to express dismay over the book's thematic content, these are reviewer comments, not direct quotes from the book's characters.
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumWitchcraft and magic are fundamental to the narrative, as the story is set in a magical 'School for Good and Evil' where characters learn spells, curses, and develop supernatural abilities. These elements are integral to the fantasy world-building and character development, not presented as real-world occult practices.
The entire premise of the series revolves around students being trained in magical arts at the 'School for Good and Evil' to fulfill roles in fairy tales. Sophie actively battles 'her own witch impulses' and fears her latent dark magical capabilities, indicating the presence and influence of magic on character actions and internal conflict.
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe book features a darker tone and intense plot developments compared to its predecessor. It includes high-stakes conflicts, betrayal, and a chaotic world where established norms are overturned. While graphic horror is minimal, the narrative creates suspense and portrays life-threatening situations for the protagonists.
The fairy tale world is plunged into 'chaos' with the schools divided by gender, leading to a 'dangerous enemy' emerging and Sophie and Agatha battling to 'restore peace,' creating an atmosphere of constant threat and intensity. Characters face 'life-threatening situations' as a direct consequence of the ongoing conflicts and power struggles within the transformed schools.
Substance Use
LowThere is no direct evidence or mention of characters engaging in substance use such as alcohol, drugs, or smoking within the book's narrative. Mentions of 'addiction' in search results were related to reviewer commentary on real-world issues, not content within 'A World Without Princes.'
No instances were found where characters like Sophie or Agatha consume alcohol, use illegal drugs, or engage in smoking. The narrative does not include themes or scenes involving substance abuse.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes or content were identified in the available information. The concepts of 'Good' and 'Evil' are explored within a fantastical, fairy-tale framework, focusing on moral choices and character development rather than religious doctrines or criticisms of Christianity.
The story's core conflict revolves around the philosophical nature of 'Good' and 'Evil' as applied to fairy tale characters and their destinies, without referencing or disparaging Christian beliefs or practices. There are no reported instances of characters mocking Christian symbols, figures, or engaging in sacrilegious acts.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
A World Without Princes is recommended for ages 10-11 and up. This recommendation is based on its classification as Middle Grade/Young Adult fantasy and content that includes moderate violence, intense thematic conflicts, implied LGBTQ+ representation, and discussions of complex gender roles that may be better understood by pre-teen and early teenage readers.
Additional Notes
Parents should be aware that while the book is categorized as Middle Grade/Young Adult, it addresses complex themes of identity, gender roles, and relationships, which can be points for discussion. The portrayal of extreme gender conflict and the subtle LGBTQ+ themes may require parental guidance depending on the family's values. Some reviewers noted that the book's message about feminism and gender dynamics could be confusing or problematic, presenting 'wrong messages' without clear distinction between feminism and misandry.
Related Reviews
Is A World Without Princes right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required