House of Salt and Sorrows
House of Salt and Sorrows is a gothic Young Adult (YA) fantasy novel by Erin A. Craig, a dark retelling of 'The Twelve Dancing Princesses.' Set in a manor by the sea, the story follows Annaleigh, one of twelve sisters, as she grapples with the mysterious deaths of four of her siblings. Whispers of a family curse by the gods circulate through the villages, and Annaleigh begins to suspect foul play rather than accidents. The narrative weaves elements of mystery, romance, and psychological horror as Annaleigh investigates the truth behind her sisters' nightly escapades to glittering, yet sinister, balls. The book is intended for mature YA readers, generally recommended for ages 14-16 and up, due to its dark and eerie atmosphere, supernatural themes, and instances of violence.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe novel contains moderate to high levels of violence, primarily revolving around mysterious deaths, graphic descriptions of injuries, and situations of peril. The plot is driven by the tragic deaths of several sisters, described with unsettling details.
Four of Annaleigh's sisters die under tragic circumstances, including "the plague, a plummeting fall, a drowning, a slippery plunge." Reviewers note "pretty graphic" descriptions, including "semi graphic descriptions of animal and human bodies after death." Sketches depicting dead girls include "details alluding to the manner of their deaths (an obviously broken neck, for example)." Additionally, tentacled arms grab a girl in the water, creating a situation of physical peril.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighWitchcraft and occult themes are central and pervasive, featuring explicit magic, curses, ghostly phenomena, and a polytheistic religion. The narrative heavily relies on supernatural elements, including gods, trickster deities, and demonic activity.
The sisters' family "worship the god of the sea, Pontus," and their lives revolve around this deity. The family is believed to be "cursed by the gods", with a specific "trickster deity" cursing the Thaumas family and a goddess manipulating events. Annaleigh experiences "ghostly visions" and she and a sister "see ghosts and encounter some haunting experiences." The book is described as having "magic" and "supernatural (demons and demonic activity)."
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe novel is intensely scary and atmospheric, incorporating strong gothic horror elements, psychological torment, and disturbing imagery. It aims to create a pervasive sense of dread and unease for the reader.
The book is described as "spooky, terrifying, oh-my-god-my-hands-are-still-trembling, gothic-elements, ghosts-and-curses" and "really scary and mind-bending." Psychological horror is explicitly mentioned, including a "nightmarish party with really gross food and drink served" and descriptions that "qualify as psychological horror." The main character experiences "doppelgangers/shapeshifters" and "unreliable narration where the book would make you second guess what you KNEW to be true," contributing to a feeling of dread and creepiness. The story also features the "Harbinger of Madness and Nightmares" and a goddess actively "manipulating their lives in ways to make the sisters go mad and kill themselves."
Anti-Christian Themes
HighThe book's world features a prominent polytheistic religious system where characters worship various gods, particularly Pontus, the god of the sea, who is central to their culture and burial traditions. This pervasive alternative religious framework, combined with explicit mentions of curses from deities and 'demonic activity,' presents content that could be considered anti-Christian.
Annaleigh and her family actively "worship the god of the sea, Pontus," with their culture and traditions, including burial rituals, anchored in this worship. The villagers believe the family is "cursed by the gods." The world includes a "pantheon of gods" and their opposites, the "Tricksters," one of whom curses the family and uses a goddess to manipulate the sisters. The presence of "Supernatural (demons and demonic activity)" is also noted as a key consideration.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumRomantic elements are present, featuring a slow-burn relationship with kissing and expressions of affection. There are no explicit sexual acts or graphic details, but implied romantic interest and emotional intimacy are central to the main character's storyline.
Annaleigh develops a "slow-burn, passionate, tender, and devoted love story" with Cassius. The book includes scenes of "kissing between boy and girl." Annaleigh is also "attracted to two different men," leading to some elements of jealousy, though it is not a traditional love triangle. One review mentions 'instalove,' where the relationship progresses quickly.
Substance Use
MediumThe book includes instances of social drinking, specifically champagne at parties, where some characters become intoxicated. This leads to inappropriate behavior from the drunk men.
The content notes explicitly state "Social drinking, such as champagne at a party." Furthermore, it notes that "At one party, several men get drunk and say cruel or inappropriate things to women there." This indicates casual alcohol consumption leading to negative social interactions, but no explicit drug use.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe narrative features elements of rebellion and defiance, particularly concerning the sisters' secret activities and challenging societal expectations. The protagonist, Annaleigh, actively questions authority and disobeys parental rules to investigate the mysteries surrounding her family.
The sisters repeatedly sneak out nightly to attend forbidden balls, directly defying their father and stepmother. Annaleigh's sister, Eulalie, was rumored to be planning to "elope with Edgar Morris, an apprentice at a clockmakers' shop, a man beneath her," indicating defiance of social class expectations and parental wishes. Annaleigh herself becomes increasingly suspicious that her sisters' deaths were not accidents and actively investigates, going against the family's desire to move on and overlooking potential murder.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowNo explicit LGBTQ+ or gender identity content, characters, or themes were identified in the provided search results for "House of Salt and Sorrows" or its author, Erin A. Craig. Multiple specific searches for LGBTQ+ representation yielded no relevant information.
Searches for terms such as 'House of Salt and Sorrows' with 'lgbtq', 'gay', 'lesbian', 'transgender', 'queer representation', 'LGBTQ characters', and 'Erin A. Craig lgbtq' did not return any specific examples or mentions of LGBTQ+ content within the book. The narrative primarily focuses on heterosexual romance and family dynamics.
Profanity
LowThe use of profanity is infrequent and generally mild. Reviewers indicate that any crude language present is not a pervasive element of the dialogue or narrative.
According to content notes, "Mild profanity used pretty infrequently." While one reviewer used a strong expletive to describe their own reaction to the book, this does not reflect the content of the book itself. The narrative's language is largely clean, with only occasional minor expletives.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Ages 14-16 and up. The book is a dark gothic fantasy retelling with significant horror elements, including psychological torment, graphic descriptions of death, and a pervasive sense of dread. Several sources recommend it for older teens due to its mature themes and intense content.
Additional Notes
The novel is a standalone book, though it is the first in a series (Sisters of the Salt). Reviews suggest the sequel, 'House of Roots and Ruin,' maintains a similar spooky atmosphere but specific content changes are not detailed in the provided information. The narrative includes themes of grief and family dynamics, with the protagonist often questioning her own sanity due to the psychological horror elements.
Related Reviews
Is House of Salt and Sorrows right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required