House of Roots and Ruin
"House of Roots and Ruin" is a gothic thriller-fantasy and the second book in Erin A. Craig's "Sisters of the Salt" series, though it can be read as a standalone. The narrative follows seventeen-year-old Verity Thaumas, who possesses the unique ability to see ghosts but is unaware of her gift. Driven by a desire for independence and an opportunity to paint a portrait, Verity leaves her family's ancestral home, Highmoor, for the grand estate of Bloem. There, she encounters Alexander Laurent, and a complex romance begins to unfold amidst the lush, yet unsettling, surroundings. However, Verity's new life is quickly overshadowed by disturbing nightmares and the unraveling of dark secrets hidden within Bloem. The story intricately weaves elements of mystery, suspense, and horror, exploring themes of doomed love, menacing ambition, and the lingering presence of past traumas and family secrets. The atmospheric setting and supernatural undertones contribute to a chilling and immersive experience, making it a compelling read for those who appreciate dark fantasy. This novel is generally targeted at young adult (YA) to new adult (NA) audiences, recommended for readers aged 14 and up due to its mature and graphic content.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe media features frequent and intense depictions of violence. Content warnings explicitly mention graphic violence, murder, torture, and gore, indicating a high level of disturbing imagery and thematic focus on brutal acts.
Content warnings for the book include 'graphic depictions of violence, death, murder, torture, gore.' There are 'descriptions of torture, references to assault, and some graphic descriptions of murder and attempted murder.' Trigger warnings also mention 'intense blood depictions, emesis, execution, gun violence, animal death and injury,' as well as 'body horror.'
Romance and Sexual Content
HighThe book includes both heterosexual and homosexual romantic relationships, alongside explicit sexual content. There are instances of kissing, vague references to sex, the discovery of pornographic materials, and a scene depicting sexual activity.
One of Verity's sisters is noted to have a 'secret romance with a woman.' The protagonist, Verity, engages in kissing with a male character. The book contains 'vague references to sex,' with one character, Alex, expressing worries about the possibility of sex. Notably, Verity 'discovers a secret bookshelf filled with pornographic books,' which she then 'briefly but explicitly describes.' Additionally, 'one scene shows a boy and girl having sex.'
Witchcraft & Occult
HighSupernatural elements are central to the plot, revolving around the protagonist's ability to see ghosts, curses, and interactions with the spirit world. The narrative incorporates gothic horror tropes and discussions of occult practices.
Verity, the protagonist, 'sees ghosts, but she can't tell which of the people she sees are ghosts and which are not,' making this a core aspect of her character and the story. The plot is noted to revolve around themes of 'seances, communing with spirits and an exorcism vibe.' The series is fundamentally a 'gothic thriller-fantasy' about 'ghosts that haunt us forever' and includes characters who are 'cursed.'
Substance Use
HighThe narrative includes references to social drinking, but also features more serious and non-consensual substance use, including poisons, hallucinogens, and opium, with instances of characters being forcibly drugged.
The book contains 'references to social drinking.' More significantly, characters are drugged 'through the use of poisons, hallucinogens, and opium.' Trigger warnings specifically highlight 'forced drugging' as a concern within the story.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book is consistently described as gothic horror/thriller with a high degree of scary and intense content. This includes graphic violence, body horror, psychological distress through nightmares and visions, and themes of possession and suicidal ideation.
Content warnings specify 'graphic depictions of violence, death, murder, torture, gore,' and 'body horror.' The protagonist, Verity, is 'plagued with nightmares' and experiences 'creepy situations, like what appear to be screaming women.' Trigger warnings for the book also mention 'mentions of prior suicide attempt, suicide ideation, mentions of potential self harm, being possessed.'
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book contains a confirmed instance of a same-sex romance involving one of the supporting characters, specifically one of Verity's sisters. Additionally, reader discussions suggest speculation about other characters' sexual orientations, such as Julien possibly being gay and Verity being perceived as asexual by some.
One of Verity's sisters has a secret romance with a woman. In a fan community discussion, a reader speculates about Julien, noting, 'Julien also came across to me as being possibly gay.' Another reader in the same discussion indicated 'how they thought Verity was asexual.'
Profanity
MediumThe book contains profanity, with some sources indicating infrequent, mild use and others suggesting slightly stronger language. This places the overall intensity at a moderate level rather than being pervasive or overtly offensive.
One content review states 'Mild profanity used infrequently.' However, other audience notes describe the language as 'a little strong' or 'some strong,' suggesting a moderate presence of curse words throughout the narrative.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumA significant plot point involves the protagonist, Verity, defying her older sister's authority and explicit prohibition to leave her home. This act of rebellion drives the initial narrative and sets the stage for her journey.
Verity 'flees Highmoor' against the express wishes of her older sister, Camille, who 'forbids her to leave.' Verity 'takes her future into her own hands' despite Camille's warnings, demonstrating a clear act of defiance central to the story's beginning.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowThe spiritual content of the book is rooted in gothic fantasy elements such as ghosts, curses, and supernatural phenomena rather than engaging with or disparaging Christian themes. No explicit anti-Christian content was identified.
The book's spiritual content primarily focuses on Verity's ability to 'see ghosts,' which she struggles to distinguish from living people, establishing a non-Christian supernatural framework. The narrative style is consistently described as 'gothic thriller-fantasy' and involves elements of 'curses' and haunting, all within a fantasy context without targeting Christian beliefs.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Recommended for ages 14 and up. This recommendation is based on the book's classification as YA/NA gothic thriller-fantasy, which includes graphic depictions of violence, murder, torture, body horror, mature romantic and explicit sexual content, and the presence of significant substance use and intense supernatural themes.
Additional Notes
The book is a companion novel to "House of Salt and Sorrows," meaning it can be read as a standalone, but reading the first book may provide additional context for the family's history. The narrative includes representation of a character with a physical disability (Alexander Laurent uses a wheelchair).
Related Reviews
Is House of Roots and Ruin right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required