The Hawthorne Legacy
The Hawthorne Legacy is the second book in Jennifer Lynn Barnes' popular young adult mystery series, "The Inheritance Games." The story continues to follow Avery Grambs, a seemingly ordinary teenager who unexpectedly inherited the vast fortune of billionaire Tobias Hawthorne. As Avery delves deeper into the intricate puzzles and riddles left by the eccentric patriarch, she uncovers more family secrets and faces escalating threats to her life and inheritance. The narrative is characterized by its fast pace, numerous plot twists, and a constant sense of suspense and danger.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains significant violence, including attempted murder, kidnapping, gun violence, and explosions, though on-page descriptions are generally not gory. Threats against the main character are frequent, and past deaths are central to the plot.
Avery Grambs, the protagonist, experiences being shot at and constantly faces danger. The book includes trigger warnings for 'attempted murder,' 'gun violence,' 'plane explosion,' and 'kidnapping'. Additionally, a disturbing scene involves a bloody cow's heart being left in Avery's bedroom.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book features frequent intense and suspenseful situations, including attempted murder, explosions, gun violence, and kidnapping. Characters face constant threats and danger, and there are mentions of trauma and suicidal ideation, creating a high-stakes atmosphere.
The plot is described as having 'nonstop action' and keeping readers 'on their toes' with danger at every corner. Trigger warnings include 'kidnapping,' 'plane explosion,' 'gun violence,' 'death (on-page),' and 'suicidal ideation (mentioned)'. Avery also endures being shot at and is noted to be struggling with PTSD.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book features confirmed LGBTQ representation through side characters. Specifically, a lesbian couple from the previous book is present and shares a brief kiss.
Two side characters, a lesbian couple, are included in the narrative. There is a specific, brief scene depicting these two characters kissing. The trigger warnings for the book explicitly list 'WLW side characters' (women-loving-women).
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe book features a prominent love triangle with significant romantic tension and several kissing scenes, including one in a hot tub. There are allusions to sex and mentions of characters 'sleeping together,' but no explicit sexual acts are described. A scene involving 'strip bowling' is mentioned but is not graphic.
The narrative includes a love triangle involving Avery and two of the Hawthorne brothers, Jameson and Grayson, with multiple kissing scenes, one occurring in a hot tub. There are 'allusions to sex' and 'mentions of casually "sleeping" together' without explicit details. A scene where characters engage in 'strip bowling' is mentioned, but the main character only ends up without a shoe, and it is interrupted before going too far.
Profanity
MediumThe book contains moderate profanity. While some sources indicate 'very little' harsh swearing, others explicitly list specific mild to moderate curse words and note frequent use of 'substitute bad words' by characters.
The book is rated 'Moderate' for language, with 'around 25 uses of mild language, 11 uses of moderate language and a handful of uses of the name of Deity in vain'. Advisory notes also mention 'Coarse language' including 'sl** (2), bi*** (7), ass**** (4), pi** (2)' and 'Words used to replace coarse language (ship, duck, etc)'.
Substance Use
MediumThe book depicts underage alcohol consumption, with one character frequently drinking and another getting drunk. There are also mentions of past drug use, addiction, and rehabilitation.
One of the Hawthorne brothers frequently drinks, and another underage brother gets drunk at one point, which is presented as irresponsible. Trigger warnings explicitly list 'Alcohol consumption,' 'Alcoholism,' and 'Drug addiction (mentioned),' with references to 'being high and attending rehab for a drug addiction'. Past drug and alcohol use by a deceased character, Toby, is also referenced.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumCharacters, particularly Avery and the Hawthorne brothers, exhibit sass, wit, and defiance towards societal expectations and sometimes direct authority figures. This is often portrayed as cleverness and is integral to the plot's theme of unraveling complex games and challenging norms.
Avery is described as 'prickly, witty, and stubborn as a mule' with 'quippy one-liners that level even the snobbiest among them,' indicating a defiant personality. Jameson Hawthorne's philosophy, 'There are no rules that matter more than winning,' reflects a rebellious disregard for conventional boundaries in the pursuit of the games and mysteries.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowNo explicit witchcraft or occult themes were identified in Jennifer Lynn Barnes' "The Hawthorne Legacy." The book is consistently categorized as a young adult mystery/thriller, focusing on puzzles, inheritance, and family drama.
The genre of the book is consistently defined as Young Adult Mystery or Thriller across various reviews and summaries. There is no mention of magic, spells, supernatural entities, or occult practices in any of the content descriptions or trigger warnings.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes or content were identified in the search results. The book's narrative focuses entirely on a secular mystery and family drama.
The primary genre of 'The Hawthorne Legacy' is consistently identified as Young Adult Mystery/Thriller, and reviews focus on puzzles, inheritance, and character relationships. There is no mention of religious or anti-religious commentary or symbolism within the provided content summaries or critical reviews.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
14+ due to consistent themes of violence including attempted murder and gun violence, underage alcohol consumption, moderate profanity, and emotionally intense situations involving danger and trauma. While some platforms suggest 12+, the mature content warrants a higher age recommendation for parental guidance.
Additional Notes
Parents should be aware that the book, while marketed as YA, deals with complex and intense themes that could be unsettling for younger readers. The portrayal of underage drinking and references to past drug addiction, combined with the high-stakes violence and psychological intensity, warrant careful consideration. The series progresses with increasing complexity and potential emotional impact.
Related Reviews
Is The Hawthorne Legacy right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required