The Giver
The Giver is a poignant young adult dystopian novel by Lois Lowry, set in a seemingly utopian community that has eliminated pain, conflict, and individuality through a system called "Sameness." The story follows Jonas, a twelve-year-old boy, as he is selected to become the next Receiver of Memory, the sole individual entrusted with holding the collective memories of humanity from before "Sameness." Through his training with the current Receiver, known as The Giver, Jonas uncovers the profound truths of human experience, including joy, love, suffering, and war, which have been deliberately suppressed from his community. This revelation forces Jonas to confront the moral implications of his society's existence and question its carefully constructed reality. The novel explores themes of memory, choice, individuality versus conformity, and the importance of both pain and pleasure in a fully lived life. It is intended for a young adult audience but is widely read and discussed by readers of all ages due to its deep philosophical and ethical questions.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe Giver contains significant themes of violence, primarily through the institutionalized practice of 'release,' which is a euphemism for euthanasia and infanticide. While not graphically depicted in a bloody manner, the acts themselves are stark and disturbing, showcasing a society's controlled elimination of its members.
Jonas learns that 'release' means a lethal injection. He witnesses his own father calmly administer a lethal injection to a newchild twin who is deemed too small, and then disposes of the body, revealing the horrifying truth of government-sponsored murder. The Giver transmits memories of war to Jonas, including graphic descriptions of suffering and dying soldiers, which deeply traumatize Jonas with the reality of human brutality.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe Giver contains highly intense and psychologically disturbing content, particularly concerning the true nature of the community's practices. The revelation of infanticide and euthanasia, coupled with Jonas's experiences of memories of war, pain, and suffering, can be deeply unsettling for readers.
The most intense content revolves around the discovery that 'release' is a euphemism for death, including the infanticide of infants who do not meet the community's standards and the euthanasia of the elderly. Jonas experiences profound psychological distress when he receives memories of extreme human suffering, such as the horrors of war (e.g., dying soldiers crying for water) and the agony of starvation.
Disrespect & Rebellion
HighDisrespect and rebellion are central and positive themes in The Giver, as Jonas's journey involves a growing defiance against the oppressive rules and philosophy of his community. His actions, driven by a desire for genuine human experience, challenge the entire societal structure.
Jonas's ultimate act of defiance is his decision to flee the community with the newchild Gabriel, directly violating the rules and risking his own life to restore true memories and emotions to humanity. Jonas deliberately stops taking his daily medication to suppress 'the Stirrings,' choosing to embrace his emotions and individuality against the explicit regulations of the Elders.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe novel portrays a heteronormative and cissexist society where relationships are arranged exclusively between a male and a female. The concept of individual gender and sexual identity is suppressed through societal conditioning and mandatory medication. While no explicit LGBTQ characters are present, the themes of suppressed individuality and choice deeply resonate with allegorical interpretations from the LGBTQ community, who see parallels in Jonas's struggle against "Sameness."
The Community's rules dictate that matches are arranged solely between a 'man and a woman' for the purpose of creating 'family units,' completely bypassing natural romantic or sexual attraction. All citizens are required to take daily pills to suppress 'the Stirrings,' which are identified as sexual feelings, thereby enforcing a state of 'pseudo-heteroromantic asexuality' within the society. One Reddit user explicitly noted that Jonas's struggles against the imposed 'sameness' mirrored their own personal experience of coming out as LGBTQ, highlighting a significant allegorical connection within the fan community.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe novel centrally features the suppression of romance and sexual feelings. Jonas experiences a significant internal struggle with nascent sexual desires, known as 'the Stirrings,' which are then medically controlled by the community. Romantic relationships, as understood in a free society, are non-existent, replaced by arranged pairings for societal function.
Jonas experiences 'the Stirrings,' described as a dream where he desires to bathe his friend Fiona, admitting, 'I wanted it so terribly'. Following this experience, his parents instruct him to begin taking a daily pill to suppress these feelings, which all adults in the community do. The society lacks any concept of dating or freely chosen romantic relationships; spouses are 'matched' by the Elders based on compatibility for the practical purpose of establishing 'family units,' devoid of love or sexual intimacy.
Substance Use
MediumSubstance use is present through the mandatory daily medication taken by all citizens to suppress emotions and sexual 'Stirrings.' Additionally, 'release' is performed via lethal injection, representing a controlled use of a substance for euthanasia.
All community members, including Jonas, are required to take a daily pill to suppress 'the Stirrings,' which are powerful emotional and sexual feelings, ensuring emotional neutrality and conformity. The process of 'release' involves administering a lethal injection, as witnessed by Jonas when his father 'releases' a newchild, which constitutes a state-sanctioned drug for ending life.
Profanity
LowThe Giver contains very little to no explicit profanity. The society values 'precision of language,' which implicitly discourages the use of harsh or imprecise words, including swear words. Therefore, coarse language is not a concern within the book.
The community in 'The Giver' enforces 'precision of language,' a rule that guides all communication and discourages the use of slang, vague terms, or strong language. There are no notable instances of profanity or curse words mentioned in detailed content reviews or plot summaries of the book itself.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThe novel does not contain any elements of witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, or supernatural phenomena. The society depicted in 'The Giver' is strictly controlled by scientific and social engineering, completely devoid of any spiritual or magical beliefs.
The dystopian society of 'The Giver' is characterized by its reliance on strict rules, scientific manipulation (e.g., genetic engineering, emotion-suppressing pills), and social conditioning to maintain 'Sameness' and order. The narrative focuses on memory, human emotion, and societal control, with no mention or depiction of magic, spells, or supernatural entities.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowThe Giver does not overtly promote anti-Christian themes. Instead, it depicts a society that has actively eradicated all forms of religion, including Christianity, in its pursuit of 'Sameness.' While not explicitly critical of Christianity, the absence of faith and the suppression of profound human experiences can be interpreted as a critique of a society devoid of spiritual depth. Some scholarly interpretations note the allegorical Christian themes of sacrifice and redemption.
The Community's adherence to 'Sameness' means that all memories and historical practices, including religious ones, have been purged to eliminate conflict and suffering. While not explicitly anti-Christian, this absence of spiritual life highlights a world where the fullness of human experience, which often includes faith, is missing. Lois Lowry has stated she didn't intend to write a religious book, but is aware that readers find allegorical connections, such as Jonas bearing the world's pain, reminiscent of Christ-like figures, and the presence of biblical names like Jonas and Gabriel.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
The Giver is recommended for readers aged 12 and above (grades 6-8 and up). While often read in middle school, its mature and disturbing themes, such as infanticide, euthanasia, and emotional suppression, warrant a recommendation for at least age 12, allowing for greater comprehension of the complex moral and philosophical dilemmas presented. Discussion with parents or educators is highly encouraged for younger readers to process the challenging content.
Additional Notes
Parents should be aware that while the reading level is suitable for middle schoolers, the thematic content of 'The Giver' is profound and mature. Key themes like euthanasia, infanticide, societal control, and the importance of individual choice can be quite heavy. It is highly recommended to read this book alongside your child to facilitate discussions about these complex moral and ethical issues, helping them process the difficult concepts presented.
Related Reviews
Is The Giver right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required