StoryScanner
Start free

The Girl Who Drank the Moon

Here's what we found in The Girl Who Drank the Moon. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family
General Review

Parent's Guide to The Girl Who Drank the Moon

The Girl Who Drank the Moon is a middle-grade fantasy novel by Kelly Barnhill, recipient of the Newbery Medal. The story centers on Luna, a girl accidentally "enmagicked" by moonlight and raised by a kind witch named Xan, a wise swamp monster, and a tiny dragon. The narrative explores Luna's journey to understand and control her growing magic as she approaches her thirteenth birthday, while simultaneously weaving in the story of the Protectorate, a village living under the oppressive fear of a mythical witch, a fear deliberately manufactured by its corrupt leaders. The book is suitable for a target audience of middle-grade readers, generally recommended for ages 10 and up. It delves into themes of love, family (both biological and found), hope, courage, and challenging corrupt authority. The content includes magical elements inherent to the fantasy genre, some instances of violence and intense situations, and focuses on moral lessons about truth and compassion.

Things to Consider

High1

Witchcraft & Occult

Witchcraft and magical elements are central to the plot and worldview of the story. Benevolent witches, sentient magical creatures, spellcasting, and a dark entity feeding on sorrow are key components of the fantasy world.

Xan is a central character and a kind, benevolent witch who rescues and raises abandoned babies, using magic, including feeding them starlight or, in Luna's case, moonlight. Luna herself is 'enmagicked' after drinking moonlight as a baby, developing extraordinary, often uncontrollable, magical powers as she grows. The main antagonist, Sister Ignatia, is revealed to be a 'Sorrow Eater,' a powerful occult figure who sustains herself by feeding on the grief and fear of the Protectorate's inhabitants, orchestrating the annual baby sacrifice.

Would these 1 concern matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium3
ViolenceScary & Intense ContentDisrespect & Rebellion
Low5
LGBTQ & Gender IdentityRomance and Sexual ContentProfanitySubstance UseAnti-Christian Themes
Medium3

Violence

The book contains instances of implied and depicted violence, including child abandonment, psychological torment leading to madness, physical scarring, and a villain who feeds on sorrow, suggesting a moderate level of intensity.

Scary & Intense Content

The book features several intense and potentially frightening elements, including themes of child sacrifice, a character driven to madness and imprisonment, a malevolent entity feeding on sorrow, and a looming natural disaster.

Disrespect & Rebellion

The narrative includes themes of challenging oppressive authority and standing up against injustice, with characters actively questioning and rebelling against harmful traditions and corrupt leaders. This is portrayed as a positive and necessary action.

Low5

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

Explicit searches for LGBTQ+ content, characters, or themes within "The Girl Who Drank the Moon" yielded no specific mentions. While one general review site's tag cloud included 'transgender' as a broader category, this was not specific to the book's content. Discussions of gender roles by a reviewer referred to traditional parental and caretaker roles within the story rather than gender identity.

Romance and Sexual Content

Romantic content is present but is mild and wholesome, focusing on a developing relationship between two characters that leads to marriage and mutual care. There is no explicit sexual content or suggestive language.

Profanity

The book contains very minimal instances of mild profanity. One specific instance of the word "damned" has been noted in content reviews, but overall language is considered clean.

Substance Use

There is no mention or depiction of alcohol, drugs, smoking, or any other substance use in the book, based on comprehensive searches of parental reviews and plot summaries.

Anti-Christian Themes

The book is a fantasy novel featuring a benevolent witch, magic, and mythical creatures, which may be perceived as conflicting with some traditional Christian worldviews due to its occult themes. While one reviewer noted 'new-agey references,' the book does not explicitly mock or insult Christian beliefs. Instead, it focuses on universal themes of love, hope, and good triumphing over evil within its magical framework.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

The Girl Who Drank the Moon presents several core themes that resonate with biblical values, particularly regarding justice, compassion, and the dangers of deception and oppressive power. The narrative strongly condemns corrupt authority figures who manipulate fear and control information for their own gain, aligning with a Christian call to seek truth and challenge injustice. Themes of sorrow versus hope are central, with sorrow being depicted as a destructive force when hoarded and exploited, while hope, born from selfless action and love, brings transformation and healing. This reflects a transcendent worldview where truth, love, and hope ultimately prevail over darkness, which aligns with Christian understanding of light overcoming darkness. The book emphasizes that love, particularly the selfless, sacrificial kind, is a powerful and transformative force, echoing the biblical emphasis on agape love. Character morality is generally clear, with virtuous characters like Xan, Luna, and Antain acting out of love, empathy, and a desire to protect the innocent. They are rewarded with growth, understanding, and the ability to bring positive change. Conversely, characters driven by vice, such as Sister Ignatia and the corrupt Elders who manipulate sorrow and fear, ultimately face consequences for their actions. Moral accountability is present as their deceit and cruelty are exposed and overcome. The book also subtly explores themes of redemption through the transformation of sorrow into hope and the breaking of cycles of fear and ignorance, suggesting that even deeply ingrained patterns of harm can be overcome through courageous acts of love and truth-telling. While not explicitly Christian, these elements of sacrifice and transformation can be viewed through a redemptive lens. Family values are presented broadly, emphasizing the strength of both biological and 'found' families nurtured by unconditional love. Xan’s adoption and loving care of Luna, despite not being biologically related, highlights the value of chosen family and selfless parenting. The story also showcases parental devotion and the lengths parents will go to protect their children, which is a universally relatable and biblically affirmed value. The book does not explicitly depict Christianity or any specific faith. Instead, it features a magical world with witches, swamp monsters, and dragons, where a 'Bog' is described as the source of creation and life. While the magical elements require discernment for Christian families, the underlying moral messages of love, compassion, and the triumph of good over evil are broadly consistent with Christian ethical principles.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

Recommended for ages 10 and up, aligning with its middle-grade classification. The Lexile level of 640L and thematic complexity, including themes of grief, sacrifice, and challenging oppression, make it most appropriate for readers in grades 5-8. Younger readers aged 8-9 may enjoy it if they are strong readers comfortable with longer narratives and mature themes, as noted by various educators and parental reviews.

Good to Know

The book strongly emphasizes themes of found family, unconditional love, and the power of truth and hope against manipulation and fear. It explores complex ideas about grief, sacrifice, and the nature of good versus evil through its varied characters and interwoven storylines. The narrative encourages critical thinking about authority and the importance of compassion.

How does this review compare?

This review
  • 9 standard concerns
  • General sensitivity level
  • One-size-fits-all perspective
Your report
  • Concerns you choose
  • Sensitivity levels you set
  • Tailored to your family

What are you reading next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly
Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families