Me and Earl and the Dying Girl
Me and Earl and the Dying Girl is a critically acclaimed young adult novel that navigates the complex landscape of high school, friendship, and terminal illness with a unique blend of cynical humor and raw honesty. The story centers on an awkward high school senior, Greg Gaines, who maintains a strategy of social invisibility by having 'acquaintances' rather than true friends, with the exception of his 'co-worker' Earl. Their unusual bond revolves around making bizarre, amateur film parodies. Greg's carefully constructed world is upended when his mother insists he befriend Rachel Kushner, a classmate recently diagnosed with leukemia. The narrative unfolds through Greg's self-deprecating and often crass first-person perspective, challenging traditional 'sick-lit' tropes by explicitly stating it's not a sappy romance or a story about profound life lessons gleaned from tragedy. Instead, it offers an unfiltered look at teenage anxieties, the awkwardness of navigating serious illness, and the unexpected depth of human connection. The book is intended for mature young adult readers, generally aged 14 and above, who can engage with its mature themes, frequent strong language, and frank discussions of sensitive topics, while also appreciating its dark humor and poignant exploration of grief and friendship.
Concerns
Romance and Sexual Content
HighThe book contains frequent sexual references, crude humor, and discussions of sexual topics, often from the perspective of a teenage boy. While explicit sexual acts are not depicted, the language and jokes are often explicit.
The narrator, Greg, exhibits a 'foul mouth and habit of talking about women's bodies.' There are 'references to sex' and 'some explicit statements about sex,' with no actual sexual contact shown. Two chapters in the book are explicitly titled 'Phone sex.' Furthermore, there is 'one very cringy scene in which the characters make jokes about oral sex.' Earl, in conversation with Greg, utters the words 'eat pussy.'
Profanity
HighProfanity is prolific and frequent throughout the book, including strong sexual expletives and other curse words. The language is integral to the authentic voice of the teenage narrator and characters.
The book is described as having 'lots of profanity' and 'some crude language,' with the character Earl particularly noted for his 'five star' ability to use profanity. Sources indicate 'there's almost not a single page without a swear word.' The terms used include the 'sexual expletive' and Earl and Greg are 'fond of the word 'fuck' and say it often.' Greg also uses the phrase 'Jesus Christ on a cockwagon.'
Violence
MediumInstances of violence are present but generally not graphic, often depicted as scuffles or referred to indirectly through the characters' film-making activities. Emotional and verbal conflicts are more prominent than physical aggression.
The book includes a scene where Earl punches Greg during an argument. Additionally, the characters Greg and Earl frequently watch and create parodies of violent movies, though the book does not describe these cinematic depictions in graphic detail within its own narrative.
Substance Use
MediumThe book depicts both casual and accidental substance use, including smoking, implied hard drug use by a character's history, and a scene of accidental marijuana consumption.
Earl is noted to 'smoke cigarettes and is rumored to have used hard drugs before the story began.' A significant plot point involves Greg and Earl 'accidentally get[ting] high when they eat some food they don't realize has marijuana in it,' a scene which spans approximately 30 pages. Additionally, Rachel's mother in the adaptation is shown 'frequently drinks to deal with family stress and appears to be drunk on at least one occasion,' and in the movie gives alcohol to teen boys.
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe book deals with the heavy and emotionally intense theme of terminal illness and death. While not containing horror elements, the narrative's focus on a dying girl can be profoundly sad and disturbing for some readers.
The central theme of the story is 'terminal illness and death,' particularly Rachel's battle with leukemia. The book features a 'distressing scene in which Rachel dies,' which is identified as potentially disturbing for younger audiences. The overall tone, while humorous, is also described as 'sad but heart-warming,' reflecting the inherent emotional intensity of the subject matter.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe narrative frequently features displays of disrespect and rebellion from teenage characters towards authority figures and societal norms, expressed through cynical attitudes, backtalk, and minor acts of defiance.
The narrator, Greg, describes his relationship with his family as 'classic high school stuff,' believing his 'mom is out to ruin his life' and expressing disdain for high school itself. Greg's cynical and 'smart-alecky humor' often reflects a disrespectful tone. His initial reluctance to befriend Rachel when prompted by his mother also demonstrates a rebellious streak against parental requests.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile the book is not explicitly anti-Christian, it contains irreverent and potentially blasphemous language, alongside criticisms from one source alleging broader anti-religious sentiments, specifically antisemitic undertones.
Greg uses the phrase 'Jesus Christ on a cockwagon,' which can be perceived as blasphemous and irreverent. Furthermore, one reviewer asserts the book contains 'Jew-Hatred' through subtle scorn of 'Jewish burial and Shiva practices' and derogatory characterizations like the 'Boring Jewish Senior Girls Subgroup,' aiming to diminish Jewish self-esteem, which, while specifically anti-Semitic, highlights a broader anti-religious insensitivity within the narrative.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowThe book contains dialogue where characters reference homosexual stereotypes in social commentary, but it does not feature openly LGBTQ+ characters or explore LGBTQ+ themes as a central social message. Explicit searches confirm the absence of LGBTQ+ representation within the narrative's character arcs or thematic development.
The narrator, Greg, mentions a social stereotype, stating, 'if a jock, God forbid, witnesses you hobnobbing with theater kids, he will immediately assume you are gay, and there is no force on earth greater than the fear jocks have homosexuals.' Additionally, discussions about the book explicitly note that, unlike other challenged books featuring LGBTQ+ individuals, 'Me and Earl and the Dying Girl has no political or social message to be censored' related to such themes.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowNo elements of witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, spells, or supernatural themes were found in the content analysis of the book.
The retrieved information contains no references to witchcraft, occult themes, or supernatural elements within the book's plot or character activities.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
16+ (Mature Teens) due to pervasive strong language, frequent sexual references and crude humor, depiction of substance use, and the emotionally intense themes surrounding terminal illness and death. While some sources suggest 14+, the intensity and frequency of certain elements warrant a higher recommendation for parental guidance.
Additional Notes
The book is a standalone novel and does not have sequels or companion books that would introduce new or intensified content. The author, Jesse Andrews, has stated his intention was to create a realistic portrayal of an emotionally limited teenager dealing with tragedy, often through humor and self-deprecation. The book has been frequently challenged due to its profanity and sexual content, indicating that its candid and often crude portrayal of adolescence may be controversial for some parental audiences.
Related Reviews
Is Me and Earl and the Dying Girl right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required