Identical
Identical by Ellen Hopkins is a young adult novel, presented in free verse, that delves into the fractured lives of identical twin sisters, Kaeleigh and Raeanne Gardella. The narrative explores the stark contrast between their seemingly perfect family facade and the profound dysfunction, abuse, and mental health struggles hidden beneath. Through alternating perspectives, the story intricately weaves their individual coping mechanisms with disturbing family secrets. The book is intended for mature young adult readers, as it tackles a range of extremely sensitive and graphic topics without reservation. It unflinchingly addresses child sexual abuse, incest, self-harm, eating disorders, substance abuse, and psychological trauma, culminating in a significant plot twist involving dissociative identity disorder. Due to the intensity and frequency of these mature themes, parental guidance is strongly advised, and the book is generally recommended for older teens.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains graphic and pervasive depictions of violence, primarily in the form of child sexual abuse, self-harm, and implied physical abuse within a relationship. The psychological toll of this abuse is central to the narrative.
Kaeleigh is the victim of ongoing sexual abuse by her father, Ray, which began when she was ten years old. Reviewers mention graphic details such as a 'man performing oral sex on his daughter'. Raeanne, one of the twin personalities, is involved in a 'toxic relationship with a man who is physically and emotionally abusive,' and a scene depicts Mick attempting to rape Raeanne.
Romance and Sexual Content
HighRomance and sexual content are highly explicit and disturbing, centered around father-daughter incest, promiscuity, and implied sexual assault. This content is integral to the twins' trauma and coping mechanisms.
The central theme involves father-daughter incest, with Kaeleigh being sexually abused by her father. This is explicitly described as 'graphic paedophilia & child sexual abuse (on-page).' Raeanne engages in promiscuous sexual acts, often trading sex for drugs, and is described as 'sexually promiscuous—giving sex in return for drugs.'
Substance Use
HighSubstance use is a pervasive and central theme, depicting significant drug and alcohol abuse by multiple characters as a means of coping with trauma and emotional pain.
Raeanne is frequently described as a 'drug addict' who uses 'painkillers, drugs, [and] alcohol' daily to numb her pain and is noted for 'getting stoned daily' and trading sex for marijuana. The father, Ray, is an 'alcoholic' who 'drinks [and] abuses Oxycontin' at home, and Kaeleigh experiences an overdose on 'whiskey and pills' at one point.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book is described as highly disturbing and intense due to its focus on severe psychological trauma, graphic child sexual abuse, self-harm, and a significant plot twist involving mental illness.
Reviewers frequently characterize the book as 'disturbing,' 'sick and creepy,' and 'atrocious' due to the graphic nature of the father-daughter incest and the emotional impact of the twins' suffering. The revelation that Raeanne is a dissociative identity created by Kaeleigh to cope with her father's sexual abuse and Raeanne's death years prior is a 'surprising twist' and a profoundly intense psychological element.
Profanity
MediumThe book includes instances of profanity, consistent with its realistic depiction of troubled teenage lives and stressful situations. While not explicitly quantified as pervasive, its presence aligns with mature themes.
One instance noted involves a character referring to their grandfather as a 'prick'. The overall 'dark, sensitive territories' and 'unsparing and unflinching in their plainspoken truths' of Ellen Hopkins's writing often include strong language.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumRaeanne, as one of the central characters, displays significant rebellious behavior, including substance abuse, promiscuity, and defiance, stemming from her feelings of neglect and resentment towards her family situation.
Raeanne chooses 'drugs, alcohol, and sex' as a form of rebellion and to 'lose on her own terms' because she perceives her father's favoritism towards Kaeleigh. She also 'berates Kaeleigh for not standing up to their father,' showcasing a defiant attitude against the abusive dynamic and parental authority.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowExplicit searches for LGBTQ content related to "Identical" by Ellen Hopkins yielded no direct or confirmed representation of LGBTQ characters, themes, or plotlines. The book's content warnings and summaries focus on heterosexual relationships and abuse dynamics.
N/A (no explicit LGBTQ content found across multiple targeted searches).
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThe provided information and reviews indicate no presence of witchcraft, sorcery, occult themes, or supernatural elements within 'Identical.' The book is grounded in contemporary realistic fiction.
N/A (no explicit content found).
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes, mockery, or criticism of Christian beliefs or symbols were found in the search results. The book is secular in its approach to its difficult themes.
While themes of morality are inherent in the discussion of abuse, the narrative does not specifically target or critique Christianity. Notably, Kaeleigh finds employment and solace at a 'Lutheran home,' indicating a neutral or potentially positive, albeit minor, interaction with a religious institution.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
17+ due to graphic and pervasive themes including child sexual abuse (incest), extensive substance abuse, self-harm, and severe psychological trauma.
Additional Notes
The book is written in free verse, which can impact reading experience and emotional intensity. The core narrative features a major plot twist that reveals one of the twin perspectives is a manifestation of dissociative identity disorder, adding a layer of psychological complexity and intensity. Due to the very sensitive nature of the content, including child sexual abuse, self-harm, and drug addiction, it is frequently flagged with trigger warnings and has been challenged or banned in some educational settings.
Related Reviews
Is Identical right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required