Heather Has Two Mommies
Heather Has Two Mommies is a groundbreaking children's picture book that tells the story of a young girl named Heather, who lives with her two mothers, Mama Jane and Mama Kate. The narrative unfolds as Heather attends school for the first time and encounters other children who have daddies, leading her to realize her family structure is different. Her compassionate teacher, Molly, facilitates a classroom discussion where all the children draw their families, revealing a diverse array of family compositions. The book's core message emphasizes that families come in many forms and that the most important element is the love shared among its members. Targeted at preschool and early elementary children, typically ages 3-7, it aims to foster inclusivity and understanding of diverse family units. Despite its gentle approach, the book has been historically controversial due to its positive portrayal of same-sex parenting, sparking debates and challenges regarding its appropriateness in schools and libraries.
Concerns
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
HighThe book's central theme revolves around Heather, a child with two lesbian mothers, Mama Jane and Mama Kate. It was specifically created to provide positive representation for children in non-traditional families, highlighting the normality and love within same-sex parent households. The book directly addresses and normalizes lesbian parenting.
The primary characters, Mama Jane and Mama Kate, are explicitly depicted as Heather's two lesbian mothers, forming the core family unit presented in the story. During a class activity where children draw their families, Heather's teacher, Molly, reinforces that families come in many forms, including a classmate named Stacy who has two daddies, directly affirming same-sex parental structures.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumThe book itself does not directly critique or mock Christian beliefs. However, its central affirmation of a lesbian family structure inherently conflicts with traditional Christian views on marriage and family. Historically, the book faced significant opposition and was challenged by conservative religious groups who perceived its themes as anti-traditional or anti-religious.
The book's explicit portrayal of 'Heather Has Two Mommies' directly advocates for and normalizes same-sex parenting, which runs contrary to the theological doctrines of many Christian denominations that define family exclusively within a heterosexual marriage. This content led to the book being 'attacked by the religious right' and becoming a 'lightning rod' for controversy, including efforts to ban it from libraries due to concerns raised by groups like the Traditional Values Coalition, demonstrating a direct clash with specific Christian parental values.
Violence
LowThe book contains no depictions or descriptions of physical violence, battle, gore, death, or any other form of harm. The narrative focuses on gentle domestic and school-related interactions, maintaining a calm and pleasant tone suitable for young children.
The story follows Heather's everyday experiences, such as playing at home and attending her first day of school, without any elements of conflict or aggression. While Mama Kate, who is a doctor, is shown putting bandages on Heather's knee, this action suggests minor, non-violent childhood scrapes and emphasizes care, not injury severity.
Romance and Sexual Content
LowThe book portrays a loving family dynamic between Heather and her two mothers without any explicit romantic or sexual content. Affection is depicted through familial care, not physical intimacy. An earlier edition's brief mention of artificial insemination was removed in later versions to suit younger audiences.
Heather's relationship with Mama Jane and Mama Kate is characterized by shared activities like baking cookies and going to the park, focusing on nurturing and family life rather than romantic interactions. The original 1989 edition included a detail about Heather's conception via 'artificial insemination,' which was later omitted in the 10th-anniversary edition to enhance its accessibility and appropriateness for younger children.
Profanity
LowThere is no profanity, swear words, or strong language used throughout the book. The vocabulary is simple and appropriate for young children, consistent with a picture book's target demographic.
The text is described as 'simple and straightforward' and 'mild-mannered,' ensuring that all dialogue and narration are clean and inoffensive. The teacher, Molly, delivers a key message about love in families, using only positive and gentle language, such as: 'The most important thing about a family is that all the people in it love each other.'
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThe book does not contain any themes related to witchcraft, sorcery, the occult, magic, demons, spells, or supernatural elements. It is set in a realistic contemporary environment, focusing on social themes and family life.
The story is grounded in everyday reality, depicting Heather's experiences at home and during her first day at a playgroup, with no fantastical or magical occurrences. The characters are ordinary individuals, such as Mama Jane, a carpenter, and Mama Kate, a doctor, without any supernatural abilities or associations.
Substance Use
LowThere is no mention or depiction of substance use, including alcohol, drugs, or smoking, within the book. The content is wholesome and focuses on healthy childhood activities and family interactions.
The narrative illustrates typical childhood routines, such as 'drink a big glass of milk,' and family activities like baking cookies, with no presence of substances. The book's focus remains on creating a positive and inclusive portrayal of family life, entirely devoid of any references to drugs or alcohol.
Scary & Intense Content
LowThe book is devoid of scary, frightening, or intensely suspenseful content. While Heather experiences a brief moment of sadness about not having a daddy, this emotion is quickly and gently resolved through the teacher's reassuring message about family diversity, preventing any prolonged distress.
Heather initially becomes 'upset' when she realizes she lacks a daddy compared to some peers, but this feeling is swiftly addressed by her teacher, Molly, who explains that all families are special, leading to Heather's gratitude. The overall tone of the book is described as 'calm and pleasant,' aiming to provide comfort and acceptance rather than evoke fear or anxiety.
Disrespect & Rebellion
LowThe book portrays respectful interactions among characters and does not feature instances of disrespect, defiance, or rebellious behavior from children towards adults or authority figures. The children in the story are shown learning and accepting the message of family diversity presented by their teacher.
Heather, despite her initial sadness about not having a daddy, accepts the inclusive message from her teacher, Molly, without defiance or backtalk. The teacher, Molly, is depicted as 'wise' and 'wonderful,' and the classroom environment fosters understanding and acceptance rather than encouraging rebellious attitudes.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
The book is recommended for children aged 3-7 years, with some sources suggesting it's suitable for ages 6-9 or preschool through 2nd grade. The simple text, engaging illustrations, and theme of family diversity are designed for young readers to grasp the concept of different family structures and the importance of love within a family.
Additional Notes
First published in 1989, 'Heather Has Two Mommies' was a pioneering work in LGBTQ+ children's literature and has undergone revisions, notably the removal of the artificial insemination detail from later editions to make it more appropriate for younger readers. The book has been frequently challenged and banned in schools and libraries throughout its history, illustrating the ongoing societal debate surrounding its themes. The author, Lesléa Newman, has also written companion books like 'Daddy, Papa, and Me' and 'Mommy, Mama, and Me,' continuing her focus on diverse family structures.
Related Reviews
Is Heather Has Two Mommies right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required