Freewater
Freewater by Amina Luqman-Dawson is a historical fiction novel for middle-grade readers, set against the backdrop of American slavery. It chronicles the perilous journey of Homer and his younger sister, Ada, as they escape a brutal plantation and seek refuge in Freewater, a hidden community deep within the swamp formed by formerly enslaved people. The narrative explores themes of freedom, resilience, community, and courage, told through multiple character perspectives. While offering an inspiring look at a little-known part of history, the book addresses difficult and intense subjects, including the harsh realities of enslavement, physical abuse, and the constant threat of recapture. It is generally considered appropriate for older middle-grade readers due to its mature themes and intense content.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains significant and often brutal violence directly reflecting the realities of slavery, including whippings, beatings, and armed confrontations, as well as themes of violence against children and animal death. This violence is central to the story's depiction of life under enslavement and the fight for freedom.
Homer's mother, Rose, is severely whipped and left bleeding after an escape attempt, with salt being applied to her wounds, causing her to scream. Characters' fingers are cut off as punishment for escape attempts. Mrs. Crumb hits Anna, and Anna's mother cut an arrow shape into Anna's arm. The book details melees involving guns, knives, and slingshots, with characters like Suleman hitting a militia man with an arrow and Sanzi setting a wedding tent on fire with flaming arrows.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe narrative is replete with scary and intense content, including perilous escapes, brutal physical abuse, pursuit by slave hunters and dogs, and life-threatening situations in the natural environment. These elements are integral to depicting the harsh reality of slavery and the struggle for freedom.
Homer and Ada endure a "danger-filled journey" while fleeing the plantation, chased by an overseer and his dogs through the swamp. The book describes the "horrific predicaments the slaves endured," including graphic depictions of whippings and violence against children. There are mentions of characters dodging snakes and slave hunters through treacherous swamp paths that include sharpened stakes. Reviews also highlight "very scary moments in the book that might be upsetting to some readers".
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumRomantic content is minimal and mild, limited to youthful affection. However, there is a serious allusion to the sexual assault of a mother character, which significantly increases the overall severity for this category.
One instance mentions a boy liking a girl and a girl kissing a boy on the cheek. Another scene describes a girl's skin having spots, leading her brother to infer a possible innuendo related to the Master, which an adult reader might interpret in a sexual context. A review explicitly states a "slight allusion to rape to the mother character".
Profanity
MediumWhile traditional profanity is largely absent, the book contains strong racial slurs used by oppressive characters, which is offensive and impactful.
Stokes, the cruel overseer, refers to runaways using the racial slur "darkies". The content warnings for the book specifically mention "racism (including racist language)".
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumThe Freewater community practices an alternative belief system centered on the swamp as a deity, involving prayer, gratitude, and the use of natural elements for healing and protection. This is presented as a spiritual practice distinct from mainstream religions.
Residents of Freewater "pray to the swamp as a deity, thanking it and asking it for protection". Mrs. Light, a community leader, presides over a religion that uses swamp plants and herbs for medicine and thanks the swamp as "a kind of mother goddess for protection". Additionally, Sanzi believes a dream she had will come true, suggesting a belief in omens or prophetic dreams.
Substance Use
MediumThe book includes instances of alcohol consumption for pain relief and the use of alcohol combined with other substances to create a sedative to drug individuals, along with general allusions to drug abuse.
Rose drinks an "alcoholic drink to ease her pain". Anna uses "flowers and stolen alcohol to make a similar sedative to drug the wedding guests". Reviews also mention general "allusions to drugs and drug abuse".
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumRebellion against the institution of slavery is a central and positive theme, portraying acts of defiance against oppressive authority figures (slave owners and overseers) as a courageous quest for freedom.
Homer and Ada's entire flight from the plantation is an act of rebellion against their enslavers. Suleman, a formerly enslaved man, actively "patrols and wreaks havoc on the cruel plantations that once enslaved him". The very existence of the Freewater community represents a collective act of defiance and rebellion against the system of slavery.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile Christian beliefs like "Heaven is mentioned," the Freewater community's primary spiritual practice involves praying to and revering the swamp as a deity. This portrayal of an alternative, nature-based deity worship, explicitly noted as lacking Christian influence by reviewers, could be perceived as conflicting with Christian monotheistic beliefs.
The residents of Freewater "pray to the swamp as a deity, thanking it and asking it for protection". Reviewers observe that the inhabitants of Freewater "don't seem to have taken any Christian influence with them: expressions of gratitude and petition go to the swamp, not to God".
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowNo explicit LGBTQ+ themes, characters, or gender identity discussions are identified within the available content reviews and summaries for "Freewater." The narrative focuses on historical events and personal struggles related to enslavement.
No specific examples of LGBTQ+ content were found in the extensive search conducted across various review sites and community discussions.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
12+ due to the depiction of intense violence, racial slurs, mature themes of enslavement and its brutal consequences, and an allusion to sexual assault. While presented for middle-grade readers, the graphic nature of some content warrants careful consideration for younger audiences.
Additional Notes
Freewater is a powerful historical novel that offers valuable insights into maroon communities and the fight for freedom. Parents should be prepared for mature themes, including the graphic realities of slavery, racial slurs, and an allusion to sexual assault. The multi-perspective narrative may also be challenging for some younger readers. Discussion of the historical context and the spiritual practices of the Freewater community may be beneficial for Christian families.
Related Reviews
Is Freewater right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required