City of Glass
City of Glass is the third book in Cassandra Clare's widely popular urban fantasy series, "The Mortal Instruments." The narrative plunges readers into the hidden world of Shadowhunters, human-angel hybrids who protect the mundane world from demons. The story centers on Clary Fray's urgent quest to save her mother, who is trapped in a magical coma, by traveling to Alicante, the ancestral city of the Shadowhunters. This perilous journey also forces her to confront her villainous father, Valentine Morgenstern, who is determined to eradicate all Downworlders and even some Shadowhunters using powerful magical artifacts. The book features a blend of action, mystery, and intricate relationships, set against a backdrop of supernatural conflict involving vampires, werewolves, warlocks, and demons. While offering a captivating escape into a richly imagined world, the content is designed for a young adult audience. Parents should be aware of the mature themes, including significant violence, complex romantic entanglements with suggestive elements, and discussions around identity and belonging in a magical society.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains frequent and graphically described battles between Shadowhunters and demons, including explicit details of injuries, dismemberment, and death. There are instances of implied sexual violence and specific, brutal character deaths.
Max Lightwood, the youngest of the Lightwood siblings, a child of nine years old, is brutally killed by Sebastian Verlac. Battles against demons are described with graphic detail, including demons having heads cut off, throats slit, and instances of demon and Shadowhunter blood being spilled. It is also intimated that a demon attempted to rape a Shadowhunter.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighWitchcraft and occult themes are central to the entire narrative, which is an urban fantasy. This includes extensive magic use, interaction with various supernatural beings (demons, angels, warlocks, vampires, werewolves), and the use of powerful magical artifacts and rituals.
Clary Fray possesses the unique ability to create new runes, which are magical symbols that grant various powers, including the creation of portals for travel to different realms like Idris. The antagonist, Valentine Morgenstern, actively seeks and utilizes powerful magical artifacts known as the Mortal Instruments to summon angels and demons, aiming to enact his destructive plans.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe content is highly intense, featuring graphic violence, the death of a child, implied sexual violence, and significant psychological distress. The pervasive threat from a genocidal villain and the constant danger faced by the protagonists contribute to a high level of suspense and frightening situations.
The book contains graphic descriptions of demon battles, detailing their grotesque appearances with talons and skeletal bodies, and the visceral effects of combat. The brutal death of the young character Max Lightwood at the hands of Sebastian Verlac is a particularly distressing event.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book features a prominent gay character, Alec Lightwood, whose romantic relationship with the warlock Magnus Bane develops significantly. Their relationship challenges the traditional norms and societal expectations within the Shadowhunter community, leading to some internal and external conflict regarding acceptance.
Alec Lightwood, a Shadowhunter, is explicitly in a homosexual relationship with Magnus Bane, a warlock, which is initially met with disapproval within the conservative Shadowhunter society, particularly by Alec's parents. A significant moment occurs when Alec publicly kisses Magnus, acknowledging their relationship before a crowd, including his family and the governing Clave.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe narrative includes passionate kissing scenes, suggestive physical intimacy, and implied sexual encounters that are stopped before becoming explicit. A central, intense romantic conflict involves characters who believe they are siblings but are still mutually attracted, leading to themes of incestuous thoughts.
Clary and Jace share an "intimately described passion" after the destruction of Wayland Manor, where they begin to disrobe before Clary stops them from going further. They also sleep in the same bed. Isabelle Lightwood throws Simon onto a bed and attempts to initiate sexual activity with him shortly after her brother's death, though Simon later indicates they did not have sex.
Profanity
MediumThe book includes a moderate amount of mild to moderate curse words and exclamations, including instances where God's name is used in vain.
Words such as "a--," "d--n," "b--tard," "b--ch," and "h--" are present in the dialogue. Additionally, phrases like "God's name is used with thank, oh my and sake" and the Spanish exclamation "Dios" are used.
Substance Use
MediumThe book depicts instances of teenage alcohol consumption and includes a significant plot element involving a magical substance that induces hallucinations and can lead to madness upon ingestion.
Teenage Shadowhunters are shown sharing and consuming a bottle of wine during dinner while left unsupervised in a house. Clary accidentally ingests water from Lake Lyn, which is known to cause hallucinations, fever, and can drive a person to madness among Nephilim.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumCharacters frequently engage in acts of defiance against established authority figures and rules, sometimes leading to dangerous situations or severe consequences. Authority figures themselves are occasionally portrayed as flawed or corrupt.
Clary deliberately breaks the Law by entering the Shadowhunter city of Alicante without permission, a transgression that could lead to her death. Isabelle Lightwood is explicitly described as a "rebellious daughter," often acting independently and in defiance of her parents' or the Clave's expectations.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile the book does not explicitly mock or insult Christian beliefs, it presents an extensive urban fantasy mythology centered on Nephilim (human-angel hybrids), demons, and various supernatural species, which significantly deviates from traditional Christian doctrine. There is also an instance of a Christian symbol being used deceptively.
Raphael, the leader of the vampires, is depicted wearing a cross and regularly attending church to deceive his human family into believing he is not a vampire, thereby using Christian symbols for manipulation rather than genuine faith. The series establishes its own distinct mythology of angels and demons as integral to the Shadowhunter world, which, while containing biblical terms, operates within a unique fantasy framework separate from Christian theology.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
14 and up. This recommendation is based on the presence of intense violence, including graphic descriptions of battles and character deaths, mature romantic content involving implied sexual activity and themes of perceived incest, instances of profanity, and complex moral dilemmas.
Additional Notes
The book is part of a larger series, and themes often evolve and intensify across subsequent installments. The complex family dynamics, particularly the perceived incestuous relationship between Clary and Jace, can be emotionally challenging for younger readers, even though the issue is resolved later in the series. Parents may find it beneficial to discuss these mature themes with their children.
Related Reviews
Is City of Glass right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required