City of Fallen Angels
City of Fallen Angels is the fourth installment in Cassandra Clare's urban fantasy series, The Mortal Instruments. It continues the story of Clary Fray, a young Shadowhunter who has recently discovered her unique angelic powers and her place in a hidden world of demons, angels, vampires, and other supernatural beings. The book picks up after the resolution of a major conflict, with Clary and her boyfriend, Jace, navigating their relationship while a new wave of mysterious murders targets Shadowhunters. Concurrently, Clary's best friend, Simon, grapples with his new identity as a Daylighter vampire and complex romantic entanglements. This volume delves deeper into the characters' personal struggles and relationships, setting the stage for further developments in the overarching saga. Aimed at a young adult audience, it explores themes of love, loyalty, identity, and the ongoing battle between good and evil within a supernatural New York City setting.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe narrative includes multiple instances of graphic violence, including murders of Shadowhunters, demonic attacks, and descriptive consequences of a magical mark. The book explores intense themes of death and physical harm, which can be disturbing.
Jace experiences disturbing nightmares where he graphically murders Clary, and these dreams escalate to him actually injuring Clary with a dagger during an intimate moment, fearing his dreams are becoming reality. Shadowhunters are being murdered, and one such dead Shadowhunter is temporarily brought back to life by Clary, choking out the name of his killer before dying again. The book also describes people being destroyed by the 'Mark of Cain' placed on Simon.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighThe book is deeply embedded in an urban fantasy world where magic, demons, angels, vampires, and other supernatural beings are central. Shadowhunters derive power from angelic blood, warlocks wield magic, and various rituals are depicted or referenced.
Shadowhunters are created by the blood of the angel Raziel and use runes for magical effects. The plot involves efforts to create demonic children, mirroring Sebastian, and Jace's vulnerability to demonic influence after his resurrection. Warlocks like Magnus Bane are powerful magic users, and there are explicit references to demons (e.g., Hydra demon fight) and rituals, such as the Shadowhunter protection ritual for infants and attempts to replicate it for Jace.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book contains elements designed to be frightening and suspenseful, including disturbing nightmares, violent deaths, demonic appearances, and grotesque imagery. The atmosphere can be tense and psychologically unsettling, with high stakes for the characters.
Jace is plagued by nightmares where he murders Clary, which become so vivid that he physically harms her in his sleep. This psychological torment is a central plot point, causing significant distress. The book features disturbing imagery such as a 'room full of dead babies' and descriptions of people being 'destroyed by the Mark of Cain' in horrifying ways, which a reviewer highlights as effectively 'horrifying.'
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book features an established homosexual relationship between Alec Lightwood and Magnus Bane, which is a significant part of the narrative. However, some reader reviews point out problematic 'queer comments' made by characters and narrative choices that some consider biphobic, indicating areas of concern for Christian parents.
Alec Lightwood is in a homosexual relationship with the warlock Magnus Bane, and they are shown on a romantic holiday at the beginning of the novel. Alec expresses jealousy when he learns of Magnus's past relationship with Camille, indicating a confirmed same-sex relationship and the emotional complexities within it. A reviewer notes Clary's statement 'you can't have two fathers,' which is criticized for being an outdated and potentially harmful 'queer comment' within the narrative. Another reviewer also critiques 'borderline biphobia' in Alec's jealousy regarding Magnus's past partners.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe book features multiple romantic relationships, including passionate kissing, suggestive situations, and discussions about sexual health. There are instances of implied sexual activity and emotional complexities arising from romantic entanglements.
Jace and Clary share several passionate kisses and engage in sensual foreplay. During one scene, Clary is in bed wearing only a T-shirt and underwear, and the narrative implies they would have proceeded further if Jace hadn't injured her. Isabelle has a frank discussion with Clary about birth control, indicating that older teens are engaging in or discussing sexual activity. Simon also dates both Maia and Isabelle simultaneously without their knowledge, involving multiple kisses and emotional manipulation.
Profanity
MediumThe dialogue contains frequent use of mild to moderate profanity, reflecting a teenage cast in a high-stress environment. Specific curse words are noted by reviewers as being present throughout the book.
Reviewers explicitly state that 'Much of the teens' dialogue is laced with profanity including d–n, h—, b–ch, b–tard, a– and a–hole.' A fan community reviewer uses strong language ('Oh my fucking god,' 'Like the fuck?') to describe their frustration with the book's content, particularly regarding character behavior, indicating that profanity is present in the text to evoke such reactions.
Substance Use
MediumSubstance use is present through the depiction of vampirism, where characters consume blood. Simon, as a Daylighter vampire, struggles with his new nature and hides blood from his mother, leading to conflict.
Simon, a main character, is a vampire who needs to drink blood. His mother discovers 'bottles of blood and blood bags' in his room, leading to a confrontation. Simon is shown actively biting Maureen, a fourteen-year-old fan, and drinking her blood during a concert. He also struggles with feeling ill from 'lack of blood consumption.'
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumInstances of disrespect and rebellious behavior are present, particularly concerning teenage characters defying parental figures or engaging in deceptive romantic practices. Some dialogue also exhibits a dismissive attitude towards authority or traditional values.
Simon repeatedly hides his vampiric nature from his mother, eventually using his vampiric persuasion powers (Encanto) to make her believe her discovery of his blood supply was 'a bad dream' after she confronts him and begins to pray for him. Simon dates both Maia Roberts and Isabelle Lightwood simultaneously, keeping each relationship secret from the other girl, demonstrating a pattern of deception and disrespect in his romantic dealings.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile the series incorporates angels and uses terms like 'fallen angels,' its portrayal of a supernatural world with demons, magic, and various non-Christian belief systems may conflict with a strict Christian worldview. There's a 'critique of organized religion' hinted at, and Christian symbols like crosses are treated as anti-vampire weapons rather than solely religious items.
The foundational mythology of the Shadowhunters involves their creation from the blood of the angel Raziel, setting up a different origin story than traditional Christian theology, and angels are depicted within a broader fantasy context rather than a strictly biblical one. Simon's mother reacts to his vampirism by believing he is no longer her son and begins to pray, which Simon resolves by using his powers to make her forget, showing a conflict between mundane Christian belief and the supernatural reality of the world. Additionally, crosses are primarily presented as anti-vampire weapons.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
14 and up. This recommendation is based on the book's complex themes, including graphic violence, mature romantic and sexual content, detailed supernatural and occult elements, and instances of profanity. The emotional intensity, coupled with discussions of challenging interpersonal relationships and moral dilemmas, makes it more suitable for a young adult audience capable of processing such content.
Additional Notes
City of Fallen Angels is the fourth book in The Mortal Instruments series, and its content builds upon the previous books. New readers should be aware that understanding the full scope of relationships, mythology, and character arcs may require familiarity with the earlier volumes. The book maintains a strong focus on character development and emotional drama alongside its supernatural plot. Later installments in the series continue to explore and intensify many of the themes present here, particularly regarding romance, violence, and the occult.
Related Reviews
Is City of Fallen Angels right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required