Is American Horror Story right for your family?

This review covers common concerns — screen for what YOUR family cares about.

American Horror Story

TV

American Horror Story is a long-running anthology horror television series, with each season presenting a self-contained narrative in a new setting with a distinct theme. The show delves into various subgenres of horror, exploring elements of supernatural, psychological, slasher, and creature features. It is consistently rated TV-MA, indicating content strictly for mature audiences due to its graphic and intense nature. The series frequently tackles mature themes such as violence, sexuality, mental health, societal discrimination, and the occult, often pushing boundaries with its explicit depictions. While individual seasons vary in specific content, the overall series maintains a high level of mature themes, making it unsuitable for younger viewers.

Content concerns found:Click to jump

What are you watching next? Screen any title — even ones without reviews elsewhere.

Concerns

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

High

American Horror Story is notably inclusive of LGBTQ+ characters and themes, with showrunner Ryan Murphy, who is openly gay, consistently integrating queer representation into the narrative of every season. The series explores diverse sexual orientations and gender identities, often depicting challenges faced by the LGBTQ+ community, including discrimination and conversion therapy. This aspect is not merely incidental but often central to character development and plotlines, with numerous openly LGBTQ+ actors cast in queer roles.

In 'Asylum', Lana Winters, a lesbian journalist, is involuntarily committed to Briarcliff Manor and subjected to electro-shock therapy by Dr. Oliver Thredson as an attempt to 'cure' her homosexuality. 'American Horror Story: NYC' prominently features a storyline centered on mysterious deaths and disappearances of gay men in 1980s New York City, making queer identity and the threats faced by the community central to the season's narrative.

Violence

High

The series is characterized by pervasive and graphic violence, gore, and disturbing imagery. Each season features intense scenes of murder, mutilation, torture, and various forms of physical brutality, often depicted explicitly and in detail. The violence is a core element of the horror genre presented, designed to shock and disturb viewers.

In 'Murder House', Chad and Patrick, a gay couple, are brutally murdered in their home, with elements of BDSM and violence being central to their deaths. In 'Delicate', the season includes graphic instances such as dead animals being placed in bassinets and scenes showing characters' gums bleeding profusely, alongside a general high frequency of explicit violence and gore.

Romance and Sexual Content

High

American Horror Story regularly features strong and explicit sexual themes, including graphic nudity, suggestive dialogue, implied and explicit sexual acts, bondage, masturbation, and instances of sexual violence and assault. This content is frequently interwoven with the horror elements, serving to heighten the disturbing nature of the narratives.

The season 'Delicate' is noted for 'a lot of graphic nudity and clear sex scenes', including one instance where a woman has 'fingers forced inside her to the point of pain'. In 'Murder House', the Rubber Man character engages in various sexual acts, including a scene depicting a 'very awkward kink scene' involving the suit, often tied to violent or disturbing events.

Profanity

High

The series consistently uses very mature and coarse language, including frequent strong expletives. Profanity is a regular feature in dialogue, often used aggressively or in moments of intense emotional distress, contributing to the show's adult rating.

According to fan discussions, 'American Horror Story' was first allowed to use 'The F-Bomb' uncensored in the 'Cult' season, with occasional sound-censored usage in 'Roanoke' for effect. Characters across various seasons, such as Dandy Mott in 'Freak Show' or various coven members in 'Coven', frequently use strong curse words in their dialogue during confrontational or emotional scenes.

Witchcraft & Occult

High

Witchcraft, sorcery, and occult themes are central to several seasons, notably 'Coven' and 'Apocalypse'. The series explicitly depicts magical rituals, spellcasting, demon summoning, and interactions with supernatural entities. These elements are not merely background but drive significant plot developments and character powers.

In 'Coven', the entire premise revolves around a coven of witches performing explicit magic rituals, incantations, and demonstrating various supernatural powers, including resurrection and telekinesis. 'Apocalypse' features the Anti-Christ as a central figure, with extensive plotlines involving powerful warlocks and witches engaging in dark magic to bring about and combat the end of the world, directly exploring demonic and occult forces.

Substance Use

High

The show frequently depicts the use of various substances, including alcohol, tobacco, and illegal drugs. Characters, both adult and sometimes adolescent, are shown consuming these substances, often in contexts that highlight addiction, self-destruction, or as catalysts for violent or sexual encounters. This content is explicit and recurring across seasons.

In 'Hotel', characters like The Countess and Detective John Lowe frequently consume alcohol and illegal drugs, with substance abuse being a significant plot device and contributing to the characters' erratic and violent behaviors. Many characters across different seasons, such as Sister Jude in 'Asylum' or Elsa Mars in 'Freak Show', are shown smoking cigarettes, with tobacco use being a common visual element.

Scary & Intense Content

High

As an anthology horror series, 'American Horror Story' is inherently designed to be scary and intense. It consistently utilizes disturbing imagery, psychological terror, jump scares, body horror, and themes of extreme violence, torture, and death. The narrative frequently places characters in life-threatening situations and explores deeply unsettling psychological states.

The 'Asylum' season features intense psychological horror within a mental institution setting, including the terrifying serial killer Bloody Face and scenes of extreme distress and torture inflicted upon characters like Lana Winters. In 'Freak Show', the character Twisty the Clown is a profoundly disturbing figure who commits graphic murders and kidnappings, creating constant fear and grotesque visual horror.

Disrespect & Rebellion

High

Disrespect towards authority figures and rebellious behavior are common themes throughout 'American Horror Story'. Characters frequently challenge social norms, defy parental or institutional rules, and engage in acts of outright insubordination. This can range from sarcastic defiance to extreme acts of rebellion that lead to dangerous or violent consequences.

Violet Harmon in 'Murder House' exhibits significant rebellious behavior and disrespect towards her parents, Ben and Vivien, often engaging in defiance and secretive activities. In 'Coven', many of the young witches, despite being students under the guidance of Cordelia Goode, frequently engage in disrespectful backtalk, challenge rules, and pursue their own agendas, often leading to conflict and dangerous magical rivalries.

Anti-Christian Themes

High

The series frequently incorporates elements that can be interpreted as anti-Christian. This includes the portrayal of corrupt or evil religious figures, explicit depictions of demonic entities, the Anti-Christ, and the glorification of occult practices. Christian symbols or beliefs are sometimes mocked, subverted, or shown in a negative light within the context of the horror narratives.

In 'Asylum', Sister Jude, a prominent religious figure, is depicted as a cruel and abusive nun who engages in torture, blackmail, and un-Christian behavior while running a mental institution. 'Apocalypse' centers around the literal Anti-Christ, Michael Langdon, whose storyline involves the direct opposition to Christian beliefs, the destruction of the world, and the ultimate triumph (albeit temporary) of demonic forces.

Found 9 high-concern themes. Want to set your own sensitivity levels?

Other Notes

Target Demographic

18+ due to pervasive graphic violence, explicit sexual content (including sexual violence and nudity), strong language, mature themes, and disturbing imagery. The content is consistently intense and not suitable for minors, as confirmed by its TV-MA rating and detailed content warnings across all seasons.

Additional Notes

The anthology format means that specific content and intensity can vary slightly between seasons, but the overall tone and themes remain consistently mature and graphic. Parents should research individual season summaries if they have particular sensitivities, though the general TV-MA rating applies to the entire franchise. The show frequently explores real-world societal issues, including discrimination, through a horror lens.

What are you watching next? Screen any title — no review needed.

Is American Horror Story right for your family?

These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.

Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.

“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”

— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX

“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”

— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)

No credit card required