The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

Name: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse - Christian Parent's Review
Item: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
Rating: 1
Author: StoryScanner

Here's what we found in The Twilight Saga: Eclipse. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family

General Review

Parent's Guide to The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse is the third installment in the popular romantic fantasy series, continuing the complex love story between human teenager Bella Swan, vampire Edward Cullen, and werewolf Jacob Black. The film builds upon the established supernatural world of Forks, Washington, as Bella finds herself at the center of a brewing conflict. A vengeful vampire, Victoria, is creating an army of "newborn" vampires to target Bella, forcing the ancient enemies—vampires and werewolves—to form an uneasy alliance for her protection. Targeted primarily at a young adult audience, the movie blends intense action sequences, a heightened sense of danger, and a deepening romantic entanglement. It explores themes of choice, sacrifice, and commitment amidst supernatural threats. While the film retains the romantic core of the series, it significantly escalates the stakes with more intense violence and darker undertones.

Things to Consider

High2

Violence

Eclipse is considered the most violent film in the series up to this point, featuring intense and graphic sequences of supernatural combat, dismemberment, and disturbing implied violence. The film showcases brutal attacks and deaths, significantly contributing to its PG-13 rating.

The film includes several highly violent scenes. For instance, the opening sequence depicts Riley being violently attacked by a shadowy vampire, thrown against a wall, and bitten on the hand, with visible bite marks as he is turned into a newborn vampire. Later, a flashback details Rosalie's tragic backstory, involving an "inferred rape scene and beating" by a group of men before she is transformed into a vampire, though this occurs off-screen. The climax features a large-scale battle where the Cullen family and werewolves fight Victoria's newborn vampire army, resulting in graphic dismemberment as vampires are ripped apart, their bodies shattering like stone.

Scary & Intense Content

Eclipse features highly intense and frightening sequences, including graphic supernatural violence, jump scares, and a pervasive sense of dread due to the constant threat to the protagonist. The film's darker tone and higher stakes contribute to a more disturbing experience than previous installments.

The film opens with an intense and frightening scene of Riley being brutally attacked and transformed into a vampire, setting a dark tone. A disturbing flashback depicts Rosalie's violent assault and near-death experience before her transformation into a vampire. The climax involves a large-scale, brutal battle between the Cullens, the Quileute wolves, and Victoria's newborn vampire army, filled with graphic fighting, dismemberment, and the constant threat of death to main characters.

Would these 2 concerns matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium4

LGBTQ & Gender IdentityRomance and Sexual ContentWitchcraft & OccultDisrespect & Rebellion

Low3

ProfanitySubstance UseAnti-Christian Themes

Medium4

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

The film does not contain explicitly LGBTQ+ characters or canonical storylines. However, academic analyses, fan discussions, and even comments from cast members suggest queer subtext or interpretations. Fan communities have explored homoerotic readings of the intense rivalry and bond between male characters Edward and Jacob. Promotional materials for the film were also noted for targeting the gay community.

While no explicit LGBTQ+ characters are present, academic papers discuss "queer readings" of the series, particularly focusing on the "triangular love" between Bella, Edward, and Jacob as having queer potential due to the intense male bond and rivalry between Edward and Jacob. Additionally, promotional photos for 'Eclipse' featuring Edward and Jacob without Bella were interpreted as a deliberate attempt by the studio to appeal to the gay community. Kristen Stewart, who plays Bella, retrospectively described 'Twilight' as 'such a gay movie' due to themes of 'oppression,' indicating a perceived subtext.

Romance and Sexual Content

The film features significant romantic tension and sensuality, focusing on the central love triangle. While explicit sexual acts are avoided, there are passionate kisses, suggestive situations, and discussions around premarital sex and virginity. The presence of shirtless male characters also contributes to the film's sensual elements.

Bella and Edward engage in several passionate kisses, including a scene where they are fully clothed, embracing on a bed, and Edward stops Bella's attempts to undress him, reinforcing his stance on waiting for marriage for sex. Bella explicitly tries to persuade Edward to engage in sexual activity, indicating her desire for intimacy. Jacob Black frequently appears shirtless throughout the film, particularly during scenes like the tent encounter, where he attempts to keep Bella warm, adding to the visual appeal and romantic tension in the love triangle.

Witchcraft & Occult

The entire premise of "The Twilight Saga: Eclipse" is steeped in supernatural elements, involving vampires, werewolves, and their associated powers and lore. While these elements are central, they are presented as fantasy rather than promoting real-world occult practices or rituals.

The narrative is driven by the conflict between vampires, who possess superhuman strength, speed, and unique abilities (like Alice Cullen's precognition), and werewolves, who can transform and exhibit supernatural healing and power. The creation of Victoria's 'newborn' vampire army, depicted as immensely strong and uncontrollably bloodthirsty, and their subsequent battle against the established supernatural factions, is a core occult theme. The Volturi, an ancient and powerful coven of vampires, also play a role as supernatural enforcers of the vampire world's laws.

Disrespect & Rebellion

The film portrays instances of mild disrespect and themes of rebellion, primarily through Bella's self-directed choices and her challenging of traditional expectations. Her intense commitment to Edward often puts her at odds with parental and societal norms, and Jacob also displays rebellious actions.

Bella demonstrates a rebellious spirit by consistently prioritizing her relationship with Edward and her desire to become a vampire over her human life and the concerns of her father, Charlie. This is exemplified by her willingness to make "self-destructive choices" for Edward. Jacob Black, despite knowing Bella's choice for Edward, continues to aggressively pursue her romantically, even kissing her against her will and acting defiantly towards Edward, showcasing his own rebellious nature.

Low3

Profanity

The film contains a limited amount of mild profanity and derogatory slang. It is infrequent and generally not used in an extreme or aggressive manner, aligning with its PG-13 rating.

Substance Use

The film includes brief and incidental depictions of alcohol consumption, primarily by adult characters. There is no significant focus on drug use or addiction.

Anti-Christian Themes

The film does not contain explicit anti-Christian themes or mockery. While its core involves supernatural beings like vampires and werewolves, which some Christian viewers might find problematic, the narrative does not actively promote anti-religious sentiments. In fact, aspects like Edward's insistence on marriage before sex can be seen to align with conservative values.

The supernatural elements of vampires and werewolves are presented as fantasy creatures within the film's universe rather than being tied to anti-Christian rituals or demonology. Notably, the film includes themes that align with conservative Christian values, such as Edward's firm stance against premarital sex, where he explicitly tells Bella he will not sleep with her until they are married. Bella also discusses her virginity with her father, Charlie, who expresses relief at her decision to wait.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse presents a mixed bag for Christian parents, offering some themes that align with biblical values while also featuring elements that warrant caution. On the positive side, the movie strongly emphasizes the value of commitment, self-sacrifice, and waiting for marriage for sexual intimacy. Edward's insistence on marrying Bella before they become intimate, and Bella's discussion of virginity with her father, align with conservative Christian values regarding sexual purity. The themes of self-sacrifice are prominent, with Edward, Jacob, and Bella all willing to risk or give up their lives for one another's protection, echoing biblical concepts of sacrificial love, such as 'Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends' (John 15:13). The narrative also highlights the importance of choosing good over evil, as the ancient enemies, vampires and werewolves, unite against a common threat, demonstrating that opposing forces can work together for a righteous goal. However, there are problematic aspects to consider. The central love triangle, while romanticized, can be seen as promoting an unhealthy, obsessive form of love rather than a balanced, God-honoring relationship. Bella's consistent prioritization of Edward and her desire to become a vampire over her human life and her father's concerns can be viewed as rebellious and self-destructive, contradicting biblical principles of honoring parents and valuing one's life. The underlying worldview, while not explicitly anti-Christian, introduces supernatural beings like vampires and werewolves without directly addressing their spiritual implications from a biblical perspective. While Edward's internal struggle against his vampiric nature might be seen as an allegory for overcoming temptation, the overall emphasis leans more towards a transcendent view of life through eternal romantic love rather than a purely biblical one centered on God. Family values are portrayed with some notable tensions. While Edward seeks Charlie's approval for marriage, Bella's intense focus on her relationship with Edward often leads her to disregard her father's worries and wishes, portraying a struggle with parental authority. The movie does not explicitly depict Christianity, but some interpretations suggest that Edward's character, in his struggle and abstinence, can be seen to exhibit certain Christian values, such as sexual abstinence and a respect for human life. However, the presence of occult and pagan elements, even if presented as fantasy, demands discernment for Christian families. Parents might find this movie a good starting point for discussions on healthy relationships, sacrificial love versus obsessive desire, and discerning spiritual themes in popular culture.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

Recommended for ages 14+ with parental guidance. The film is rated PG-13 by the MPAA primarily due to intense sequences of action and violence, and some sensuality. It contains graphic supernatural battles, an inferred scene of sexual assault in a flashback, and mature themes related to obsessive love and self-sacrifice, which may be disturbing or inappropriate for younger teens.

Good to Know

Parents should be aware that the intensity of violence and mature themes escalates significantly in Eclipse compared to the previous films in the series. Discussions about healthy relationships, consent (especially regarding Jacob's actions), and the implications of Bella's self-sacrificial tendencies for love might be beneficial for viewers, particularly teenage girls.

Related Reviews

View all movie reviews →

How does this review compare?

This review

9 standard concerns
General sensitivity level
One-size-fits-all perspective

Your report

Concerns you choose
Sensitivity levels you set
Tailored to your family

What are you watching next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly

Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families

Start free — 10 scans included