The Shadow
The media identified as "The Shadow (2024)" encompasses at least two distinct feature films: an Estonian historical crime thriller titled "The Shadow" (also known as "Vari") and an Indonesian action film titled "The Shadow Strays." The Estonian film, directed by Jaak Kilmi, is a period drama centered on the poet Juhan Liiv, who investigates gruesome murder cases amidst 19th-century Estonian nationalism under Russian imperial rule. This narrative blends psychological drama with murder intrigue and contains instances of graphic violence, alongside themes of identity, freedom, and the struggle against oppression. The Indonesian film, "The Shadow Strays," directed by Timo Tjahjanto, is a high-octane action crime thriller focusing on a young assassin's journey and her eventual defiance against her organization. It is critically noted for its extremely graphic and excessive violence, intense combat sequences, and significant gore. Due to the varied and intense content across these films, particularly the explicit violence present in both, parental guidance is strongly recommended, with the content being most suitable for mature audiences.
Concerns
Violence
HighBoth films contain high levels of violence. "The Shadow Strays" is notably extreme, with critics describing "nonstop carnage" and "slasher level gore effects." "The Shadow (Vari)" also features "very graphic and abundant violence" as its psychological drama evolves into a murder intrigue.
In "The Shadow Strays," reviewers noted "a graceless orgy of death and dismemberment" with "hundreds of gnarly kills" and significant blood and gore. For "The Shadow (Vari)," the narrative "morphs into a murder intrigue, with very graphic and abundant violence," involving multiple gruesome murder cases.
Scary & Intense Content
HighBoth films contain highly intense and potentially frightening content. "The Shadow Strays" is characterized by its "nonstop carnage" and "gruesome murder cases." "The Shadow (Vari)" features a "murder intrigue" with graphic violence and a "mysterious killer donning a horrific black mask."
"The Shadow Strays" is described as having "horrifying imagery" and being a "graceless orgy of death and dismemberment." In "The Shadow (Vari)," events take a turn into a "murder intrigue" involving a "mysterious killer donning a horrific black mask (taken straight out of a folk horror movie)," creating a suspenseful and frightening atmosphere.
Disrespect & Rebellion
HighThemes of defiance and rebellion are prominent in both films, though against different forms of authority. In "The Shadow (Vari)," the protagonist's ideas are subversive to political authority. In "The Shadow Strays," a young assassin rebels against her training organization.
In "The Shadow (Vari)," Juhan Liiv's "ideas are deeply subversive" as he questions the use of Russian in schools and a sycophantic 'God save the Emperor,' leading authorities to pursue him. In "The Shadow Strays," Codename 13, a 17-year-old assassin, disobeys orders by sparing an innocent target and later actively fights against her own organization, "The Shadow Guild."
Profanity
MediumWhile specific instances of profanity were not extensively detailed for either main film, general descriptions of "The Shadow (Vari)" as "mostly clean" suggest minimal profanity. For "The Shadow Strays," the focus of reviews was on graphic violence rather than language, but its intense nature implies the potential for some strong language.
For "The Shadow (Vari)," the film is generally noted as being "mostly clean" by one reviewer, implying a low incidence of strong language. In the trailer for "The Shadow (2024)" (Estonian film), dialogue includes phrases like "don't let that bastard get away with it" and a character repeatedly states "I want to kill him," indicating intense emotional language.
Witchcraft & Occult
Medium"The Shadow (Vari)" incorporates elements of the occult and supernatural. Investigations take the protagonist into areas where witchcraft is practiced, and 'the devil' is presented as a pervasive influence, providing explanations for events.
In "The Shadow (Vari)," the detective's investigations lead him "to the depths of ancient forests where witchcraft is still practiced." Additionally, "The devil is pervasive presence and provides a facile explanation for unwarranted events and behaviours" within the film's narrative.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowExplicit searches for LGBTQ+ content within "The Shadow (2024)" (referring to both the Estonian and Indonesian films) did not yield any specific in-film characters, plotlines, or themes related to LGBTQ+ or gender identity. While general searches for "Shadow"-related media (e.g., TV series, other films) did reveal LGBTQ+ content, it was not connected to the specific 2024 movie releases requested.
No direct examples of LGBTQ+ characters or themes were found within the content descriptions or reviews for either 'The Shadow (Vari)' or 'The Shadow Strays'.
Romance and Sexual Content
LowNeither identified film provides extensive detail on overt sexual content. "The Shadow (Vari)" includes an element of unrequited love, while "The Shadow Strays" focuses primarily on action. No graphic nudity or explicit sexual acts were indicated in available reviews.
In "The Shadow (Vari)," there is mention of Juhan Liiv's "unrequited love for the poet's obligatory muse, Liisa Golding," but this is portrayed without explicit sexual details. Reviews of "The Shadow (Vari)" also describe it as a "mostly clean movie" in some aspects, despite the violence.
Substance Use
LowNo specific details regarding substance use, such as explicit drug use or excessive alcohol consumption, were found for either "The Shadow (Vari)" or "The Shadow Strays" in the available content reviews.
No explicit scenes or references to drug use or significant alcohol consumption within the plot were mentioned in the analyses of either "The Shadow (Vari)" or "The Shadow Strays."
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes, mockery of Christian beliefs, or sacrilegious acts were identified in the content reviews for either "The Shadow (Vari)" or "The Shadow Strays." While "The Shadow (Vari)" references 'the devil' and 'witchcraft,' these are presented as narrative elements rather than direct attacks on Christianity.
Although "The Shadow (Vari)" mentions "The devil" as a "pervasive presence" in the story, it is presented as a facile explanation for events rather than an anti-Christian statement. References to "witchcraft" are within the context of a historical crime thriller's plot.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Recommended for ages 16 and older. Both identified films under "The Shadow (2024)" contain significant graphic violence, murder, and intense sequences. "The Shadow Strays" explicitly carries a "Not for under 16 years old" audience rating in some territories, reflecting the high level of mature content. The themes of rebellion, psychological distress, and occult references further necessitate a mature audience.
Additional Notes
Due to the generic nature of the title "The Shadow (2024)," two distinct feature films from 2024 were identified: an Estonian historical crime thriller ("The Shadow" or "Vari") and an Indonesian action film ("The Shadow Strays"). This analysis synthesized information from both, prioritizing more explicit content descriptions where available. Parents should verify which specific film they are considering. The high level of violence, particularly in "The Shadow Strays," is a significant parental concern.
Related Reviews
Is The Shadow right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required