The Shack
The Shack (2017) is a fantasy drama film that delves into profound themes of grief, faith, and forgiveness. The narrative follows Mackenzie "Mack" Phillips, a man deeply affected by the abduction and presumed murder of his youngest daughter, Missy. His spiritual journey begins when he receives a mysterious invitation to the isolated shack where evidence of her disappearance was found, leading to encounters with personifications of the Holy Trinity. The film explores Mack's struggle with suffering and trauma, ultimately aiming to deliver a message of healing and reconciliation through God's unconditional love. Targeted primarily at adults and mature adolescents, the movie addresses complex emotional and theological discussions. While it offers solace and a unique perspective on faith for many viewers, its unconventional theological interpretations of the Trinity and divine attributes have generated significant controversy and discussion within Christian communities. These aspects are central to the film's identity and its reception.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe movie contains significant thematic and implied violence, central to the protagonist's profound trauma. This includes severe childhood abuse, the off-screen abduction and murder of a child, implied patricide, and a suicide attempt. While not always graphically depicted, the emotional impact is intense.
Mack's childhood involves severe physical abuse from his alcoholic father, including a brutal beating with a belt after Mack confides in a preacher. As a 13-year-old, Mack is implied to have poisoned his abusive father with strychnine in his whiskey, leading to his father's death. Missy, Mack's youngest daughter, is abducted and murdered by a serial killer, with her blood-stained dress discovered in the shack and her body later seen in a casket. Mack contemplates suicide, pointing a revolver at his head before being interrupted.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe film is highly intense due to its central themes of profound loss, child murder, domestic violence, and a suicide attempt. These elements are deeply ingrained in the narrative and are portrayed with significant emotional weight, which can be distressing for viewers.
The central premise revolves around Mack's "Great Sadness" following the abduction and murder of his young daughter, Missy, with the discovery of her bloodied dress serving as a direct and intense reminder of the tragedy. Flashbacks throughout the film depict Mack's traumatic childhood, including instances of physical abuse from his alcoholic father. Mack experiences a moment of desperation where he holds a gun to his head, contemplating suicide.
Anti-Christian Themes
HighThe film generated significant controversy within Christian communities for its unorthodox theological portrayals. Critics have argued that its depiction of the Holy Trinity and interpretations of biblical concepts such as sin, judgment, and the crucifixion deviate from traditional Christian orthodoxy, leading to accusations of promoting heretical views.
The portrayal of God the Father as an African American woman ('Papa'), Jesus as a Middle Eastern man, and the Holy Spirit ('Sarayu') as an Asian woman was considered by many Christian leaders to be 'profoundly unbiblical' and 'problematic.' The film's theology has been criticized for promoting universalism and minimizing biblical concepts of God's holiness and wrath. For example, Papa states that 'Sin is its own punishment' and that God did not forsake Jesus on the cross, which contradicts traditional Christian understanding. Jesus's character in the film also makes statements such as 'religion is too much work,' which some found dismissive of organized Christianity.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumWhile there is no explicit sexual content, the film carries a strong and disturbing implication of child sexual assault in connection with Missy's murder. This element is significant to the plot and Mack's emotional journey. Other romantic elements are limited to the protagonist's marriage.
The central tragedy of Missy's abduction and murder includes a 'strong suggestion of a sexual assault of a young girl,' which is a disturbing, implied element of the narrative. Mack and his wife, Nan, share a loving and supportive relationship, but their intimacy is portrayed without explicit sexual content.
Substance Use
MediumSubstance use, specifically alcohol, is present early in the protagonist's life and is depicted with significant negative consequences. This includes the portrayal of an abusive alcoholic parent and an implied act of patricide involving poisoned alcohol.
Mack's childhood is marked by his father being an abusive alcoholic, a condition depicted as evil and immoral. As a 13-year-old, Mack puts strychnine poison into his father's whiskey, an act implied to be fatal, to stop the abuse.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThemes of disrespect and rebellion are explored through Mack's actions during his youth and his intense emotional and intellectual struggles with God in the face of tragedy. His journey involves openly challenging divine authority and questioning traditional faith.
As a boy, Mack makes the rebellious and ultimately fatal decision to poison his abusive, alcoholic father. Throughout his time at the shack, Mack openly challenges God (Papa, Jesus, Sarayu), expresses anger, and questions divine justice and love, reflecting a period of intense spiritual rebellion and disrespect towards traditional theological concepts of God.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowThe film does not feature explicit LGBTQ characters or storylines. The primary aspect related to gender identity is the non-traditional, symbolic portrayal of the Holy Trinity. These depictions are theological interpretations rather than representations of human LGBTQ identity.
God the Father is portrayed by an African American woman named Papa (Octavia Spencer). The Holy Spirit, Sarayu, is depicted as an Asian woman (Sumire Matsubara). Jesus is portrayed by a Middle Eastern man (Avraham Aviv Alush). These are symbolic cast choices for divine figures and do not involve human LGBTQ characters or themes.
Profanity
LowThe film contains very minimal and mild profanity. No strong or offensive language is used throughout the movie, making this a low concern for parents.
The character Mack is noted to say "Oh, my God" at one point, but he subsequently apologizes to the depiction of the Trinity. Parental reviews consistently indicate an absence or very mild language.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThe film does not depict or promote witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, or spells. Its spiritual elements are firmly rooted within a Christian theological framework, albeit with controversial interpretations.
The narrative focuses on Mack's spiritual journey and his encounters with characters representing the Christian Trinity. There are no elements related to witchcraft or occult practices. Mack references God as the "Great Spirit" in a story he tells his daughter, which is used as a narrative device and not an occult theme.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
The film is rated PG-13 for thematic material including some violence. Due to the intense and mature nature of its themes, such as child abduction, implied murder and sexual assault, domestic abuse, and a suicide attempt, a recommended age of 14+ is appropriate. Younger viewers may find the emotional weight and complex theological discussions challenging and potentially disturbing.
Additional Notes
The film has a runtime of 2 hours and 12 minutes. There were no indications of significantly different content across theatrical, extended, or director's cuts. While based on a popular novel, no direct movie sequels or adaptations that intensify content were identified. The movie's core themes remain consistent with the controversial elements of the book.
Related Reviews
Is The Shack right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required