Is The Rule of Jenny Pen right for your family?

This review covers common concerns — screen for what YOUR family cares about.

The Rule of Jenny Pen

Movie

The Rule of Jenny Pen (2025) is a psychological horror film starring John Lithgow and Geoffrey Rush, directed by James Ashcroft. Set in a New Zealand assisted living facility, the movie explores the dark themes of elder abuse, bullying, and psychological torment. It follows Stefan Mortensen, a former judge recovering from a stroke, who becomes the target of Dave Crealy, another resident who wields power over the facility's vulnerable inhabitants using a menacing hand puppet named Jenny Pen. The film has received critical acclaim for its performances and unsettling atmosphere, but it contains exceptionally disturbing and graphic content. Intended for mature audiences, it delves into the indignity of aging and the extreme measures taken to fight against tyranny and helplessness.

Content concerns found:Click to jump

What are you watching next? Screen any title — even ones without reviews elsewhere.

Concerns

Violence

High

The film contains very strong and disturbing violence, encompassing both physical brutality and intense psychological abuse, often targeting vulnerable elderly individuals within the nursing home setting. The violence is a central and pervasive element of the antagonist's terror.

Antagonist Dave Crealy manipulates an elderly character, leading them out into the woods at night where they subsequently drown in a muddy creek, their corpse later discovered face down. Dave violently rips a catheter out of another character, causing them to writhe in agony while also striking their injured hip. In the climax, Stefan and Tony ambush Dave and suffocate him to death with blankets in a laundry room.

Romance and Sexual Content

High

The movie features explicit sexual references and depicts instances of attempted sexual assault, which are presented in a highly disturbing and unsettling manner as tools of degradation and terror. These elements are integral to the villain's abuse tactics.

Dave Crealy crudely orders residents to 'lick Jenny Pen's a**hole,' presenting his wrist with the puppet as the target for this degrading act multiple times. Dave attempts to forcibly undress and sexually assault a helpless elderly woman, though he is stopped by Stefan. The film also includes a disturbing joke about a chaplain sexually assaulting a man when he was a child.

Profanity

High

The film features frequent strong profanity and offensive language, used casually and in frustration, with several instances of highly explicit curse words and crude sexual implications. This contributes to the movie's overall harsh and adult tone.

Reviews indicate 11 obscenities, including two uses of the 'f' word and other words with crude sexual implications. There is a single use of 'c*nt' as an insult, along with other offensive terms such as 'sh*t,' 'bloody,' 'bastard,' 'a**hole,' and 'wanker.'

Scary & Intense Content

High

The film is a psychological horror/thriller that maintains a high level of anxiety and dread through atmospheric fear, disturbing imagery, and intense psychological torment. It deals with traumatic subjects like elder abuse and helplessness, creating a deeply unsettling experience.

The movie is described as a 'mind-ripper that successfully both terrifies and horrifies,' employing unexpected framing, depth of field, and intense editing to convey Stefan's deteriorating mental state and the oppressive environment. A nightmare scene explicitly shows 'lots of blood' pouring out, contributing to the graphic and frightening nature of the content. The themes of medical gaslighting, elder abuse, and the loss of personal autonomy contribute significantly to its 'low-level terror' and 'painfully cautionary tale' aspect.

Disrespect & Rebellion

High

The film centrally features extreme disrespect and rebellion, as Dave Crealy systematically abuses and terrorizes other residents and staff, effectively running the care home through fear. Stefan Mortensen, initially a condescending character, eventually engages in a violent act of rebellion to end Dave's tyranny. The staff are also depicted as negligent and dismissive of resident concerns.

Dave Crealy 'terrorizes the people in a nursing home' with 'multiple acts of casual cruelty,' demanding residents answer 'Jenny Pen' when he asks 'Who rules?'. Stefan Mortensen, initially a 'condescending dickhead' and 'contemptuous of the mostly female care staff,' eventually conspires with Tony to lure Dave to a laundry room and suffocate him to death as an act of defiance against his abuse.

Found 5 high-concern themes. Want to set your own sensitivity levels?

Substance Use

Medium

There is a brief depiction of alcohol use where an elderly character is shown swigging an alcohol bottle, portrayed unfavorably. This instance is minor and not central to the plot.

A 'broken old man' is observed swigging an alcohol bottle, which is presented negatively within the film's context. Beyond this specific scene, further explicit substance abuse is not detailed as a prominent concern in available content reviews.

Anti-Christian Themes

Medium

While one review suggests a 'Light Christian, redemptive, moral worldview,' a highly concerning element is the inclusion of a joke about a chaplain sexually assaulting a child. This negative portrayal, even if brief, casts a shadow on faith representation, creating a problematic association for Christian viewers.

Movieguide notes the film's worldview as 'Light Christian, redemptive, moral' where the hero risks his life for others. However, a character makes a disturbing joke about a chaplain sexually assaulting a man when he was a child, introducing a significant anti-clerical or anti-Christian insinuation.

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

Low

No confirmed LGBTQ+ characters, themes, or representation were found in the available public reviews and content analyses for "The Rule of Jenny Pen (2025)". While one search result referenced a separate film featuring a gay couple, this was not in relation to the content of 'The Rule of Jenny Pen'.

Across multiple explicit searches for LGBTQ+ content pertaining to 'The Rule of Jenny Pen (2025)', no direct or implied instances of LGBTQ+ characters or themes were identified in the movie's plot or character descriptions. A search result mentioned 'LOVE IS STRANGE', a film starring John Lithgow about a gay couple, but explicitly noted it was a separate movie.

Witchcraft & Occult

Low

The movie incorporates a symbolic, non-magical element of the occult with a 'death-sensing cat' named Pluto, which acts as a 'harbinger of the end.' However, there are no depictions of witchcraft, magic rituals, demons, or explicit occult practices performed by characters within the film.

The cat, Pluto, is noted to appear around patients who are about to die, symbolizing inevitability rather than active supernatural intervention. Dave's puppet, Jenny Pen, is a tool of psychological terror and control, not a magical or occult artifact.

Other Notes

Target Demographic

This film is strictly recommended for adults aged 18+ due to its R-rating and extensive disturbing content, including graphic violence, sexual assault, strong profanity, and psychologically intense themes. Younger audiences, even older teenagers, are likely to find the depictions of elder abuse, sexual violence, and the bleak moral landscape deeply unsettling and potentially traumatizing.

Additional Notes

The film is distributed by IFC Films and Shudder, indicating its target audience is likely fans of independent and psychological horror. Reviews frequently mention the slow-burn nature of the film, which may not appeal to all viewers. The movie has been praised for the powerful performances of its lead actors, John Lithgow and Geoffrey Rush, but some critics note 'massive leaps in logic regarding the staff's negligence' which may strain credibility for some viewers.

What are you watching next? Screen any title — no review needed.

Is The Rule of Jenny Pen right for your family?

These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.

Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.

“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”

— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX

“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”

— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)

No credit card required