Stonehearst Asylum
Stonehearst Asylum (2014) is a psychological horror-thriller set in a remote English mental institution in 1899, loosely based on Edgar Allan Poe's short story "The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether." The film follows a young Oxford graduate, Dr. Edward Newgate, who arrives for an apprenticeship and quickly becomes entangled in the asylum's dark secrets. He falls for a mysterious patient, Eliza Graves, and uncovers a horrifying truth about the facility's leadership. The movie explores themes of sanity, madness, and the barbaric medical practices of the era. It is characterized by its eerie, gothic atmosphere and psychological tension rather than jump scares, making it suitable for audiences who appreciate suspenseful drama with a historical setting.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe film contains significant violence, including graphic descriptions of mutilation, random acts of brutality, and disturbing portrayals of inhumane medical procedures.
Eliza Graves' backstory reveals that she bit off her husband's ear and gouged out his eye with a comb in self-defense after he sexually assaulted her. Mickey Finn, a patient acting as a steward, is depicted as a 'murderous henchman' who 'dispenses violence randomly.' The asylum also features 'torturous forms of treatment,' such as electric shock therapy administered to the imprisoned Dr. Salt. The climax includes Finn bursting into flames and setting the asylum on fire.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe film delivers a high level of psychological tension, an eerie atmosphere, and disturbing content related to mental illness and archaic treatments, contributing to a stressful and unsettling viewing experience.
The core plot, where patients have taken over the asylum and imprisoned the real staff, creates a pervasive sense of suspense and danger. The film features unsettling depictions of 'barbaric remedies' and 'torturous forms of treatment,' including electroshock therapy and other bizarre medical devices. The gothic setting, dark lighting, and unpredictable behavior of the patients and 'staff' enhance the feeling of psychological horror and unease.
Disrespect & Rebellion
HighThe central premise of the film is an extreme act of rebellion, where the inmates of a mental asylum overthrow, imprison, and replace the legitimate medical staff, then operate the institution according to their own distorted beliefs.
The plot hinges on the discovery that Dr. Silas Lamb, an inmate, has led a rebellion to imprison the actual superintendent, Dr. Benjamin Salt, and his staff in the asylum's basement. Lamb and the other patients then assume the roles of administrators and caregivers, defying all societal and medical authority. Mickey Finn, another patient-turned-enforcer, exhibits extreme disregard for order through his violent actions.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe film includes a historical reference to 'incurable homosexuality' as a mental illness within the context of late 19th-century psychiatric diagnoses, but it does not feature LGBTQ characters or modern representations.
During Dr. Newgate's introduction to the asylum, Dr. Lamb lists various 'cases' found there, explicitly mentioning 'incurable homosexuality' as a condition requiring treatment, reflecting the archaic medical views of the period. A review also notes that "only sixty years ago the treatment for mental 'illnesses' such as homosexuality and women's hysteria was barbaric."
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe film features a central romantic plot, but also includes disturbing thematic elements of sexual assault (implied or discussed) and historically inappropriate medical practices related to female sexuality.
A core narrative element is the romantic attraction between Dr. Edward Newgate and the patient Eliza Graves. Eliza's backstory details her violent reaction to her husband's attempt to 'force her into sodomy.' In an opening scene, a doctor 'inappropriately' touches Eliza to induce a 'hysteric fit' for a medical demonstration. The film also references historical 'sexual practices in the name of medical science' used to 'cure' women's hysteria. There are instances of kissing and suggestive comments.
Profanity
MediumThe film carries a PG-13 rating, which typically indicates the presence of some brief strong language, though extensive or frequent profanity is not highlighted as a dominant element in reviews.
While specific quotes of profanity are not widely detailed in available content analyses, the PG-13 rating by the MPAA often allows for a moderate amount of strong language. The rating descriptors mention "brief strong language."
Substance Use
MediumThe film depicts the use of sedative drugs in a medical context and includes instances of casual alcohol consumption consistent with the period setting.
In the film's opening sequence, Eliza Graves is presented to medical students as a 'heroin-sedated patient' for a demonstration. Characters are also shown engaging in casual drinking of alcohol throughout the film, as noted in general content descriptions.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThere are no identifiable elements of witchcraft, occult practices, magic, or explicit supernatural occurrences within the film's narrative.
The film is consistently categorized as a psychological thriller or gothic drama, grounded in human psychology, deception, and historical medical practices rather than supernatural or occult themes. Reviews confirm the absence of ghosts or other magical elements.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes, mockery of Christian beliefs, or negative portrayals of Christian symbols or figures were identified in the film.
The narrative focuses on the moral and ethical dilemmas surrounding mental health treatment in a historical context, rather than engaging with religious criticisms. Content reviews and plot summaries do not indicate any direct conflict with or disrespect towards Christian faith or practices.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
The film is recommended for ages 15 and older. This recommendation is based on the PG-13 rating (with a UK equivalent of 15) which accounts for strong thematic elements including psychological intensity, disturbing depictions of mental illness and inhumane medical treatments, implied sexual assault, and moments of violence and peril.
Additional Notes
The film does not have sequels or adaptations that introduce new or intensified content; it is a standalone adaptation of an Edgar Allan Poe short story. Some reviewers note that the film's tone can be inconsistent, occasionally veering into over-the-top or campy territory despite its serious subject matter.
Related Reviews
Is Stonehearst Asylum right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required