Start free10 free scans

Mulan

Name: Mulan - Christian Parent's Review
Item: Mulan
Rating: 1
Author: StoryScanner

Here's what we found in Mulan. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.

Screen for YOUR family

General Review

Parent's Guide to Mulan

Mulan is a historical action-drama film, with both an animated 1998 version and a 2020 live-action adaptation, based on the Chinese legend of Hua Mulan. The story follows a young woman who disguises herself as a man to take her ailing father's place in the Imperial Army, fighting against invaders to bring honor to her family and country. Both films explore themes of identity, honor, courage, and challenging societal expectations regarding gender roles. The animated version is a musical fantasy, while the live-action remake is a more serious war epic with martial arts elements. Due to intense battle sequences, some supernatural elements, and themes of war and deception, the films are generally recommended for older children and adolescents, offering a powerful narrative of a strong female protagonist.

Things to Consider

High2

Violence

Both versions of Mulan feature significant battle violence, particularly the live-action film, which contains numerous war scenes. While graphic gore is minimized, the depiction of large-scale combat, casualties, and intense one-on-one fights is prevalent. The violence can be intense and realistic, with implied deaths and peril.

The 2020 live-action film includes extensive battle scenes where soldiers are shot with arrows, struck by swords, and numerous dead bodies are shown strewn across battlegrounds. In one sequence, Mulan causes a massive avalanche that engulfs and presumably kills scores of enemy soldiers, and she later navigates a battlefield filled with deceased combatants. The witch character, Xianniang, uses long talons to claw at people, and in one scene, blood is visible dripping from her talons.

Witchcraft & Occult

Both films contain elements that could be categorized as witchcraft or occult. The animated film includes ancestor spirits that are presented comically. The live-action film features more prominent supernatural elements through the witch Xianniang and the concept of 'Qi,' a spiritual energy that grants superhuman abilities. Ancestor worship is also depicted.

The 2020 live-action film features Xianniang, a powerful witch capable of transforming into a bird of prey or a flock of birds, and displaying supernatural combat abilities. The film's central theme of 'Qi' (Chi) describes a spiritual life energy that manifests as superpower-like abilities in characters like Mulan and Xianniang, which is explicitly taught and discussed as a source of power. The animated 1998 film depicts ancestor spirits who are awakened and advise Mulan's family, participating in magical sequences, and some Christian reviewers consider these elements, along with Chinese mysticism, as anti-Christian.

Would these 2 concerns matter to your family?

Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.

Medium5

LGBTQ & Gender IdentityRomance and Sexual ContentScary & Intense ContentDisrespect & RebellionAnti-Christian Themes

Low2

ProfanitySubstance Use

Medium5

LGBTQ & Gender Identity

The animated Mulan (1998) features a significant queer subtext, particularly around Captain Li Shang, who develops attraction to Mulan while she is disguised as a man (Ping), leading to his interpretation as a bisexual icon. The live-action Mulan (2020) largely removes explicit romance but maintains a subtle queer subtext in the interactions between Mulan (as Hua Jun) and fellow soldier Chen Honghui. Both films, through Mulan's gender-bending and quest for self-identity, resonate with LGBTQ+ themes of not conforming to societal expectations. The character of Xianniang, the witch in the 2020 film, also connects with Mulan over their shared experiences as powerful women defying patriarchal norms.

In the 1998 animated film, Captain Li Shang shows clear respect and developing affection for Mulan when she is disguised as 'Ping,' a male soldier, and these feelings seem to continue even after her true identity is revealed, leading to his status as a bisexual icon. In the 2020 live-action film, while explicit romance is minimal, fellow soldier Chen Honghui expresses intrigue and respect for 'Hua Jun' (Mulan's male disguise), noting something 'special about this young dude,' which is interpreted as carrying queer subtext. The witch Xianniang in the 2020 film attempts to recruit Mulan, stating, 'You and I are the same. We have been made outcasts because of our power,' highlighting a connection based on defying gendered power structures.

Romance and Sexual Content

Romance is present in both films but handled differently. The animated version has a clear romantic arc. The live-action version features mild romantic tension and brief suggestive elements, but no explicit sexual content or nudity.

In the 1998 animated film, there is a developing romantic relationship between Mulan and Captain Li Shang, culminating in implied affection and a kiss. The 2020 live-action film includes mild romantic tension between Mulan and Chen Honghui, where they briefly hold hands. In one scene, Mulan is shown bathing naked in a river (her body mostly obscured by water), and a male soldier approaches to bathe nearby, stripping off his clothes at the water's edge while Mulan keeps her back turned to conceal her identity.

Scary & Intense Content

Both Mulan films contain elements that can be scary and intense, especially for younger audiences. The live-action version, with its more realistic portrayals of war and darker antagonist characters, is notably more intense.

The 2020 live-action 'Mulan' features the fierce enemy leader Bori Khan with a scarred, angry face and the scary witch Xianniang, who has painted eyes and blood dripping from her talons. Battle scenes are described as very dramatic and intense, showing agitated soldiers and perilous situations like an avalanche or Mulan balancing over molten lava. The 1998 animated film also includes intense moments such as the Hun invasion and the terrifying villain Shan Yu, along with large-scale battle sequences including an avalanche.

Disrespect & Rebellion

A central theme in both Mulan films is the protagonist's rebellion against traditional gender roles and societal expectations. Mulan's actions, while heroic, begin with an act of deception and defiance towards her family and established patriarchal norms.

Mulan's fundamental act of rebellion in both films is disguising herself as a man to join the Imperial Army, directly disobeying her family's wishes and societal expectations for women. In the 2020 film, Mulan's father, Zhou, expresses anger and asserts his authority by banging his fist on the table, stating 'I am the father!' when she questions traditional roles. The witch Xianniang in the 2020 film also represents a figure who was outcast for defying expectations and becoming powerful, suggesting a rebellious path to Mulan.

Anti-Christian Themes

Both Mulan films incorporate elements from Chinese folklore and spiritual traditions that may be considered anti-Christian by some Christian parents. These include ancestor worship, the presence of spiritual guides (like Mushu and the ancestors in the animated film, or the phoenix and 'Qi' in the live-action), and magic/witchcraft, which some reviewers explicitly identify as false religion or occult content.

The 2020 live-action 'Mulan' presents an 'Ancient Chinese false religious worldview with lots of occult activity by a witch,' ancestor worship, and the concept of 'chi' (Qi) as a spiritual energy granting powers. Some Christian reviewers specifically call this 'strong false religious, occult content' and 'abhorrent.' The 1998 animated 'Mulan' includes ancestor spirits who visibly appear and offer guidance to Mulan and her family, which some Christian viewers perceive as promoting Chinese mysticism and spiritism that undermines Judeo-Christian values.

Low2

Profanity

Neither the animated nor the live-action Mulan films contain strong profanity. The language remains generally clean, though the live-action version includes some mild, bawdy discussions among male soldiers.

Substance Use

Both the animated and live-action Mulan films contain minimal to no substance use. There are no depictions of illegal drugs, smoking, or problematic alcohol consumption.

Want these personalized to YOUR family?

Mulan offers Christian parents a complex but generally commendable narrative when viewed through a biblical lens. Core themes such as courage, self-sacrifice, honor, loyalty, and responsibility strongly align with biblical values, emphasizing putting others before oneself and demonstrating bravery in the face of adversity. Mulan's primary motivation to save her ailing father exemplifies a profound love and respect for parents, echoing the biblical commandment to honor one's father and mother. The films consistently reward Mulan's virtues of ingenuity, persistence, and selflessness, while the antagonists face consequences for their vice and aggression, establishing a clear sense of moral accountability. While Mulan's initial deception of disguising herself as a man could be seen as contradictory to biblical truthfulness, it is undertaken for a higher moral purpose—saving her father's life and her country—which some Christian analyses liken to biblical figures who used deception for a greater good. The worldview presented in "Mulan" is largely transcendent in its emphasis on intangible virtues like honor and duty, rather than purely materialistic gain, though it is rooted in Eastern cultural concepts rather than a Judeo-Christian understanding of God. The concept of 'honor' is central, driving Mulan's actions and the family's standing. Redemption themes are present in Mulan's sacrificial act for her family and country, demonstrating a selfless love. While not explicitly Christian, Mulan's journey of finding her true identity and purpose can resonate with the Christian concept of being designed with a divine purpose. Family values are highly esteemed, portraying strong bonds, filial piety (respect for parents), and the importance of protecting one's family, which are all congruent with Christian family principles. However, it is crucial for Christian parents to note the representation of faith in both versions. The films depict Chinese mysticism, particularly ancestor worship and the presence of ancestor spirits (especially in the animated version) and the concept of 'Qi' (Chi) as a spiritual life energy (more prominent in the live-action film), which some Christian reviewers consider unbiblical and potentially problematic for discerning children.

Additional Context

Best For Ages

Ages 10+ due to extensive battle violence, intense thematic elements, and depictions of death that may be disturbing for younger viewers. Parental guidance is recommended for children aged 10-13, particularly for the live-action version which has more realistic combat.

Good to Know

Parents should be aware of the stylistic differences between the animated (1998) and live-action (2020) versions. The live-action film is a more serious war drama with realistic combat sequences and a darker tone, which contributes to higher severity ratings for violence and scary content compared to the animated musical. While explicit LGBTQ+ content is absent, the underlying themes of identity and non-conformity in both films have resonated deeply with LGBTQ+ audiences. The cultural elements of Chinese folklore, including ancestor reverence and spiritual energy, are central to the narrative and should be considered by parents evaluating anti-Christian themes.

Related Reviews

View all movie reviews →

How does this review compare?

This review

9 standard concerns
General sensitivity level
One-size-fits-all perspective

Your report

Concerns you choose
Sensitivity levels you set
Tailored to your family

What are you watching next?

Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.

Personalized to your valuesDetailed findingsAny title, instantly

Start with 10 free scans

No credit card required — join hundreds of families

Start free — 10 scans included