Smile
Smile is a critically acclaimed, Eisner Award-winning graphic memoir by Raina Telgemeier, chronicling her challenging journey through middle and high school while undergoing extensive dental procedures. The narrative begins when Raina, then a sixth-grader, suffers a severe accident that injures her two front teeth, leading to years of orthodontic work, surgeries, and the wearing of various dental appliances like braces and headgear. Through a blend of humor and heartfelt honesty, the book explores universal adolescent experiences, including navigating complex friendships, dealing with teasing and peer pressure, developing self-consciousness about appearance, experiencing first crushes, and ultimately finding self-acceptance. Primarily aimed at middle-grade readers, generally within the 9-13 age range, the book addresses themes of resilience, growing up, and the importance of true friendship. While the content is largely wholesome and relatable, parents should be aware of the detailed, sometimes intense, depictions of dental trauma and medical procedures. The story also features instances of social drama and bullying. Overall, Smile is celebrated for its authentic portrayal of teenage life and its ability to connect with young readers through its engaging graphic novel format, offering valuable insights into overcoming adversity and embracing individuality.
Concerns
Violence
MediumThe book's central plot revolves around a significant physical injury to the protagonist's teeth and the subsequent extensive and often painful dental procedures. While not depicting intentional violence between characters, the graphic nature of the accident and medical interventions can be intense and unsettling for some readers, including visual representations of blood and surgical tools.
1. The story begins with Raina severely injuring her two front teeth in a fall, an accident described and visually depicted as a jarring event. This incident is the catalyst for years of dental work, root canals, and surgeries. 2. There are multiple scenes illustrating dental procedures, including extractions, braces adjustments, and the use of headgear, which are portrayed with some visual detail that could be perceived as painful or frightening, with one review noting "graphic depictions of blood and dental work could be scary for a young child."
Romance and Sexual Content
Medium"Smile" includes typical pre-teen and teenage crushes and mild flirtation, reflecting common middle school experiences. The content remains chaste and does not feature any explicit sexual acts or graphic descriptions. A notable instance of social interaction is a game of 'spin the bottle,' though the book does not detail any explicit outcomes from this game.
1. Raina experiences several crushes on boys throughout the story, such as a boy in her band class, which is portrayed innocently with internal thoughts and mild interactions. 2. The protagonist's friends engage in a game of 'spin the bottle.' While the scene itself doesn't show explicit activity, its inclusion is noted by parental reviews as potentially concerning for younger readers.
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe most intense aspects of "Smile" stem from the physical pain and discomfort associated with Raina's dental accident and subsequent numerous medical procedures. Beyond the physical, emotional intensity arises from significant social drama, peer bullying, and feelings of insecurity and embarrassment, which could be distressing for some sensitive readers.
1. The graphic depictions of Raina's initial dental injury and the ongoing cycle of orthodontist visits, surgeries, and root canals can be visually and emotionally intense, particularly for younger children who may fear dental work. 2. Raina's experiences with her "un-friendly" friends who tease her and engage in socially cruel acts, such as pulling down her skirt in front of others, create considerable emotional distress and anxiety for the protagonist.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe book portrays significant instances of disrespect and bullying among pre-teen friends, which is a major plot point for Raina's character development. While typical adolescent frustrations toward parents are present, the primary concern lies in the portrayal of peer unkindness and defiant attitudes within her social circle.
1. Raina's original friend group frequently exhibits disrespectful and unkind behavior, including teasing her about her appearance (teeth, clothes) and making fun of her crushes. 2. A particularly impactful scene of disrespect involves Raina's friends pulling down her skirt during lunch, causing her significant humiliation and ultimately leading her to seek new friends.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowThe graphic memoir "Smile" by Raina Telgemeier does not contain any explicit LGBTQ+ characters or themes. The story focuses exclusively on the protagonist Raina's personal experiences with dental trauma, friendships, and adolescent challenges within a heterosexual context. While the author, Raina Telgemeier, has included LGBTQ+ characters in her other works, notably the graphic novel "Drama," this content is not present in "Smile."
1. "Smile" is an autobiographical account of Raina Telgemeier's middle and high school years, detailing her dental journey and social life, with no characters identified as LGBTQ+. 2. The narrative depicts typical boy-girl crushes and friendships without exploring themes of same-sex relationships or gender identity. The LGBTQ+ representation found in search results refers to the author's other book, "Drama," which features gay characters like Justin and Jesse, who are not present in "Smile."
Profanity
LowThe graphic novel "Smile" generally features mild language appropriate for its middle-grade target audience. There are no instances of strong profanity, offensive curse words (such as the F-word or S-word), or consistently vulgar dialogue reported within the text.
1. Reviews and educational guides consistently characterize the language in "Smile" as suitable for elementary and middle school readers, without highlighting any concerns regarding strong language. 2. Dialogue primarily consists of realistic exchanges between adolescents and family members, which may include mild exclamations but avoids any explicit or aggressive profanity.
Witchcraft & Occult
Low"Smile" is a realistic, autobiographical graphic novel that does not feature any elements of witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, or supernatural themes. The story is grounded in real-life events and personal experiences.
1. The plot of "Smile" focuses entirely on Raina's real-life dental issues, family dynamics, and social struggles, without introducing any magical or mystical elements. 2. The narrative maintains a secular and factual tone, consistent with a memoir, and there are no characters who practice magic, engage in rituals, or encounter demons or spirits.
Substance Use
LowThe book contains no depiction or discussion of substance use, including alcohol, drugs, or smoking. The content is suitable for its target age group and avoids any themes related to intoxication, addiction, or illegal substances.
1. Parental reviews and summaries of "Smile" do not mention any scenes or dialogue involving characters consuming alcohol, using drugs, or smoking. 2. The story's focus on school life, friendships, and personal challenges is devoid of any references to substance abuse, aligning with its middle-grade appropriateness.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowThe graphic novel "Smile" does not contain any anti-Christian themes, religious mockery, or explicit criticism of Christian beliefs or practices. The narrative is a secular memoir focused on personal growth and adolescent experiences.
1. The story's content is entirely secular, centering on Raina's personal life and social interactions without any engagement with religious topics, either positively or negatively. 2. Reviews and educational materials for the book do not indicate the presence of any religious content or themes that could be interpreted as anti-Christian.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
This book is recommended for ages 9+ (grades 4-7). While some sources suggest an age range of 8-12, the detailed graphic depictions of dental trauma and surgeries, along with the emotional intensity of peer bullying and social drama, may be unsettling for younger or more sensitive readers. Middle schoolers will likely relate more to the complex social dynamics and personal struggles depicted.
Additional Notes
Smile is a graphic novel memoir, making its visual content an important aspect of its impact. The illustrations are expressive and directly convey Raina's emotional and physical journey. While the book addresses serious themes of bullying and insecurity, it ultimately emphasizes resilience, self-discovery, and the importance of finding supportive friendships. Parents may find it a useful tool for discussing these themes with their children.
Related Reviews
Is Smile right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required