One of Us Is Next
“One of Us Is Next” by Karen M. McManus is a young adult mystery-thriller and the highly anticipated sequel to “One of Us Is Lying.” Set a year and a half after the original Bayview High mystery, the story introduces a new, anonymous "Truth or Dare" game that targets students, forcing them to reveal dark secrets or complete dangerous tasks. As the dares escalate and become deadly, a new trio of protagonists – Maeve, Phoebe, and Knox – must work together to unmask the mastermind behind the game. The narrative weaves together themes of secrets, social media's pervasive influence, bullying, and the complexities of adolescent relationships, delivering a suspenseful and twist-filled plot that keeps readers engaged. The book is designed for a young adult audience, continuing the high-stakes drama and character-driven mystery that defined its predecessor. It offers a contemporary setting where teenage anxieties and moral dilemmas are amplified by a sinister online game. While it functions as a standalone, readers familiar with the first book will recognize returning characters and appreciate the ongoing evolution of the Bayview High universe. It is important to note that the book series and its TV adaptation have diverged in their storylines, particularly concerning certain character relationships.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe central plot involves a dangerous 'Truth or Dare' game that escalates to lethal consequences, directly leading to character deaths and other severe physical harm. The violence is integral to the thriller genre, featuring both direct and implied acts of aggression, including attempted bombing and physical attacks.
A student named Brandon is killed while attempting a dare, which is a pivotal event in the story. Content warnings for the book specifically list 'attempted bombing and murder, and actual character death.' Additionally, a review mentions scenes where a 'Character falls through a roof which ends in death, Character gets concussion, Character sexually forces himself on another character.'
Profanity
HighProfanity is present throughout the book, with reviewers noting the frequent use of strong language. The inclusion of explicit curse words contributes to the realistic depiction of high school dialogue and intense situations.
Reviews indicate 'Extreme profanity used fairly frequently' within the narrative. Specific examples of strong language mentioned include 'Sh*t,' 'f**k,' and 'd*mn.'
Scary & Intense Content
HighAs a young adult thriller, 'One of Us Is Next' contains significant scary and intense content. The plot is driven by a deadly 'Truth or Dare' game that creates a pervasive atmosphere of suspense, fear, and psychological tension. This includes threatening messages, dangerous dares, and the ultimate death of a student, ensuring a consistently high level of drama and urgency.
The game's dares become 'deadly,' creating intense situations where characters' lives are at risk. The narrative features 'threatening messages online and through text messages' that create a frightening environment for the students. The book is characterized by 'jaw dropping plot twists' and 'plenty of tense moments' as the protagonists race to solve the mystery.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book includes LGBTQ representation through established characters, most notably Cooper, who is openly gay and in a stable relationship with his boyfriend Chris. His past experience of being outed and facing discrimination is referenced. The narrative also mentions a character whose father reacted homophobically to her coming out as a lesbian, indicating the presence or discussion of lesbian identity. There are no explicit transgender characters identified within the book itself, though the author is known for including LGBTQ characters in her works.
Cooper, a character from 'One of Us Is Lying' who appears in 'One of Us Is Next,' is openly gay and happily involved with his boyfriend, Chris. His previous struggles with being outed are acknowledged. The book also references a character whose father was homophobic when she came out as a lesbian, highlighting issues of discrimination.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe book contains romantic elements including kissing and references to characters' sex lives. It also addresses sensitive topics such as sexual assault, indicated by a trigger warning, and slut shaming as a consequence of leaked secrets. The content includes implied sexual activity rather than explicit depictions.
The book features 'some kisses/make-outs' and 'general discussion of sex life' among the teenage characters. A trigger warning specifically notes 'sexual assault (unwanted kissing/grabbing – Ch. 8)' and 'slut shaming.' One of the truths revealed through the game involves a girl being bullied due to rumors about her sleeping with someone.
Substance Use
MediumThe book depicts underage drinking, including instances of characters consuming alcohol at parties and one character experiencing alcohol poisoning. References to drug use are also present, aligning with some characters' established backgrounds from the previous book in the series.
The book includes a scene showing a 'house party at which teens are drinking alcohol,' contributing to the theme of underage drinking. Additionally, there is a content warning for a 'Character drinks to excess and ends up getting alcohol poisoning.' The character Nate Macauley, known from 'One of Us Is Lying,' was on probation for dealing drugs, and his past is part of the established background for characters in 'One of Us Is Next.'
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe book prominently features teenagers navigating complex and dangerous situations independently, often choosing to keep secrets from adults and law enforcement. While not always overtly defiant, this demonstrates a theme of adolescent self-reliance and occasional disregard for conventional rules and adult authority figures in their pursuit of solving the mystery.
The main characters, Maeve, Phoebe, and Knox, feel they 'can't count on the police for help. Or protection' when the dares become deadly, prompting them to investigate on their own. The premise of the 'Truth or Dare' game itself encourages students to keep and reveal 'deepest darkest secrets,' highlighting a culture where peer influence and personal agendas often supersede respect for authority.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThere is no content related to witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, spells, or other supernatural elements in 'One of Us Is Next.' The narrative is firmly set in a realistic contemporary thriller genre.
No instances of witchcraft or occult themes were found in the comprehensive search. The story's mystery and suspense are entirely grounded in human actions and motives.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowThere are no anti-Christian themes, mockery of Christian beliefs, or sacrilegious acts present or referenced within 'One of Us Is Next.' The book is a secular young adult thriller that does not delve into religious commentary or criticism.
No instances of anti-Christian themes were identified in the search results. The storyline focuses on contemporary issues within a high school setting, devoid of religious conflict or content.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
One of Us Is Next is recommended for readers aged 14 and up, or those in grades 9 and up. This recommendation is supported by the mature themes present, including violence, sexual content, frequent profanity, and substance use, which are handled in a manner generally considered appropriate for young adult audiences capable of processing complex, intense plots and character struggles.
Additional Notes
While 'One of Us Is Next' can be read as a standalone, its enjoyment and full understanding are enhanced by prior reading of 'One of Us Is Lying' due to returning characters and ongoing plotlines. The television adaptation of 'One of Us Is Lying' has diverged from the book series, so content and character relationships in the show may not reflect those in the book.
Related Reviews
Is One of Us Is Next right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required