One of Us Is Next
Here's what we found in One of Us Is Next. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.
Screen for YOUR familyParent's Guide to One of Us Is Next
“One of Us Is Next” by Karen M. McManus is a young adult mystery-thriller and the highly anticipated sequel to “One of Us Is Lying.” Set a year and a half after the original Bayview High mystery, the story introduces a new, anonymous "Truth or Dare" game that targets students, forcing them to reveal dark secrets or complete dangerous tasks. As the dares escalate and become deadly, a new trio of protagonists – Maeve, Phoebe, and Knox – must work together to unmask the mastermind behind the game. The narrative weaves together themes of secrets, social media's pervasive influence, bullying, and the complexities of adolescent relationships, delivering a suspenseful and twist-filled plot that keeps readers engaged. The book is designed for a young adult audience, continuing the high-stakes drama and character-driven mystery that defined its predecessor. It offers a contemporary setting where teenage anxieties and moral dilemmas are amplified by a sinister online game. While it functions as a standalone, readers familiar with the first book will recognize returning characters and appreciate the ongoing evolution of the Bayview High universe. It is important to note that the book series and its TV adaptation have diverged in their storylines, particularly concerning certain character relationships.
Things to Consider
Violence
The central plot involves a dangerous 'Truth or Dare' game that escalates to lethal consequences, directly leading to character deaths and other severe physical harm. The violence is integral to the thriller genre, featuring both direct and implied acts of aggression, including attempted bombing and physical attacks.
A student named Brandon is killed while attempting a dare, which is a pivotal event in the story. Content warnings for the book specifically list 'attempted bombing and murder, and actual character death.' Additionally, a review mentions scenes where a 'Character falls through a roof which ends in death, Character gets concussion, Character sexually forces himself on another character.'
Profanity
Profanity is present throughout the book, with reviewers noting the frequent use of strong language. The inclusion of explicit curse words contributes to the realistic depiction of high school dialogue and intense situations.
Scary & Intense Content
As a young adult thriller, 'One of Us Is Next' contains significant scary and intense content. The plot is driven by a deadly 'Truth or Dare' game that creates a pervasive atmosphere of suspense, fear, and psychological tension. This includes threatening messages, dangerous dares, and the ultimate death of a student, ensuring a consistently high level of drama and urgency.
Would these 3 concerns matter to your family?
Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.
Additional Context
Best For Ages
One of Us Is Next is recommended for readers aged 14 and up, or those in grades 9 and up. This recommendation is supported by the mature themes present, including violence, sexual content, frequent profanity, and substance use, which are handled in a manner generally considered appropriate for young adult audiences capable of processing complex, intense plots and character struggles.
Good to Know
While 'One of Us Is Next' can be read as a standalone, its enjoyment and full understanding are enhanced by prior reading of 'One of Us Is Lying' due to returning characters and ongoing plotlines. The television adaptation of 'One of Us Is Lying' has diverged from the book series, so content and character relationships in the show may not reflect those in the book.
What are you reading next?
Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.
No credit card required — join hundreds of families