Old School
Old School is the tenth installment in Jeff Kinney's highly successful Diary of a Wimpy Kid series, which follows the humorous and often challenging life of middle schooler Greg Heffley. In this book, Greg's town decides to unplug from modern technology, leading to a series of adjustments and Greg's reluctant participation in a rustic, old-fashioned farm camp. The narrative, told through Greg's diary entries and simple line drawings, explores themes of adapting to change, navigating family relationships, and the social dynamics of adolescence without electronics. Aimed at a middle-grade audience, typically ages 8 to 12, the book offers a relatable and comical look at everyday experiences and the trials of growing up. The content generally aligns with age-appropriate children's literature, but Christian parents may wish to consider specific elements further.
Concerns
Disrespect & Rebellion
HighDisrespect and rebellion are prominent and recurring themes throughout the book and series. Greg Heffley frequently displays a cynical, manipulative, and disobedient attitude towards authority figures and family members, often seeking to avoid responsibility or manipulate situations to his advantage.
Greg attempts to shift blame onto a teenager doing community service after an incident involving his car. Greg routinely demonstrates a disrespectful attitude towards his parents and school, with common parental feedback noting concerns about children 'disrespectful to their parents' in the series. For his trip to Hardscrabble Farms, Greg intentionally disobeys packing instructions by discarding his raincoat and instead packing 'three packs of Freshies' (implied junk food/wipes), prioritizing his comfort over rules.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumWhile the canonical 'Old School' book and the 'Diary of a Wimpy Kid' series do not feature explicit LGBTQ+ characters or storylines, fan communities extensively explore and create fanfiction with prominent gay, lesbian, and transgender themes involving main characters such as Greg and Rodrick. Within the canon, there are subtle hints and interpretations by some readers, along with discussions of gender stereotypes.
Fanfiction explicitly portrays characters like Rodrick as gay with a boyfriend, leading to a father's furious reaction. In another fanfiction, Greg Heffley expresses 'I love you' to his best friend Rowley, saying 'I don't know if I'm bi, or what, but I love you'. Additionally, Greg's mother walks in on Greg and Rowley in their underwear, and later tells Greg it's 'normal for boys to explore,' which some interpret as a subtle nod to exploring sexuality. The series has also been noted for portraying gender stereotypes, such as Greg being called a 'sissy' for having a diary.
Violence
MediumThe book and series contain mild, cartoonish, and slapstick violence, with occasional instances of slightly more explicit physical harm, though not graphically depicted. Threats of violence are also present.
During a 'Trust Fall' exercise at Hardscrabble Farms, Jeffrey Swanson's fall causes Rowley and Gareth Grimes to crash into each other, resulting in Gareth's tooth getting lodged in Rowley's forehead, necessitating a doctor or dentist visit. Grandpa recounts that he and Greg's father, Frank, would bury weapons for self-defense as children, and Frank once 'poked Giles in the butt with a spork' during an argument about their effectiveness.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumRomance and sexual content are minimal and generally age-appropriate, primarily focusing on crushes, mild flirtation, and vague suggestions of exploration, rather than explicit details or sexual acts.
Grandpa, having broken up with Darlene, engages in online dating and dates 'fifty women'. Greg expresses a desire for 'love advice' and wished his mother had volunteered as a female chaperone. In the broader series, Greg has been depicted wanting to sit between 'hot girls' in his classes, and a movie adaptation includes a scene where Greg's older brother has a magazine with a bikini-clad woman showing 'a lot of cleavage'.
Substance Use
MediumSubstance use is briefly implied and not depicted explicitly or in a detailed manner. There are minor instances that suggest alcohol consumption without focusing on intoxication.
Rodrick, while working as the mascot 'Old-Timey Tobias,' is noted to 'drink through his costume's left eye,' implying consumption of alcohol while in costume. Another instance mentions Rodrick shivering in his bed for two days after a trip to Hardscrabble Farms, which some readers could infer might relate to an unpleasant experience possibly involving peer pressure or substance exposure, though not explicitly stated as such.
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe book contains moderately intense content, mainly revolving around an urban legend and depicted comedic or suspenseful mishaps. These elements are designed to be frightening for young characters but are not overly graphic or deeply disturbing for the target audience.
The legend of 'Silas Scratch' creates an intense atmosphere at Hardscrabble Farms, with campers holding signs to 'BEWARE OF SILAS SCRATCH'. Greg recounts that his older brother Rodrick was so traumatized by his own trip to Hardscrabble Farms that he 'stayed in bed for two days afterward,' implying a significant frightening experience. Greg also experiences an intense situation when he accidentally causes his car to swerve into a ditch with Grandpa in the passenger seat, leading to significant trouble with his parents.
Profanity
LowThe book and series contain mild coarse language, primarily in the form of name-calling and put-downs rather than strong expletives. This is consistent with middle-grade content.
Common instances of coarse language include name-calling such as 'shrimp,' 'runt,' 'weirdo,' 'nerd,' 'moron,' 'jerk,' and 'idiot'. Parental reviews for the broader series also note the presence of 'some coarse language and put-downs'.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThe book features a local urban legend, 'Silas Scratch,' which is used to create suspense and scare characters, but it is explicitly revealed to be a fictional story rather than actual witchcraft, occult practices, or supernatural occurrences.
Campers at Hardscrabble Farms are warned to 'BEWARE OF SILAS SCRATCH,' a farmer who supposedly lived there before being kicked off his land. However, it is later revealed that Greg's father, Frank, invented the Silas Scratch story to keep people away from a secluded hut he used for himself.
Anti-Christian Themes
LowNo explicit anti-Christian themes, mockery of Christian beliefs, or sacrilegious acts were found within the content analysis for 'Old School' or the 'Diary of a Wimpy Kid' series. The books primarily focus on secular themes of childhood and family life.
There is an absence of direct references to Christian practices, symbols, or characters that are depicted in a negative or disrespectful light. The narrative maintains a neutral stance on religion, focusing instead on everyday life and humorous situations of a middle schooler.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
8+ years old. This recommendation is based on the book's target audience of middle-grade readers and its exploration of themes like family dynamics, friendship, and school life through humor and cartoon-style illustrations. While it contains mild instances of disrespect, light cartoonish violence, and subtle references to romance and substance use, these are presented in an age-appropriate context suitable for children entering pre-adolescence.
Additional Notes
Parents should note that while the official 'Diary of a Wimpy Kid' series, including 'Old School,' maintains a generally mild content profile, the protagonist Greg Heffley often exhibits morally ambiguous behaviors, including selfishness, manipulation, and a cynical worldview. These traits can provide opportunities for discussion with children about character choices and values. The widespread fanfiction community also explores mature themes, including LGBTQ+ content, which is separate from the canonical books but reflects engagement with the characters and world.
Related Reviews
Is Old School right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required