From Blood and Ash
From Blood and Ash is the first installment in Jennifer L. Armentrout's popular New Adult fantasy romance series. It introduces readers to Poppy, a young woman chosen from birth to be the 'Maiden,' a figure of purity and solitude whose life is strictly controlled in preparation for her Ascension. The narrative follows Poppy's clandestine desire for freedom and her forbidden connection with Hawke, her enigmatic personal guard. The series is set in a world grappling with ancient deities, rising kingdoms, and dark creatures, as Poppy uncovers secrets about her world and her own destiny. The book blends action, mystery, and a passionate, slow-burn romance, targeting an adult audience due to its mature themes and explicit content.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains high levels of graphic violence, including explicit depictions of physical attacks, gore, torture, and murder. Combat scenes are frequent and brutal, involving various forms of injury and death.
Trigger warnings explicitly list 'Assault,' 'Blood,' 'Bones,' 'Death,' 'Decapitation,' 'Gore,' 'Murder,' 'Physical Abuse,' 'Torture,' and 'Violence.' The narrative includes graphic descriptions of dead bodies and scenes of whipping/flogging.
Romance and Sexual Content
HighThis book features extensive and graphic sexual content, including multiple explicit sex scenes and suggestive language. The romance is central to the plot, with a significant focus on physical intimacy and Poppy's exploration of her sexuality.
The book 'starts off with a steamy scene and dives into a story that is brutal and sucks you in,' featuring 'spicy scenes' and 'multiple graphic sex scenes.' Hawke, a main character, engages in a sexual relationship with Poppy, an 18-year-old virgin, before she is aware of his true, considerably older age, raising concerns about power dynamics.
Profanity
HighThe book includes frequent strong language and profanity throughout the narrative and dialogue. This contributes to the mature tone of the text.
Profanity is listed as a trigger warning. A character is explicitly referred to as 'a fucking asshole.' Additionally, the use of modern colloquialisms like 'freaking' and 'totally' by characters such as Poppy can be distracting and contribute to a more casual, sometimes defiant, tone.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book contains intensely scary and disturbing content, characterized by graphic violence, sexual assault, psychological abuse, and pervasive themes of danger and fear. The narrative aims to create a brutal and suspenseful atmosphere.
Trigger warnings list 'Sexual assault (on-page),' 'Physical, psychological & emotional abuse, including gaslighting,' and 'Torture.' The story is described as 'brutal' and contains 'extremely heavy scenes' relating to sexual assault and abuse. Additionally, creatures called 'Barrats' are depicted as 'the thing of nightmares,' adding to the frightening elements.
Witchcraft & Occult
MediumThe narrative is steeped in a fantasy world with supernatural elements, including a system of 'gods,' unique beings like 'Craven,' 'Wolven,' and 'Vamprys,' and a central ritualistic event known as the 'Ascension.' These elements form the core of the world-building and magic system.
The central premise revolves around Poppy's role as the Maiden, chosen to 'usher in a new era' through an 'Ascension' ritual to the 'gods.' The world also features various supernatural races and creatures, such as the 'Wolven' and 'Vamprys,' whose existence and powers are integral to the plot.
Substance Use
MediumThe book features instances of alcohol consumption and references to recreational drug use within its mature fantasy setting. These occurrences are present in social contexts and as part of the characters' world.
Trigger warnings include 'Alcohol consumption' and 'Recreational drug use.' In the very first chapter, protagonist Poppy visits a 'house of ill repute' where 'drinking, card games, and… other things' are taking place, illustrating early exposure to such environments.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe protagonist, Poppy, frequently demonstrates defiance and rebellion against established authority and societal expectations. Despite being the 'Maiden' with strict rules, she actively seeks forbidden experiences and questions the system she is bound to.
Poppy, as the Maiden, is meant to be solitary and untouched, yet she 'follows exactly none of them' and is found in a 'house of ill repute' in the first chapter, defying her strictures. She is portrayed as having 'no faith and constantly questions everything' about her destiny and the 'gods.' Her personal guard, Hawke, encourages her to 'go and seize' forbidden experiences and embrace her sexuality, fostering rebellious behavior.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowThe first book, "From Blood and Ash," does not explicitly feature LGBTQ+ characters or themes in its canon content. While some fan discussions speculate on a main character's bisexuality in later series installments or the fluidity of cultural norms in the world, this is presented as fan interpretation rather than explicit representation within this specific book. The author has shown growth in avoiding past 'gay stereotypes' in previous works.
Discussion on Reddit suggests fans interpret Casteel's sexuality as bisexual based on broader cultural fluidity within the Wolven society (e.g., 'the joining' traditions), but this is explicitly stated as 'headcanon' and not canon in the first book. A review notes the author's prior works contained 'gay stereotypes,' suggesting an awareness of LGBTQ+ themes in her writing history, but does not confirm their presence in 'From Blood and Ash.'
Anti-Christian Themes
LowThe book is set in a fictional world with its own unique pantheon of 'gods' and a distinct religious/societal system centered around the 'Ascension.' The content does not directly mock, insult, or critique Christian beliefs or symbols. Any 'faith' discussed pertains to the fictional religion within the story.
The narrative focuses on a constructed belief system involving 'gods' and a ritual called the 'Ascension,' which is integral to the world-building, rather than engaging with real-world religions. Characters use exclamations like 'Oh gods!' as a common phrase within this fictional context. While 'faith' is mentioned in the story, it refers to belief in the established deities of the book's universe, not Christianity.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
18+ due to graphic sexual content, explicit violence and gore, pervasive profanity, and mature themes including sexual assault, torture, and substance use. While some suggest 16+ for mature readers, the intensity and frequency of the content push it into a strictly adult category, making it unsuitable for younger or more impressionable audiences.
Additional Notes
The series often features complex and morally grey characters, and the relationship dynamics between Poppy and Hawke can be perceived as toxic by some readers due to power imbalances and manipulative elements. The progression of the series is noted to introduce new and potentially more intense content in subsequent volumes.
Related Reviews
Is From Blood and Ash right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required