Eclipse
Eclipse, the third installment in Stephenie Meyer's popular Twilight Saga, continues the supernatural romance and conflict centered around human teenager Bella Swan and her relationships with vampire Edward Cullen and werewolf Jacob Black. Set primarily in Forks, Washington, the narrative unfolds amidst a series of mysterious killings in Seattle, revealing a vengeful vampire, Victoria, is building an army of newborn vampires to target Bella. The book delves into Bella's complex emotional dilemma as she is torn between her love for Edward and her deep friendship with Jacob, exploring themes of choice, consequence, and impending transformation into a vampire. It culminates in a climactic battle between the Cullen family, the Quileute werewolf pack, and Victoria's forces, forcing Bella to make definitive choices about her future and loyalties. The story is a young adult fantasy romance, blending elements of love, danger, and the paranormal, with a focus on intense relationships and personal sacrifice.
Concerns
Violence
HighThe book contains frequent and intense supernatural violence, including graphic descriptions of combat between vampires and werewolves, dismemberment, and severe injuries. A significant backstory involves implied sexual assault.
Vampires and werewolves engage in brutal battles where bodies are snapped, dismembered, and throats are torn out. Edward decapitates Victoria, then dismembers and burns her body parts to ensure her demise. Rosalie's human backstory details her being attacked, possibly gang-raped, and left for dead. Jasper recounts his past leading armies of newborn vampires on killing rampages.
Witchcraft & Occult
HighWitchcraft and occult themes are central to the narrative, revolving entirely around the existence and powers of vampires and werewolves (shape-shifters). These supernatural elements include unique abilities, tribal legends, and a mythology distinct from the human world.
The core plot is driven by vampires like Edward with powers such as mind-reading, and werewolves like Jacob and his pack who possess rapid healing and 'imprinting' abilities. The Quileute tribe's history includes 'spirit warriors' who used 'magic' to defend their land, highlighting the inherent supernatural elements of their heritage.
Scary & Intense Content
HighThe book contains frequent scary and intense elements, including a suspenseful atmosphere of danger from vengeful supernatural beings, psychological manipulation, and climactic battles with life-threatening situations.
Seattle is plagued by mysterious killings, creating a 'terrorized atmosphere' due to a newborn vampire army. Bella is in constant peril, pursued by the vengeful vampire Victoria. The emotional manipulation from both Edward (controlling behavior) and Jacob (forced kisses, guilt-tripping) creates significant psychological tension for Bella. The story culminates in a major battle against the newborn vampire army.
Disrespect & Rebellion
HighThe narrative frequently depicts instances of disrespect towards parental authority, significant emotional manipulation, and blatant disregard for personal boundaries within romantic relationships.
Bella frequently lies to her father, Charlie, through both direct falsehoods and omissions, to maintain her forbidden relationships. Edward exhibits controlling behavior, forbidding Bella from certain activities and even forging her college application without her consent. Jacob forcibly kisses Bella against her will and manipulates her emotionally, including threatening to get himself killed in battle to coerce her affection.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumExplicit LGBTQ+ content is absent within the book. However, fan community discussions contain speculative interpretations regarding the character of Leah Clearwater, pondering if her experiences or internal thoughts, such as dreaming of kissing Bella, might subtly hint at underlying gender identity or sexual orientation themes. These remain purely fan-driven interpretations and are not presented as canon within the narrative.
A Reddit discussion from a reader notes, 'I do wonder if Leah is having gender confusion. Even though that's not even what she was talking about. She was saying she couldn't stand to be in Jacob's head anymore and she dreamed about kissing Bella.' The commenter further speculates about 'SEXUALITY confusion' or 'gender confusion' for Leah, noting if such themes were intended by the author, they were poorly conveyed.
Romance and Sexual Content
MediumThe narrative is saturated with intense romantic tension, frequent urgent kissing, and suggestive situations. Bella expresses a desire for sexual intimacy with Edward, who insists on waiting until marriage, leading to scenes where Bella initiates physical contact that Edward prevents from escalating. The relationships are often portrayed with themes of possessiveness and unhealthy dynamics.
Edward and Bella engage in 'frequent and urgent' kissing. Bella attempts to unbutton shirts to escalate intimacy, but Edward stops her, adhering to his 'old fashioned' belief in waiting for marriage for sex. Jacob forcibly kisses Bella, causing her to break her hand, and later kisses her again after threatening to get himself killed in battle.
Profanity
MediumThe book includes a moderate number of mild to common expletives, generally described as minimal but present throughout the text.
Several dozen uses of mild curse words such as 'damn,' 'hell,' 'sucks,' 'screw,' 'crap,' and 'pissed' appear in the text. A Goodreads review also broadly mentions 'swearing' in the book.
Anti-Christian Themes
MediumWhile not explicitly anti-Christian, the book's central premise involves a supernatural world of vampires and werewolves that exists outside conventional Christian theology. A prominent character, Edward, voices a belief in damnation for vampires, reflecting a specific theological concern within the narrative.
Edward expresses the belief that all vampires are 'damned' and conveys concern for Bella's soul, which is a key reason for his reluctance to transform her into a vampire before marriage. The entire fictional universe is built upon supernatural beings and powers (vampirism, lycanthropy, psychic abilities) that are not aligned with or explained by traditional Christian doctrine.
Substance Use
LowSubstance use is minimal and incidental, primarily appearing as descriptive metaphors or brief mentions without active or graphic depiction of intoxication or addiction.
Edward describes the scent of Bella's blood to him as being 'like fine wine to an alcoholic'. Jacob mentions feeling 'a little stoned' after taking pain medicine provided by Dr. Cullen. Edward also jokes about pilots on Bella's plane being 'passed out drunk'.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Ages 14+ is recommended due to pervasive themes of intense, controlling romantic relationships, significant supernatural violence including dismemberment, frequent emotional manipulation, and discussions surrounding premarital intimacy and implied sexual assault in a character's backstory. While readable for younger ages, the complex and mature nature of these themes makes it more appropriate for older young adults capable of discerning healthy versus unhealthy relationship dynamics.
Additional Notes
Parents should be aware of the intense and sometimes unhealthy portrayals of romantic relationships, characterized by possessiveness, emotional manipulation, and a significant power imbalance. Bella's self-worth is often tied to her romantic interests, and her decisions frequently prioritize these relationships over her personal well-being, family, or future aspirations. The book's portrayal of 'love' should be discussed with young readers to differentiate it from healthy relationship models.
Related Reviews
Is Eclipse right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required