Aru Shah and the Song of Death
Aru Shah and the Song of Death is the second book in Roshani Chokshi's New York Times bestselling Pandava Quintet, a middle-grade fantasy adventure series published under the Rick Riordan Presents imprint. Spanning approximately 300-400 pages, the narrative continues the journey of twelve-year-old Aru Shah, a modern-day reincarnation of a Pandava warrior. The core of the story is deeply rooted in Hindu mythology, blending ancient Indian folklore with contemporary elements and pop culture references. The plot follows Aru, her soul-sister Mini, and new allies Brynne and Aiden, as they are tasked with recovering Kamadeva, the god of love's, stolen bow and arrow. This powerful artifact is being misused to transform individuals into 'heartless fighting-machine zombies,' and the protagonists must retrieve it within ten days to clear their names and prevent further chaos in the Otherworld.
Concerns
Witchcraft & Occult
HighThe book is entirely based on Hindu mythology, presenting a world where gods, goddesses, demons (asuras), and various mythical creatures are real. Magic, divine powers, enchanted objects, and spiritual abilities are fundamental to the characters and the plot, forming the primary fantasy framework.
The entire premise revolves around Hindu mythology, with characters like Aru and Mini being reincarnations of the Pandavas, children of Hindu deities, possessing divine gifts such as Aru's lightning bolt, Vudra, and Mini's dand stick, Dei. The quest to retrieve Kamadeva's (the god of love) stolen bow and arrow is central, involving interactions with various mythological figures and navigating realms such as the serpent realm. Antagonists include 'asuras,' described as 'demons in Hindu mythology,' whose magical abilities and dark intentions drive conflict.
Anti-Christian Themes
HighThe book is entirely immersed in Hindu mythology, portraying its gods, demons, and spiritual concepts as the foundational reality of the story's universe. This central focus on a polytheistic belief system and its associated practices could be viewed as conflicting with Christian monotheistic tenets, even without direct criticism or mockery of Christianity.
The entire plot and world-building are predicated on Hindu mythology, with characters being reincarnations of Pandavas and interacting directly with figures from the Hindu pantheon, such as Kamadeva and various asuras. The protagonists' powers and quests are derived from these Hindu divine connections and operate within the 'Otherworld' governed by these deities. The book explores moral complexities within this framework, stating that 'gods aren't all perfect' and 'villains in the myths are not pure evil,' which presents a worldview distinct from traditional Christian teachings.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
MediumThe book contains a brief, incidental mention of diverse family structures, explicitly including same-sex parents. This reference appears in a reflective thought by a character, acknowledging different family compositions without elaborating on specific LGBTQ characters or relationships within the main plot.
When contemplating Aiden's divorced parents, Aru Shah internally notes, 'Lots of kids at school had divorced parents, and not all families needed a dad and a mom to be whole. Some had two dads, or two moms, or just one parent, or no parent at all.' This is a direct acknowledgement of same-sex parent families. No other explicit LGBTQ romantic relationships or specific gender identity explorations are central to the narrative or characters mentioned in reviews.
Violence
MediumThe narrative features frequent fantasy violence, including battles with magical weapons against mythological beings and 'heartless fighting-machine zombies.' While described as 'action-packed,' the violence is generally not graphic, though mentions of 'blood' appear in trigger warnings for the series. Characters sustain injuries and face perilous, life-threatening situations.
The plot involves battles against 'heartless fighting-machine zombies' that the protagonists must fight. For instance, Aru and Mini battle a zombie dentist using Mini's dand stick and Aru's lightning bolt to physically subdue him. In an 'epic, multi-chapter battle scene' at the climax, Aiden is hit by an arrow, 'crumpled up on the ground,' and temporarily turned into one of the Heartless. Trigger warnings for the book specifically mention 'Fantasy Violence, Zombies, Blood, Physical assault, and animal attack.'
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe book contains moderately intense and scary elements typical of fantasy adventure, including encounters with 'fighting-machine zombies,' demons, and threatening mythical creatures. Characters face perilous situations and life-threatening quests, but the tone remains adventurous, not aiming for horror.
The protagonists frequently encounter and battle 'heartless fighting-machine zombies' that are created by the stolen bow and arrow. These encounters include physical confrontations in various settings, such as a supernatural super market. Characters face direct danger, such as Brynne being 'eaten' by a giant crab (from which she shapeshifts out), and Aru falling from a great height after a blast of wind, nearly losing consciousness.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe protagonist, Aru, is often characterized by her 'sass' and 'snarky' dialogue, which contributes to humor and character voice rather than outright malicious disrespect. The narrative also includes themes of questioning traditional mythological portrayals and challenging established patriarchal narratives, framed as critical thinking rather than simple defiance.
Aru Shah is described as a 'sassiest heroine ever' and her internal monologue is presented as 'the consciousness stream of a twelve-year-old, full of hyperbole and snark.' This indicates frequent use of witty or sarcastic remarks towards situations or potentially authority figures, fitting her age and personality. The story also 'calls B.S. on aspects of the patriarchy related to stories, myth, and religion' and addresses 'the problematic way women are treated in some of the mythological stories,' promoting a critical perspective on traditional narratives.
Romance and Sexual Content
LowRomantic content is minimal, consisting of 'little mentions of a crush' among the young protagonists, which is not a central plot element. There is no explicit sexual content, nudity, or suggestive language. A character's magical ability related to attraction is used for non-romantic purposes.
Reviews indicate 'little mentions of a crush' between characters, specifically between Aru and Aiden, but this romantic interest does not 'take over the story.' Aiden possesses an 'apsara' ability to 'smolder,' described as a hypnotic charm that makes him 'impossible to look away from,' which he uses to bypass a sage's waiting room rather than for romantic entanglement.
Profanity
LowNo specific instances of strong profanity or curse words were highlighted in available content reviews or trigger warnings. The language is generally described as witty and appropriate for a middle-grade audience.
The book is noted for its 'witty one-line quips, sarcastic comments' and Aru's 'snarky' voice, consistent with middle-grade fiction. There are no documented instances of explicit or strong profanity mentioned in critical reviews or parental guidance sources.
Substance Use
LowSubstance use is minimally referenced, with a general trigger warning for 'alcohol consumption mentioned.' No specific scenes of active alcohol consumption, drug use, or addiction are detailed as plot points or explicit depictions.
A trigger warning listed on Goodreads for 'Aru Shah and the Song of Death' includes 'alcohol consumption mentioned.' However, no further details or specific scenes describing characters consuming alcohol or drugs are provided in the available reviews, indicating it is a minor background element rather than a depicted act or theme.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Ages 9-13. This recommendation is based on the book's designation as middle-grade fiction, typically targeting readers in grades 3-7. The story features complex mythological concepts, fantasy violence involving mythical creatures and 'zombies' that, while not graphic, contribute to intense action sequences. Furthermore, it introduces diverse family structures and encourages critical thinking about traditional narratives, which is best suited for readers with developing comprehension and analytical skills. The themes are generally appropriate for this age range, offering adventure and moral lessons within a fantastical framework.
Additional Notes
Parents should be aware that while the book is a middle-grade fantasy, its comprehensive integration of Hindu mythology means that non-Christian religious concepts and practices are central to the story's fabric. The series is part of the 'Rick Riordan Presents' imprint, known for featuring diverse mythologies, and maintains a similar tone of adventure, humor, and mythological education.
Related Reviews
Is Aru Shah and the Song of Death right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required