Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret
Judy Blume's classic 1970 novel, "Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret," is a coming-of-age story centered on 11-year-old Margaret Simon as she navigates the complexities of puberty, friendship, and her search for religious identity. Moving to a new town, Margaret grapples with the physical and emotional changes of adolescence, including menstruation and her developing body, alongside social pressures from her new friends. The book explores Margaret's interfaith background (Christian mother, Jewish father) as she attempts to choose her own religious path. Intended for a middle-grade audience, the novel is widely praised for its frank and relatable portrayal of a young girl's experiences, often serving as an educational tool for discussions on maturing. The narrative follows Margaret's internal monologues and external experiences as she confronts the challenges of fitting in, understanding her changing body, and exploring different faiths to find what resonates with her. While light-hearted in tone, it addresses significant themes of self-discovery and family dynamics. The book's content, especially its open discussions about puberty and religion, has led to varying age recommendations and discussions among parents and educators regarding its suitability for younger readers.
Concerns
Romance and Sexual Content
HighThis is a central and frequent theme, featuring frank discussions and explorations of puberty, menstruation, breast development, and romantic/sexual curiosity among pre-teen girls. Content includes detailed peer conversations, looking at a pornographic magazine, and kissing games, all presented as part of Margaret's coming-of-age journey.
1. The girls form a 'secret club' where they compare breast sizes, discuss "feeling up" (sexually touching) regarding classmate Laura Danker, and chant about increasing their bust size. Margaret explicitly states she prays to God to increase her breast size. 2. Margaret and her friends look at Margaret's father's Playboy magazine, specifically the nude centerfold (not shown to the reader but discussed by the characters). Additionally, at a party, they play 'spin the bottle' and 'two minutes in the closet' where Margaret kisses a boy named Philip Leroy multiple times.
Anti-Christian Themes
HighReligion and Margaret's spiritual quest are central to the story. While Margaret explores various faiths, a notable Christian parental review perceives the narrative as presenting several anti-Christian messages, including the idea that Christianity is merely one path among many, that church services are incomprehensible, and that God is found outside traditional religious settings. It also critiques the portrayal of Margaret's parents as hostile towards religion and Margaret's prayers as selfish.
1. Margaret's Christian maternal grandparents disown her mother, Barbara, due to her interfaith marriage to Herb (Jewish), depicting religious intolerance and a negative aspect of devout Christianity. 2. Margaret visits a Jewish temple and a Christian church, commenting that they "really seemed the same to her." She frequently complains to God that she keeps trying to find Him but doesn't "see Him in any of these churches," which some Christian reviews interpret as devaluing organized worship and promoting a 'spiritual but not religious' viewpoint.
Profanity
MediumThe book contains some mild coarse language. These are occasional exclamations rather than pervasive or aggressive use of strong profanity.
1. Examples of mild coarse language include phrases such as "Oh My God." 2. Other instances include expressions like "What the hell" and "Jeez."
Scary & Intense Content
MediumThe content involves emotional intensity and anxiety common to the target age group, particularly around puberty, social acceptance, and personal identity. These moments reflect the internal struggles of an adolescent rather than horror or graphic scares.
1. Margaret experiences significant emotional distress and sadness due to being separated from her grandmother, with both characters shown crying. 2. Margaret feels intense inadequacy and anxiety about her physical development, particularly her lack of breast growth and delayed menstruation, comparing herself to her friends and praying for changes. She also feels scared and nervous when participating in the 'two minutes in the closet' kissing game.
Disrespect & Rebellion
MediumThe book features instances of both family conflict related to differing values and peer group dynamics that include elements of mild disrespect and social manipulation. Margaret's mother defied her parents' wishes regarding marriage, and Margaret experiences peer pressure and mild bullying.
1. Margaret's mother, Barbara, rebelled against her devout Christian parents by marrying Herb, who is Jewish, leading to her parents disowning her and a 14-year estrangement. 2. Nancy, Margaret's friend, exhibits manipulative behavior within their social circle, such as leading the girls in gossiping about Laura Danker and potentially ostracizing other students, creating a dynamic that challenges Margaret's sense of values.
LGBTQ & Gender Identity
LowThe book itself contains no explicit LGBTQ characters or plotlines within its narrative. While Judy Blume, the author, has publicly voiced strong support for the transgender and broader LGBTQIA+ communities, clarifying that her statements were taken out of context regarding J.K. Rowling, this stance is external to the book's content. One reviewer, identifying as queer and nonbinary, related to the book's themes of not belonging and questioning gender roles, but this is a personal interpretation rather than explicit content in the text.
1. There are no named LGBTQ characters or explicit discussions of sexual orientation or gender identity within the narrative of "Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret." 2. Author Judy Blume clarified her support for the trans community and LGBTQIA+ people, stating, "I wholly support the trans community... I stand with the trans community and vehemently disagree with anyone who does not fully support equality and acceptance for LGBTQIA+ people."
Violence
LowInstances of violence are minimal and very mild, primarily consisting of commonplace childhood roughhousing or minor accidents without graphic detail or intent to harm. These actions are not central to the plot and do not involve significant injury.
1. Nancy's brother throws a ball at her head, resulting in no serious injury. 2. Margaret's father, Herb, cuts his hand on the lawn mower, a minor household accident.
Witchcraft & Occult
LowThere is no content related to witchcraft, sorcery, occult practices, magic rituals, demons, spells, or supernatural elements in the book. The narrative is grounded in realistic, contemporary coming-of-age experiences.
1. The story focuses on the realistic anxieties and explorations of an 11-year-old girl regarding puberty, friendships, and religious identity, without incorporating any magical or supernatural elements. 2. Characters engage in everyday activities and face relatable challenges, with no mention or depiction of occult symbols, rituals, or paranormal occurrences.
Substance Use
LowSubstance use is present but very infrequent and mild, limited to incidental social drinking by adults. It is not depicted as a problem or central to the plot.
1. There is a brief mention of adults drinking wine at dinner. 2. No characters engage in illegal drug use or excessive alcohol consumption; the focus is on the children's experiences rather than adult habits.
Other Notes
Target Demographic
Ages 10-12, with parental guidance for younger readers due to mature themes. While some outlets suggest ages 9-12 for reading, explicit discussions around puberty, sex, and religion are best navigated with an adult, especially for children under 10. Common Sense Media has rated it suitable for age 11, with a 'green light' only for readers 14+ for full comprehension of sensitive topics like menstruation, bras, kissing, and emerging sexuality.
Additional Notes
The book's themes of puberty and religious exploration are timeless and often serve as a catalyst for important parent-child discussions. It is frequently challenged or banned due to its frankness regarding these topics. Parents should be prepared to discuss issues of body image, menstruation, early sexual curiosity, and diverse religious perspectives. The movie adaptation (2023) is noted to stay very true to the original book's spirit and content, so concerns largely apply to both.
Related Reviews
Is Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret right for your family?
These concerns are a starting point — what many Christian parents care about. Want to screen for other themes? Define your own concerns.
Screen any book, movie, or show — even titles no one else has reviewed.
“StoryScanner gives us clarity and confidence. It's become our go-to for checking books at the library and movies on family night.”
— Cristi & Brian, Dallas TX
“StoryScanner has been such a BLESSING for researching books for our children. You can set filters for your concerns, enter a book title, and it lets you know what's present.”
— Christian Book Reviews for Families (Facebook)
No credit card required