Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret
Here's what we found in Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. Every family is different — get a report that reflects yours.
Screen for YOUR familyParent's Guide to Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret
Judy Blume's classic 1970 novel, "Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret," is a coming-of-age story centered on 11-year-old Margaret Simon as she navigates the complexities of puberty, friendship, and her search for religious identity. Moving to a new town, Margaret grapples with the physical and emotional changes of adolescence, including menstruation and her developing body, alongside social pressures from her new friends. The book explores Margaret's interfaith background (Christian mother, Jewish father) as she attempts to choose her own religious path. Intended for a middle-grade audience, the novel is widely praised for its frank and relatable portrayal of a young girl's experiences, often serving as an educational tool for discussions on maturing. The narrative follows Margaret's internal monologues and external experiences as she confronts the challenges of fitting in, understanding her changing body, and exploring different faiths to find what resonates with her. While light-hearted in tone, it addresses significant themes of self-discovery and family dynamics. The book's content, especially its open discussions about puberty and religion, has led to varying age recommendations and discussions among parents and educators regarding its suitability for younger readers.
Things to Consider
Romance and Sexual Content
This is a central and frequent theme, featuring frank discussions and explorations of puberty, menstruation, breast development, and romantic/sexual curiosity among pre-teen girls. Content includes detailed peer conversations, looking at a pornographic magazine, and kissing games, all presented as part of Margaret's coming-of-age journey.
1. The girls form a 'secret club' where they compare breast sizes, discuss "feeling up" (sexually touching) regarding classmate Laura Danker, and chant about increasing their bust size. Margaret explicitly states she prays to God to increase her breast size. 2. Margaret and her friends look at Margaret's father's Playboy magazine, specifically the nude centerfold (not shown to the reader but discussed by the characters). Additionally, at a party, they play 'spin the bottle' and 'two minutes in the closet' where Margaret kisses a boy named Philip Leroy multiple times.
Anti-Christian Themes
Religion and Margaret's spiritual quest are central to the story. While Margaret explores various faiths, a notable Christian parental review perceives the narrative as presenting several anti-Christian messages, including the idea that Christianity is merely one path among many, that church services are incomprehensible, and that God is found outside traditional religious settings. It also critiques the portrayal of Margaret's parents as hostile towards religion and Margaret's prayers as selfish.
Would these 2 concerns matter to your family?
Get a report based on your values — not generic ratings.
Additional Context
Best For Ages
Ages 10-12, with parental guidance for younger readers due to mature themes. While some outlets suggest ages 9-12 for reading, explicit discussions around puberty, sex, and religion are best navigated with an adult, especially for children under 10. Common Sense Media has rated it suitable for age 11, with a 'green light' only for readers 14+ for full comprehension of sensitive topics like menstruation, bras, kissing, and emerging sexuality.
Good to Know
The book's themes of puberty and religious exploration are timeless and often serve as a catalyst for important parent-child discussions. It is frequently challenged or banned due to its frankness regarding these topics. Parents should be prepared to discuss issues of body image, menstruation, early sexual curiosity, and diverse religious perspectives. The movie adaptation (2023) is noted to stay very true to the original book's spirit and content, so concerns largely apply to both.
What are you reading next?
Screen any title in seconds — even ones no one else has reviewed.
No credit card required — join hundreds of families